In this contribution I am not looking for confrontation with those who believe in a doctrine of reincarnation. Nor do I want to be a dogmatic know-all or the kind of person who superciliously dismisses the faith-context of two world religions (i.e., Hinduism and Buddhism). Explicity, what I am offering is a clear, positive statement of the Christian faith itself, which has been increasingly called into question in our society in recent decades.
Unfortunately this questioning goes hand-in-hand with a (by now) widespread religious indifference on the part even of those of our fellow-citizens who regard themselves – in the broadest sense – as adherents of the Christian religion. My critique is therefore quite deliberately addressed to those within the Christian fold who would attempt to fabricate a western-style syncretizing version of the doctrine of reincarnation and amalgamate it with Christian convictions.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Based on a lecture given at the RWTH Aachen Philosophical Institute’s conference
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Reincarnation – a question for Christian theology ?
3. Reasons why the doctrine of reincarnation is theologically incompatible with the Christian faith
4. Concluding remarks
Objectives and Themes
This work examines whether western interpretations of reincarnation can be reconciled with Christian belief from the perspective of Catholic theology. It aims to clarify the theological grounds for the author’s critique while distinguishing that critique from a confrontation with the religious traditions of Hinduism and Buddhism.
- Interreligious dialogue and Christian theological identity
- Reincarnation in early Christianity and modern theological debate
- Creation, the soul and human individuality
- Forgiveness, purification and salvation
- Bodily resurrection and the unity of body and soul
- Philosophical and ethical questions about reincarnation
Excerpt from the Book
Reasons why the doctrine of reincarnation is theologically incompatible with the Christian faith
First, some words of clarification before we examine in detail why the two world-views under consideration are incompatible. Theologically speaking it is irrelevant whether there is actually a body of Christians who have combined the doctrine of reincarnation with their personal faith and woven it into their religious conceptions. In our society, for instance, there are people who do not accept the doctrine of the Trinity, or the divinity and incarnation of Christ, or his resurrection after his death on the cross, and yet still call themselves Christians.
As far as the Catholic Church is concerned, however, being a Christian is not (only) a matter of how one describes oneself; it depends crucially on whether one shares in the Christian community of faith and tradition – even if such a view is unpopular in our emphatically tolerant and pluralist society (that is also, alas! indifferent and undiscerning). Moreover, this ecclesiastically constituted community proclaims without any doubt and from its very origins that any kind of doctrine of reincarnation, of whatever provenance, is absolutely incompatible with its fundamental convictions. It does this on the basis of its Jewish roots and its biblical faith in the resurrection, handed on from the apostles and their successors, and written for all time into the Christian confession of faith that validly binds all the major Churches and ecclesial communities. The Christian faith, after all, has its own profile that cannot be altered or watered-down.
One often hears the frivolous objection that the doctrine of reincarnation has never been rejected and condemned as erroneous by the Church’s teaching office. As we have said, non-Christian convictions do not need to be evaluated or condemned by the Church’s magisterium unless they are put forward as Christian teachings or as compatible with them.
The fundamental reasons for the incompatibility of the two world-views are the following:
The Christian belief in Creation. All that exists in the world is Creation, willed by God as such and called into being by him. This applies particularly to the human soul, which therefore cannot be held to be “divine” in any way. The soul receives its immortality from God: it does not have immortality of its own nature. Our souls were never a part of God and so there is no question of them returning to him to be reunited with him, as is claimed by some dualistic world-views of largely gnostic origin.
The immortality promised to us is something given: its origin is in God’s deep, unconditional love that is firmly covenanted to us and therefore cannot be lost. We are immortal because God loves us with an undying love, in our personality and individuality, and affirms each of us as an utterly concrete “Thou”
Our soul is the human organ of communication between man and God, whereby we open to his care for us and respond to it. That is what makes us loved and affirmed by God, not some supposed divine origin on the part of our soul. Here, in the genuinely Christian understanding of God and man, we have an unbridgeable chasm that separates us from any form of reincarnation doctrine.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The author places the critique in the context of respectful interreligious dialogue and identifies its intended audience as Christians who seek to combine reincarnation with Christian convictions.
2. Reincarnation – a question for Christian theology ?: This chapter discusses claims about reincarnation in early Christianity and considers proposals by modern theologians. It also identifies elements the author sees as shared by eastern traditions and Christianity.
3. Reasons why the doctrine of reincarnation is theologically incompatible with the Christian faith: The author develops arguments concerning creation, the soul, forgiveness, salvation and bodily resurrection. The discussion contrasts these with interpretations of reincarnation.
4. Concluding remarks: The author raises philosophical and ethical questions about the origins and implications of reincarnation beliefs, including their relationship to suffering and responsibility.
Keywords
reincarnation, Catholic theology, Christian faith, resurrection, soul, creation, salvation, forgiveness, purgatory, interreligious dialogue, early Christianity, theodicy, bodily resurrection
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It presents a Catholic theological critique of western attempts to combine reincarnation with Christian belief.
What are its central themes?
The central themes include reincarnation, creation, the soul, salvation, forgiveness, bodily resurrection and interreligious dialogue.
What is the main question?
The work asks whether a doctrine of reincarnation can be reconciled with the fundamental convictions of the Christian faith.
What scholarly approach does the author use?
The author develops a theological and philosophical argument, drawing on historical and biblical considerations and systematic theology.
What does the main discussion cover?
It examines early Christian views and modern theological proposals before discussing creation, purification, forgiveness and the resurrection of the body.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include reincarnation, Catholic theology, Christian faith, resurrection, salvation, the soul and interreligious dialogue.
How does the author approach other religions?
The introduction affirms respectful dialogue with other religions and directs the critique toward attempts to combine reincarnation with Christian convictions.
Which modern theologians are discussed?
The work considers proposals associated with Karl Rahner, Hans Küng and Michael von Brück concerning possible theological uses of reincarnation.
Why does bodily resurrection matter to the discussion?
The author treats the unity of body and soul and the promise of bodily resurrection as central to the Christian understanding of human identity and salvation.
- Quote paper
- Frank Drescher (Author), 2002, The Western Doctrine of Reincarnation. A Critique From the Point of View of Catholic Theology, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/347165