‘Desire’, ‘Pleasure’, ‘Passion’ ‘Wish’ or ‘Sex’: by whatever name ‘Eros’ is addressed, it has always been reckoned as a stumbling block in the perennial human quest to attain ‘Moksha’. Sigmund Freud, the ‘Copernicus of Psychology’ put forth the concept of ‘Eros’ and ‘Thanatos’ and posited that one’s life is structured by a rhythmic conflict between ‘Eros’ or life instinct and ‘Thanatos’ or death instinct.
‘Eros’ leads to procreation and persistently constructs a detour for an individual to reach his/ her ultimate goal i.e. death while ‘Thanatos’ chases self-destruction. The confrontation between these two instincts comes into being simultaneously with the birth of an individual. However, since time immemorial a futile attempt has been made to avert this conflict through the proliferation of multifarious endeavors such as by renouncing pleasure, through eschewing of desire and by practicing rigorous self-discipline.
This article seeks to explore how ‘Eros’ in the form of Narannapa’s demonic ways and ‘Thanatos’ through Praneshacharya’s penance has been symbolized in U.R. Ananthamurthy’s Samskara. The article will further analyze that in the tug between Praneshacharya and Narannapa’s modus vivendi neither asceticism nor eroticism emerges as an exclusive winner.
Inhaltsverzeichnis (Table of Contents)
- Abstract
- Introduction
- The Tug between Eros and Thanatos
- The Transmutation of Praneshacharya
- The Bequest of Naranappa's Modus Operandi
Zielsetzung und Themenschwerpunkte (Objectives and Key Themes)
This article explores the interplay of Eros and Thanatos in U.R. Ananthamurthy's Samskara, examining how the characters of Naranappa and Praneshacharya represent opposing life approaches. It analyzes the consequences of suppressing natural desires and the transformative power of experiencing them. The article does not conclude with a definitive answer on which approach prevails but rather investigates the complexities inherent in this conflict.
- The conflict between Eros (life instinct) and Thanatos (death instinct)
- The consequences of suppressing natural desires
- The portrayal of asceticism and hedonism in Samskara
- The transformative power of experience
- The critique of orthodox Brahmanism
Zusammenfassung der Kapitel (Chapter Summaries)
Abstract: This abstract introduces the central theme of the conflict between Eros and Thanatos, using Freud's concepts as a framework. It outlines the article's aim to explore how these opposing forces are symbolized in Samskara through the characters of Naranappa and Praneshacharya, highlighting that neither asceticism nor eroticism emerges as a sole victor.
Introduction: This chapter introduces U.R. Ananthamurthy and his novel Samskara, published in 1965 and translated into English in 1976. It establishes the novel's satirical critique of orthodox Brahmanism, focusing on the central conflict of whether Naranappa, a dissident, can receive a Vedic funeral, setting the stage for the exploration of the central themes of Eros and Thanatos.
The Tug between Eros and Thanatos: This section contrasts the ascetic life of Praneshacharya, who represses his desires, with the hedonistic lifestyle of Naranappa, who embraces them fully. It highlights the irony of Praneshacharya's ignorance about the inevitability of the life instinct, and how Naranappa serves as a catalyst, exposing Praneshacharya's repressed desires. The chapter lays the groundwork for the analysis of the consequences of suppressing natural instincts.
The Transmutation of Praneshacharya: This chapter details Praneshacharya's transformation after his sexual encounter with Chandri. His experience shatters his ascetic worldview, leading him to question his previous beliefs and embrace sensual experience. The chapter explores Praneshacharya's internal conflict and the profound impact of Eros on his spiritual journey, showing a shift from rigid asceticism towards a more nuanced understanding of life's complexities.
Schlüsselwörter (Keywords)
Eros, Thanatos, asceticism, hedonism, desire, repression, transformation, Samskara, U.R. Ananthamurthy, Brahmanism, spiritual catharsis, celibacy, liberation.
Frequently Asked Questions: A Deep Dive into Samskara
What is the main focus of this academic preview of Samskara?
This preview provides a structured overview of U.R. Ananthamurthy's Samskara, focusing on the interplay between Eros (life instinct) and Thanatos (death instinct) as represented by the novel's central characters, Naranappa and Praneshacharya. It analyzes the consequences of suppressing natural desires and the transformative power of experiencing them. The preview includes a table of contents, chapter summaries, objectives, key themes, and keywords.
What are the key themes explored in Samskara according to this preview?
The key themes revolve around the central conflict between Eros and Thanatos. The preview examines the consequences of suppressing natural desires (as seen in Praneshacharya's ascetic lifestyle), the portrayal of asceticism and hedonism, the transformative power of experience (particularly Praneshacharya's transformation), and a critique of orthodox Brahmanism. The article does not offer a definitive answer on which approach (asceticism or hedonism) prevails, but rather explores the complexities of this conflict.
How are the characters of Naranappa and Praneshacharya depicted in relation to Eros and Thanatos?
Naranappa represents the embrace of Eros – the life instinct – living a hedonistic lifestyle. Praneshacharya embodies Thanatos – the death instinct – through his strict ascetic life and repression of desires. Their contrasting approaches highlight the central conflict of the novel, and the eventual transformation of Praneshacharya through sensual experience serves as a key element of the narrative.
What is the significance of Praneshacharya's transformation?
Praneshacharya's transformation after his encounter with Chandri is a pivotal moment. This experience shatters his ascetic worldview, forcing him to confront his repressed desires and leading to a profound shift in his understanding of life's complexities. It represents the transformative power of experience and challenges the rigidity of his previously held beliefs.
What is the role of orthodox Brahmanism in Samskara?
The novel offers a satirical critique of orthodox Brahmanism, particularly through the central conflict regarding Naranappa's right to a Vedic funeral. This critique serves as a backdrop for the exploration of Eros and Thanatos, highlighting the potential limitations and hypocrisies within the traditional Brahmanical system.
What are the main chapters covered in the preview?
The preview summarizes the Abstract, Introduction, "The Tug between Eros and Thanatos," "The Transmutation of Praneshacharya," and includes a list of keywords to further enhance comprehension.
What are the keywords associated with this analysis of Samskara?
Keywords include: Eros, Thanatos, asceticism, hedonism, desire, repression, transformation, Samskara, U.R. Ananthamurthy, Brahmanism, spiritual catharsis, celibacy, and liberation. These terms encapsulate the central themes and concepts explored in the novel and the preview.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Preeti Puri (Autor:in), 2016, Narannapa’s demonic ways and Praneshacharya’s penance. Eros and Thanatos in "Samskara" by U.R. Ananthamurthy, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/316670
