The relationship between a father and his daughter is a well explored concept in Charles Dickens' novel "Dombey and Son". Various critics have suggested that the protagonists daughter, Florence, should be interpreted as a meek and feeble damsel in distress, tortured by her father’s inability to love her. Florence’s refusal to stand up to her father and unending quest for his love are represented as weaknesses that deem her a “fairy-tale princess”. Is it possible, then, to reverse the lens and consider Florence an emblem of strength? Or does her father's abuse diminish her capacity as a nineteenth century heroine?
This essay offers a character analysis on the basis of the text.
Table of Contents
The document does not contain a table of contents or chapter headings.
Aim and Themes
This essay examines how Florence Dombey’s relationship with her father in Charles Dickens’ Dombey and Son can be read as evidence of internal strength rather than weakness. It asks how literary criticism and concepts associated with abusive relationships can inform an interpretation of her character.
- Florence’s relationship with Mr. Dombey
- Family, inheritance, and business
- Gender, power, and emotional abuse
- Critical interpretations of Florence’s character
- Abusive relationship dynamics and survival
- Love and female agency in the novel
Excerpt from the Book
The Fire in Florence
Critic A. E. Dyson suggests that Florence has an “‘obsessive need to be loved’” (Zwinger 432) that could not be adequately satisfied. This suggestion perpetuates the notion that Florence is a submissive and selfless “fairy-tale princess” eager to obtain a virtually unattainable entity. Florence’s ability to remain a top priority for her father demonstrates that she is powerful enough to propagate emotion from the single person who’s grandest wish would be to relinquish any sentiment and knowledge of her. Critics Gottman and Jacobson reveal a multitude of myths regarding battered women in the homes of their abusers; women who are perhaps similar to Florence. “Myth #8” states “Women Who Stay in Abusive Relationships Must Be Crazy.” As their research shows, there is a multitude of reasons that women remain under abusive household reign; among them are fear, financial stability, low self-esteem, and emotional effects similar to Post-Traumatic-Stress-Disorder (PTSD). It is crucial to note that these women are not in any way weak in their own right, but rather their abuser’s constant battering weakens them. It is not an abused woman’s obsession to be loved by her abuser, but rather the emotional (and usually physical) effects the perpetrator imprints on the victim, which create a relational dependency on the abuser.
Jacobson and Gottman suggest the existence of a relationship dynamic known as the “cobra relationship” in which husbands or spouses “taunt their wives by pushing them away” but want them to be there when they need something from them such as “sex, companionship, or money” (Gottman 84). Florence and her father’s bond is much like this cobra relationship as Dombey makes every effort to push Florence away by refusing to accept her as a member of the business, and thus a member of the family, due to her gender. As an ultimate portrayal of pushing her away, Mr. Dombey does not acknowledge Florence as a sibling to Paul, even after Paul’s death. In fact, he requests that Paul’s tombstone read “‘beloved and only child’” (Dickens 268) and only acknowledges the impropriety of this request after the mason corrected that the stone should read “only son.” In a cobra relationship, there is a level of dependence that the spouse has on his wife. In the interactions between Florence and Mr. Dombey, there is no defined necessity Mr. Dombey retains for Florence; however, in terms where he wishes to seek reconciliation and redemption, he immediately turns to his daughter. Additionally, when coping with the death of his son, Mr. Dombey shifts the blame towards Florence in an effort to understand the reasons behind the loss of his heir. In doing so, he fictionalizes a competition between the siblings, which has delivered a clear winner. Recognizing the extreme emotional tribulations enveloped in a cobra relationship, and seeing that this type of union represents Mr. Dombey and Florence’s relationship causes the reader to acknowledge that regarding Florence as obsessive and angelic is equivalent to blaming any victim of domestic violence for his/her situation. Thus, Florence’s ability to withstand such abuse and prevail by retaliating against “Dombey’s cruelty and rejection of her by attempting to alter or eradicate her image of him” (Yelin 308) makes Florence an independent leader.
Chapter Summary
The essay has no separate chapters. It develops an interpretation of Florence through close readings of her relationship with her father, comparisons with literary criticism, and discussion of abusive relationship dynamics.
Keywords
Charles Dickens, Dombey and Son, Florence Dombey, Mr. Dombey, literary criticism, father-daughter relationships, emotional abuse, female agency, gender, family and business, inheritance, cobra relationship, Victorian literature
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It examines Florence Dombey’s character and her relationship with her father in Charles Dickens’ Dombey and Son.
What are its central themes?
The essay considers gender, family and business, inheritance, emotional abuse, love, and female agency.
What is the essay’s main question?
It asks how Florence can be interpreted as internally strong rather than merely submissive or dependent.
What method does the author use?
The author offers a literary interpretation of the novel, drawing on textual passages, published criticism, and concepts from research on abusive relationships.
What does the main discussion cover?
It explores Mr. Dombey’s hostility, Florence’s relationships with family members, critical accounts of her character, and parallels with abusive relationship dynamics.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include Florence Dombey, emotional abuse, father-daughter relationships, female agency, inheritance, and Victorian literature.
How does the essay use the idea of a cobra relationship?
It compares a dynamic described by Jacobson and Gottman with Mr. Dombey’s treatment of Florence, while acknowledging differences between spousal and parent-child relationships.
What role does Edith play in the discussion?
The essay considers Florence and Edith’s alliance and discusses how their capacity for change affects Mr. Dombey’s sense of control.
- Quote paper
- Charlotte Ljustina (Author), 2013, Florence’s Internal Strength and Power in Charles Dickens’ "Dombey and Son", Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/307718