It is now becoming increasingly evident that gender plays a vital role in investment and financing decisions of many organisations today as men and women tend to behave and act differently. Women are generally perceived to be detail-oriented, keen and sceptical in decision making relative to their male counterparts who are more risk tolerant. This study examines a number of empirical studies and other relevant literature to help justify as to whether or not, there is a relationship between gender, corporate financial decisions and risk taking.
Using General Motors (GM-US), a company that experienced a CEO and Board Chair changeover from male to female in early 2014 and 2016 respectively as a case study, the essay examines measures like leverage, solvency, M&A activities, and other metrics that can directly be attributed to CEO/Board chair’s decisions and how these decisions alter the company’s risk profile in the period prior to and after the transition.
At a glance
- Time-series comparison of GM’s leverage, Altman’s score and acquisitions around the CEO transition
- GM annual reports from 2009–2015 examined for mergers and acquisitions
- Computed leverage ratios and financial statement extracts included in Appendix II
- 13 sources in the bibliography
- 2 figures and 1 table
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Literature Review
3. A Case Study of General Motors (GM) Limited
3.1 Background Information
3.2 The Case Evaluation Criteria
3.2.1 (i) Leverage Position/Solvency Position
3.2.2 (ii) Altman’s score measure of bankruptcy
3.2.3 (iii) GM’s Mergers and Acquisition Activities
4. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This study asks whether gender is related to corporate financial decisions and risk taking. It reviews empirical research and examines General Motors’ financial indicators and corporate activities before and after a change from male to female leadership.
- Gender and perceptions of risk
- CEO transitions and corporate risk profiles
- Debt financing, leverage and solvency
- Altman’s Z-score and bankruptcy risk
- General Motors’ mergers and acquisitions
Excerpt from the Book
Literature Review
The implications of gender on corporate financial decisions and risk taking has been documented in several studies over the last few decades. The findings on the subject matter can be discussed from three main strands/viewpoints. Firstly, gender-based behavioural differences on risk perception, secondly, effects of CEO changeover (from male to female or vice versa) on corporate risk-taking, and finally the effect of gender differences in corporate financial decision making.
The initial discussion of this topic is in Byrnes, at. al., (1999) where they conducted a meta-analysis of 150 studies focusing on women and men’s propensities towards risk taking in their everyday decision-making. In this study, they established that men are highly likely to take more risk on average than women. In a similar study, Barber and Odean (2001) while attempting to predict the confidence of investors based on gender also indicates that male tend exude overconfidence in specific areas than women but emphasized that women are also overconfident in other areas where men are not. Proceeding on this track, other recent researchers have tried to explore the areas where women and men behave differently. In a study that faults the current findings, Weber, et. al., (2002) examined how women and men perceive risks within five (5) distinctive areas; healthy and safety, financial, recreational, ethical and social decisions. Female risk aversion featured more prominently in four out of five domains but women were perceived to be high-risk takers in aspects of social decision making. The four categories showed males perceiving greater risk because they generally have a greater propensity of engaging in riskier events than women.
Looking at the corporate world, it has consistently been established that women CEOs on average bear less risk relative to their male counterparts. While examining both privately and publicly listed companies run by women in Europe, Faccio, et, al., (2016) used data from Amadeus Top 250,000 and Worldscope to run a number of regressions with an aim of establishing how gender diversity compares with differences in corporate outcomes/decisions and concluded that given alternatives, female CEOs would choose investments and financing decisions with minimal risks compared to male CEOs who would prefer risky investments. The same conclusion was drawn by Palvia, et.al., (2014) whose findings indicate that female board chairs and CEOs are less risk-taking than men and that firms which are led by women are more conservative and less prone to financial risks as a result of prudent decisions.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction presents the question of gender and corporate risk taking and outlines the General Motors case study.
Literature Review: The review considers research on risk perception, leadership transitions and financial decision-making, including differing interpretations of gender-related behaviour.
A Case Study of General Motors (GM) Limited: The case study provides company background and examines leverage, Altman’s Z-score and acquisition activity around the CEO transition.
Conclusion: The conclusion considers the case alongside the literature and discusses other factors that might be examined in future research.
Keywords
gender, corporate finance, risk taking, General Motors, CEO succession, leadership, leverage, solvency, Altman’s Z-score, bankruptcy risk, mergers and acquisitions, financial decision-making
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It examines the relationship between gender, corporate financial decisions and risk taking, using General Motors as a case study.
What are the central themes?
The study addresses risk perception, leadership transitions, debt financing, bankruptcy risk and acquisition activity.
What is the main research question?
It asks whether gender is related to corporate financial decisions and risk taking.
What research method does the author use?
The author combines a literature review with a time-series case study, drawing on financial statements, Bloomberg data and annual reports.
What does the main case study examine?
It considers General Motors’ background and evaluates leverage, Altman’s Z-score and mergers and acquisitions before and after the CEO transition.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include gender, corporate finance, risk taking, CEO succession, leverage, Altman’s Z-score and mergers and acquisitions.
Why was General Motors selected?
The author selected General Motors because its leadership transition provides an opportunity to compare corporate decisions before and after a change from a male to a female CEO.
How is Altman’s Z-score used?
The study calculates and charts the score as an indicator of the company’s financial strength and potential bankruptcy risk over time.
What period does the acquisition analysis cover?
The analysis examines annual reports for 2009 through 2015 to identify merger and acquisition activity.
- Citation du texte
- Richard Ondimu (Auteur), 2016, How Gender Affect Corporate Financial Decisions and Risk Taking, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/358716