"Joothan: A Dalit's Life" by Omprakash Valmiki. A Book Review


Literature Review, 2016
6 Pages, Grade: 8

Excerpt

INTRODUCTION

After the independence of India, the political leaders of our nation had attempted to eradicate the ominous practice of untouchability through various sanctions in government laws and policies, the validation of its dismantled state was further cemented by the Constitution of India which came into power in 1950. However the scope of removal of untouchability remained limited only to be put pen to paper. That is to say, legal changes were made within political framework, but mindsets of larger population were infected with germ of obnoxious caste system. Caste system of India has allotted the untouchables to lowest echelon of society. This segregated class of people has remained downtrodden and is forbidden by the so called upper castes of society to climb up the social ladder and settle themselves down at a better place in society. Labelling them as the depressed class, scheduled class by constitution or addressing them as Harijans by Gandhi failed to confine the anguished state of mind of those people caused by the abhorrence meted out to them by their own fellow countrymen and women. The dubious and tumultuous nature of their realistic lives and experiences could not be made non-visible by wrapping the facts under the garb of law and administration, hopes and aspirations bestowed upon the ex-untouchables by the national leaders. The multifarious trajectories undertaken to comprehend and restrain the phenomenon of untouchability have still not dealt with the real life bizarre caste rigidity practices which promote exactly the opposite of the values what our state and its constitution strive to stand by. The identity crisis resurfaces with a thrust along the lines of precariousness.

The untouchables embraced the term “Dalit” first coined by Jyotirao Phule and further popularised by Dr. B.

R. Ambedkar. Dalit signified the broken people, the defeated people. However, if read between the lines, it would be easier to perceive that the brokenness of people carried a silver lining of forging new self made identities emerged from the struggles and every kind of impediment encountered in their treads of progression. To convey their unheard words, unfelt emotions, above all, rectify the misconstrued facts of their lives, the Dalits, who have been fortunate enough to cultivate knowledge and scholarship and secured alleged high esteemed disposition in society, have articulated such reminiscence and disseminated them through the medium of cultural, literary events, popularly and collectively known as Dalit literature.

DALIT AUTOBIOGRAPHY AND ‘JOOTHAN’

Dalit autobiographies act as distinctive part of Dalit literature. The nature of autobiographies is transparent and inclusive. Autobiographies present the real life experiences, but it goes beyond the life of the writer. Not only does Dalit autobiography speak about life of an individual plagued with the oppression of caste system but it speaks at communal level. Story of one Dalit life provides an insight to the lives of many other Dalit people. Though one autobiographical character remains the locus, the stories of supporting characters are also significant to be paid heed to. One such Dalit autobiography is ‘Joothan’, written by Omprakash Valmiki. The autobiography was written in Hindi, later its translation in English by Arun Prabha Mukherjee secured for it a national recognition by expanding the scope of readership.

Joothan is a collection of memoirs. The nature of non linearity of the story precludes the monotony to take a heavy toll on the minds of readers. It is rather a dovetail sewed with the author’s fragment memories of his childhood filled with hardships pertaining to his belonging in the ‘Chuhra’ community. Throughout the text, Valmiki makes it a point to assert the undeniable differences between the untouchables and the upper caste people, which had already been created by the caste hierarchization of society. He is extremely polemical in reacting to hypocrisy of Gandhiji to call the untouchables the children of God and at the same time to urge for preservation of Varna system of Indian society. To Valmiki, ‘The pigs wandering in narrow lanes, naked children, dogs, daily fights this was the environment of my childhood. If the people who call the caste system an ideal social arrangement had to live in this environment for a day or two, they would change their mind’. Thus, implication of his statement is to make an urge to the loquacious bunch of upper caste people to step into the shoes of a Dalit to feel the bitterness of this hellish life, which can be otherwise, only be experienced by Dalit himself. Also, in many other instances, Valmiki elaborates the distinguishing idiosyncrasies of lives of Dalits than that of upper caste ‘Tyagis’ of their village. He points out the ‘the deities worshipped by the Dalits are ‘different from Hindu deities and their names won’t be found in any ‘Purana’ even if one searches hard’ and also Dalits worship ‘Jaharpir’ at ‘Janmashtami’ and ‘Mai Madaran’ during ‘Deepawali’ in lieu of Lord Krishna and goddess ‘Lakshmi’ respectively. I perceive this assertion of differences in voice of Valmiki as an attempt on the part of his community to stand out of the Hindu fold, to prohibit itself from being a part of socio-religious integrated system of Hinduism. The scrupulous mention of the dichotomy between Dalits as ‘we’, ‘us’ and upper castes as ‘they’, ‘them’ is significantly manifested throughout his text. The subhuman existence of Chuhra community, its plight of everyday and groaning of hunger and starvation, deprivation of reverent existence, are all encapsulated in the term “Joothan”. Valmiki narrates for us the values of joothan or leftover received by them from the Tyagi upper caste community. The leftover foods were rugged and grubby in nature, albeit the Chuhra’s had them with relish. The consumption of pork by the ‘Chuhras’ were looked down upon by the ‘Tyagis’, the author also notes that ‘The behaviour of (this) Muslim Tagas was just like that of the Hindu Tagas’. On being exasperated at the general rebuking character of upper castes people, Hindu and Muslim Tyagis both alike, Valmiki at one instance bewrayed their hypocrite temperament and he went on to say ‘At such moments I would think of all the Tyagis who came in the darkness of the night to the Bhangi basti to eat pork. ..Those who came to eat meat secretly at night in day light observed untouchability in front of everybody.’

The author’s struggle to adjust to the educational ambience of school, primarily marked by the presence of upper castes Tyagis was burdensome and exhausting. The fact that, so called untouchables getting an opportunity of receiving education meant forging of arduous parity between the upper castes Tyagis and the ex-untouchables ‘Chuhra’ which was frowned upon by the former community. Thus the untouchables became easy targets of the wrath of Tyagis. Valmiki expressed through penning down his story his helplessness when people teased him by calling “Chuhre ke”, credential was his determination which got him through this nauseating phase and made him what he was in his later life. The caste discrimination had expanded from his dwelling to the school, so expanded the range of animosity to the author. He was isolated and made sit on a corner of the room. His other friends who were too untouchables, Ram Singh and Sukkham Singh were treated alike. Valmiki narrates an incident of unspeakable torture of Sukkham Singh by Kaliram, the headmaster of their school. Kaliram also compelled young Valmiki to sweep the entire school premises. Despite all the hurdles on his way, the author endured hardships in the hope that his father’s words might come true, that was to improve caste by education. Never indulgent in menial works, Omprakash found it disgraceful to scavenging, reaping and disposing dead cattle.

[...]

Excerpt out of 6 pages

Details

Title
"Joothan: A Dalit's Life" by Omprakash Valmiki. A Book Review
College
Presidency College, Kolkata
Grade
8
Author
Year
2016
Pages
6
Catalog Number
V337638
ISBN (eBook)
9783668275447
ISBN (Book)
9783668275454
File size
386 KB
Language
English
Tags
India, Caste System, Dalit, Omprakash Valmiki, society system
Quote paper
Pratyusha Guha (Author), 2016, "Joothan: A Dalit's Life" by Omprakash Valmiki. A Book Review, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/337638

Comments

  • No comments yet.
Read the ebook
Title: "Joothan: A Dalit's Life" by Omprakash Valmiki. A Book Review


Upload papers

Your term paper / thesis:

- Publication as eBook and book
- High royalties for the sales
- Completely free - with ISBN
- It only takes five minutes
- Every paper finds readers

Publish now - it's free