The conception of the thin individual is one that there is no real inner self waiting to unfold, but rather a malleable dumb creature. According to the thin conception of the individual, what is taken as innate human attributes, such as to think, act, and so on, are just cultural and historical variables. As Colin Wilson suggests, Descartes should have followed his assertion ‘I think therefore I am’ with the question ‘Yes but who am I’? Not the social constructed person or even the socio-technical person. The inner world reality of consciousness, the will to love, fight, have sexual relations etc. As Erich Fromm claims, many sociologists are in essence apologists for and not critics of the existing social system.
At a glance
- Applies actor-network theory and habitus to self-service shopping and social class
- Examines BP petrol stations and Tesco’s early self-service experiments
- 15 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. The‘thin’ conception of the individual. What are the strengths and weaknesses of this ‘thin’ understanding?
Objectives and Themes
This essay examines the strengths and weaknesses of the thin conception of the individual, asking how human agency and different forms of personhood emerge in relation to social structures, practices and material arrangements.
- The relationship between social structure and individual agency
- Actor-network theory and the distribution of agency through agencements
- Self-service shopping as a socially and materially organised practice
- Habitus, social class and the formation of tastes and dispositions
- Critiques of thin accounts of personhood, power and social change
Excerpt from the Book
The‘thin’ conception of the individual. What are the strengths and weaknesses of this ‘thin’ understanding?
In an era of neo-liberalism, Callon (2005) cited in (du Gay, 2008, p.33) claims from an Actor-network theory (ANT) that the individual does not possess agency rather it is distributed through agencements. That is networks of relations between people, things, props, materials, technical devices that are mediated through social training and practices. Therefore, the ability to act/agency does not come from an idea of human but is distributed throughout the arranged setting. ANT claims that the individual should only view who they are or think they are from the context that they are embedded in (Open University, 2015 security revisited). For example, when the oil company BP first introduced self-service techniques in petrol stations it caused chaos (du Gay, 2008, p.22). Furthermore, (The Times, 1972) cited in (du Gay, 2008, p.22) reported a BP marketing man witness a customer put a pound note up the nozzle and shout four gallons of commercial please.
This also happened to people when grocery shopping became self-service, people did not know how to conduct them-selves as self-service shoppers. In 1947 Tesco’s converted one of their stores to self-service, only to have to change it back as customers found it inconvenient (Humphrey 1998 cited in du Gay, 2008, p.40). In addition, class-based cultural norms also had to be overcome; Lord Alan Sainsbury got a shopping basket thrown back at him from a judge’s wife. The judge’s wife did not want to see her-self as a lowly shop assistant, someone who originally got paid to do this work. Furthermore, pictorial mediation also had to be used to explain what way it all worked (du guy, 2008, p.44). In modern society for an individual to conduct themselves as a self- service shopper there has to be a lot of equipment available, shopping trolleys, food packaging, shelves, bar-codes, bags, and check-outs, mediating sources. What needs to be in place shows that individuals have no innate ability to act as a certain type of person? In this example, self-service shoppers, as Callon (2005) cited in (du Gay, 2008) claims agency is distributed amongst all these networks, both human and material.
Chapter Summary
The‘thin’ conception of the individual. What are the strengths and weaknesses of this ‘thin’ understanding?: The essay explores how agencement and habitus connect individual conduct to social practices, material arrangements and class. It assesses these approaches alongside questions about agency, power and the possibility of social change.
Keywords
thin conception of the individual, human agency, social structure, actor-network theory, agencement, habitus, social class, self-service shopping, material mediation, personhood, social practices, sociological theory
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It examines the thin conception of the individual and its account of the relationship between people and their social worlds.
What are the central themes?
The central themes include agency, social structure, agencement, habitus, material arrangements and social class.
What is the primary question?
The essay asks what strengths and weaknesses characterise a thin understanding of the individual.
What method does the author use?
The author develops a theoretical discussion and critique using sociological concepts, published scholarship and illustrative examples.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers distributed agency through actor-network theory, the role of habitus in class-based conduct and criticisms of thin accounts of personhood.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include agency, social structure, agencement, habitus, actor-network theory, social class and personhood.
Why does the essay discuss self-service shopping?
Self-service shopping illustrates how conduct depends on learned practices and arrangements involving equipment, people and material objects.
How does Bourdieu’s concept of habitus feature in the discussion?
The essay uses habitus to explore how class-related dispositions, tastes and practices develop through social experience.
- Quote paper
- Martine Quinn (Author), 2016, The "thin" conception of the individual. What are the strengths and weaknesses of this "thin" understanding?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/351566