This essay will deal with the question of wether and how the concept of human rights has led to changes in Soviet policies and to the end of the „Cold War“. A special focus will be on the work of the CSCE (Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europea) and non-governmental groups (further revered to as NGOs).
After World War II, national leaders had learned that international regimes were not just a domestic matter but could themselves become a menace to world peace. Although, while many human rights are, as Louise Shelley has pointed out, a Western concept and not encouraged or institutionalized by many non-Western countries, these countries were signatories to the United Nations´ convention on human rights. Still their political and social cultures did not conform to many of the provisions expressed in it. This issue of human rights, as it has emerged mainly out of the ideas of the Enlightenment, still remained alien to many of the world´s nations after the War.
As has been pointed out by distinguished historians and as Shelley mentioned, Russia remained 'outside' the Enlightenment. The Soviet Union is the heir of the Russian legal tradition, a culture in which individual rights were consistently subordinated to the state. It is also important to note that Russia was, as Shelley said, never directly exposed to the ideas of the Enlightenment, although some of its values were transmitted via the czars.
Most important to know is that Human rights cannot be imposed on a society. Institutions that foster and nurture human rights must develop in a society itself. This is a gradual process. In societies without such a tradition it is unnatural to expect that such a transformation can occur in the face of a different historical legacy and in the face of other pressing economic and political problems.
Knowing this, the following paper will show how NGOs and Soviet national leaders have tried to establish Human Rights in the USSR and what role the CSCE played in that process.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines the Moscow Helsinki Group’s reporting of 195 human rights cases
- Applies Gubin’s international-regime framework to the CSCE’s human rights commitments
- Examines the Soviet proposal for a Moscow human rights conference
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. The CSCE
2.1. CSCE Human Rights concerns
2.2. The CSCE as an Human Rights Regime
3. The Soviet ‘Helsinki Period’
3.1. Pressure Groups and their influence on governments
3.2. The rise and fall of Soviet NGOs (before Gorbachev)
4. The changing face of Human Rights during the Cold War
5. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This essay asks whether and how human rights contributed to changes in Soviet policy and to the end of the Cold War, focusing on the Conference for Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE) and the activities of non-governmental groups.
- The Helsinki Final Act and its human rights commitments
- The CSCE as an international human rights regime
- Citizen pressure groups and the Moscow Helsinki Group
- Soviet responses to domestic activism and international scrutiny
- Human rights in Gorbachev-era domestic and foreign policy
Excerpt from the Book
2. The CSCE
One of the strongest pushes for human rights in the Western world has been provided, so Shelley, by the agreement establishing the Conference for Security and Cooperation in Europe. Popularly better known as the Helsinki accords, it was not originally conceived of principally as a Human Rights document5.
Adopted in Helsinki 1975, it has had a very significant impact on the US-European-Soviet dialogue on Human Rights. Initiated by the USSR in the 1950s to gain legitimacy for its dominance in Eastern Europe, the Helsinki accords were finally signed by 35 nations but only after a compromise had been reached. In exchange for the first two baskets on military and economic cooperation, the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe agreed to a variety of Human Rights provisions, the so-called Basket III6.
The first two Baskets were dealing with the assertion of Soviet leadership in Europe, the confirmation of the geopolitical status quo, resulting from World War II, which meant acceptance of their preeminent role in East Europe, and the development of scientific and technological cooperation to benefit the Soviet economy. Once Western nations agreed to such a conference, they approached it with a different agenda: the third basket was brought up, to limit Soviet influence in Europe and to ensure the recognition of existing territorial boundaries. The West wanted to establish norms of behavior among states that would enhance cooperation and ease the restrictions of the Bloc nations, particularly as these applied to a freer flow of people and ideas, these norms were mainly based on Human Rights7.
With many countries feeling that they had made very significant compromises and with the USSR and the East European countries in a very clear violation of many of the provisions agreed to, the Eastern bloc left itself open to criticism by state bodies and numerous citizen groups, that sprang up in Western Europe and the United States to monitor the observance of the accords8.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: Introduces the question of how human rights, the CSCE and non-governmental groups related to Soviet policy and the end of the Cold War. It also places Soviet attitudes toward individual rights in historical context.
The CSCE: Explains the Helsinki Final Act, its human rights provisions and the CSCE’s development as a forum for dialogue and monitoring. It discusses the regime’s political commitments, review meetings and links between human rights and security.
The Soviet ‘Helsinki Period’: Examines citizen pressure groups, the Moscow Helsinki Group and the reporting of human rights violations. It also describes Soviet repression of activists and the international reach of their work.
The changing face of Human Rights during the Cold War: Discusses Gorbachev-era reforms, Soviet foreign policy and changing approaches to human rights. Particular attention is given to the Vienna CSCE Review Meeting and the proposed Moscow conference.
Conclusion: Assesses the relationship between Helsinki activism, international diplomacy and Soviet human rights policy. It considers how official support and transnational networks contributed to changes in East-West relations.
Keywords
Cold War, Soviet Union, CSCE, Helsinki Final Act, human rights, Helsinki monitoring groups, Moscow Helsinki Group, non-governmental organizations, international regimes, Soviet foreign policy, Mikhail Gorbachev, perestroika, Vienna Review Meeting
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the essay about?
It examines the role of human rights in Soviet policy and the end of the Cold War, with particular attention to the CSCE and citizen groups.
What are its central themes?
The main themes include the Helsinki Final Act, international human rights commitments, Soviet activism, diplomatic pressure and Gorbachev-era reform.
What is the primary research question?
The essay asks whether and how the concept of human rights contributed to changes in Soviet policy and to the end of the Cold War.
What research method does the author use?
The author develops a historical discussion using published scholarship and CSCE documents. The essay does not present a separately defined empirical research method.
What does the main discussion cover?
It traces the CSCE’s human rights provisions, the activities of Soviet citizen groups and the changing place of human rights in Soviet domestic and foreign policy.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include the Cold War, the Soviet Union, the CSCE, the Helsinki Final Act, human rights, the Moscow Helsinki Group and perestroika.
How does the essay discuss the Moscow Helsinki Group?
It describes how the group collected and verified reports of violations and communicated cases to international audiences and participating states.
What role does the Vienna Review Meeting play in the discussion?
The meeting provides a focal point for examining Soviet engagement with human rights commitments and the proposal to host a human rights conference in Moscow.
- Quote paper
- BA of Arts Annalena Schäfer (Author), 2013, The Soviet Union and the CSCE. How Human Rights helped end the Cold War, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/347062