Criminology is not a typical law discipline. It can be referred to as an interdisciplinary subject
dealing a lot with sociology, psychology, statistics, medicine, economics, political science and
geography. It is concerned with a body of knowledge about crime as a social phenomenon. A
broad definition would be that crime is behaviour that breaks the law. The studies of crime are
supposed to include in their scope describing, analysing and explaining the behaviour of state penal
law. This seems to make criminology a rather analytical subject. But is it therefore really valuefree
and, if not, should or can it ever be? If we speak of values, we mean emotional attitudes in a
subjective way of seeing things as well as moral values. This examination shall basically be focused
on the influence of emotional attitudes and if criminology can be free from opinions and
subjective views. In some way this is the personal reflection of moral values, too. Specifying the
question it should be asked if criminology is or can be practised and used in an objective and
neutral way.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. The Nature of Criminology as a (Legal) Science
2.1 Criminology as a Statistical Science
2.2 Criminology as a Current Affair
2.3 Criminology as a Political Device
2.3.1 Philosophical and Theoretical Approachments
2.3.2 Criminology in British Politics
3. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This essay asks whether criminology can be practised and used objectively and neutrally, examining the influence of emotional attitudes, subjective opinions and political interests on the discipline.
- Criminology as an interdisciplinary science
- Statistical evidence and its uses
- Media representation and public perceptions of crime
- Political uses of criminological knowledge
- Moral values and criminological theory
- Law and order in British politics
Excerpt from the Book
2.3.2 Criminology in British Politics
Crime affects everyone, whether directly or indirectly, according to a Home Office survey. We have all either been victims ourselves, or personally know of someone who has. Consequently, politicians have traditionally sought to tap into public anxiety about crime as a means of gaining or retaining electoral support.
However, the Conservatives' traditional dominance of the law and order agenda has come under severe pressure, and the former opposition claimed that the government had failed to bring crime under control. After almost 18 years in opposition, the Labour party had recognised the importance and talked about getting "tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime". As a result, law and order issues occupy a centre stage in the election campaign. Traditionally the Conservative Party was the party that emphasised its "Law and Order" policy. When using it for their political campaign for their 1979 successful election it was capitalised on traditional Conservative strengths and Labour weaknesses. During the 1970s and 1980s, a period when the public concern about crime was growing, the Conservatives underlined their commitment to the rule of law. Nowadays the Labour Party has changed its appearance calling itself New Labour and wishes to be seen as the party that is the real party of law and order. However, the electorate voted for them. This is of course not the only topic that politics were concerned with. Still it shows how important the "Law and Order"-issue was. It made criminology politically become a very important discipline. The negative feature of political-activist criminology is that political goals can override the search for the truth.
Amid an array of new legislation intended to show off the government’s tough stance on crime, two issues stand out as especially important, and their effects will be hotly debated between now and the election: public order and sentencing policy. And that is where criminology comes into play.
The centrepiece of Conservative public order law, and one of the most wide-ranging pieces of legislation to be brought into existence during the last parliament, was the highly controversial 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act. This Act has been widely criticised by civil liberties groups and legal monitoring organisations for effectively criminalising large sections of the population. Among those most badly affected by the act have been squatters, direct action campaign groups, ravers and even football fans. It was followed by the 1997 Police Bill. This bill, which gives the police entirely new powers of surveillance, has been similarly criticised.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The essay introduces criminology as an interdisciplinary field and frames the question of whether it can be objective and free of subjective attitudes.
2. The Nature of Criminology as a (Legal) Science: The main chapter considers statistics, media representations and political uses of criminology. It also discusses theoretical perspectives and British law-and-order politics.
3. Conclusion: The conclusion revisits the tension between scientific objectivity and the moral and political influences that shape criminological research.
Keywords
criminology, value neutrality, objectivity, crime statistics, media, public opinion, political influence, moral values, social control, law and order, British politics, sentencing policy
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the essay about?
It examines whether criminology can be a value-free discipline.
What are its central themes?
The essay considers objectivity, crime statistics, media influence, moral values and the political uses of criminology.
What is the primary research question?
It asks whether criminology can be practised and used objectively and neutrally, without subjective opinions and emotional attitudes.
What research method is used?
The essay uses a conceptual discussion supported by published criminological sources and examples from British politics.
What does the main chapter cover?
It discusses criminology as a statistical science, its representation in current affairs, and its use as a political device, including theoretical perspectives and British politics.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include criminology, value neutrality, objectivity, crime statistics, media, moral values and law and order.
How does the essay discuss the role of crime statistics?
It distinguishes between statistics as measurements and the ways they are presented and used in public debate.
Which British political issues does the essay examine?
It considers law-and-order campaigning, public order legislation, prisons and sentencing policy, including the 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act and the 1997 Police Bill.
- Quote paper
- Dr. Timo Hohmuth (Author), 2000, Can Criminology ever be a value-free discipline?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/31317