This paper explores the evolution of the Nigerian state from the colonial era through the present democratic dispensation and maintains that the only legacy bequeathed to the country by Western imperialism that has assumed independence is conceivably religion and/or ethnicity. It is the position of the paper that religion and ethnicity have more than any phenomenon significantly militated against the evolution of the country into a nation state. This underscores continuous agitation for sub-regional autonomy and secessionist attempts by the Eastern region of the country as witnessed in the Biafra civil war of 1966.
The Nigerian state has grappled with threats to nationhood since independence as several irredentist movements have truncated the maturation of the country into a nation state. Similarly, gross failure of leadership aided by corruption of political actors has stifled the transformation of the country beyond the colonial partitioning of 1914.
The secularity of the Nigerian constitution has been interminably jettisoned in the pursuit of scarce social goods by political actors as amply demonstrated in the imposition of Sharia law in some northern states of the country. This has heightened religious and ethnic consciousness of citizens thereby constituting significant drag on the country’s march to nationhood. The paper advocates the recognition of the country’s plurality and diversity as building blocks of unity and national integration. Furthermore the de-politicization of religion and ethnicity are hereby conversed for the development of a robust and virile Nigerian nation.
At a glance
- Explains how colonial indirect rule preserved a North–South cultural and religious divide
- Examines the 1999 Constitution’s secular-state provision and its contestation in Nigerian politics
- Advocates dialogue, negotiation, consensus-building, and national citizenship as approaches to integration
- 24 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Nigeria’s Independence
3. Political Consequences of Amalgamation
4. The Challenge of Leadership in Nigeria
5. Religion in Post-Independent Nigeria
6. Ethnicity and the Struggle for Relevance in Nigeria
7. Vista of Hope in the Horizon
8. Conclusion
Purpose and Themes
This paper traces the evolution of the Nigerian state from colonial rule to the contemporary democratic period, asking how Nigeria might develop into a nation-state despite enduring religious, ethnic, and leadership challenges.
- Colonial amalgamation and its political consequences
- Leadership failure and corruption after independence
- Religion, constitutional secularism, and political mobilization
- Ethnicity, identity, and competing claims for resources
- National integration, citizenship, and recognition of diversity
Excerpt from the Book
Ethnic Consciousness, Identity, and the Multinational State
Ethnic consciousness is not detrimental to peaceful coexistence and harmony in a nation state. In fact, it can be argued that every individual needs this form of consciousness for his/her own identity. The fact that I am Mwaghavul, Hausa, Yoruba, Igbo, English, Welsh or Walloon is a basic fact of identity for me. It is also difficult, if not impossible, to transfer this identity or replace it with another one, especially in one’s adulthood. It is my argument that ethnic consciousness is not detrimental to peaceful coexistence and harmony. It can of course, be easily exploited by competing elites or politicians for other purposes. When highly notable Nigerians like Chinua Achebe, goes to take a chieftaincy title in his village, he is responding to the deculturalizing aspect of modernization as he seeks identification with his cultural obligations and rights among his own group, it is only a demonstration of ethnic consciousness. On the other hand ethnicity is ethnic consciousness transformed into a weapon of offence or defense in a competitive process in relations with other groups over desired scarce resources. This could lead to the mobilization of ethnic bedfellows in order to maximize gains at the expense of other competing groups.
While ethnicity may create numerous problems for the central elite, a poly-ethnic state has relatively less tasks than a multinational state. For our purpose, a poly-ethnic state refers to those states which have many small ethnic groups, none of which lays claim to sub-national autonomy enough to challenge self-determination. No ethnic group in such states regards itself as a nation. Thus Tanzania, Senegal, Gambia, Guinea and Congo (Brazzaville) illustrate poly-ethnic states in Africa. On the other hand, a multinational state comprises ethnic groups who not only vary in size but also in the distribution of power, influence and resources. Such state is marked by aggressive ethnic nationalism as various groups push for national self-determination. Often their demand for sub-national self-determination directly challenges the centre’s demand for national self-determination; Nigeria (Igbo, Yoruba, Hausa), Zaire (the Kongo, Mongo, Luba, and Kivu ethnic types), the Chad (the Arab, and Sudanese types) illustrate multinational states in Africa. It is my contention that problems for peaceful coexistence are less intractable in poly-ethnic states than in multinational states.
Like most developed countries, African states face difficult and simultaneous challenges of political development and the strategies adopted for coping with these challenges are in part, products of their colonial experience. While federalism is a mechanism for effecting desirable compromises in a multinational state, it is embedded with its own seeds of discord. Most African states have problems emanating from poly-ethnicity and religious differences. However, in most of these states, the necessity for the consolidation of the fragile state override demands for the satisfaction of sub-national self-determination; thus, ‘mobilizational’ techniques and structures have been more acceptable to African leaders, except in aggressively multinational states.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The paper presents Nigeria as a colonial creation formed from diverse peoples and regions. It outlines the historical divisions that continued into independence and weakened national unity.
Nigeria’s Independence: Nigeria achieved independence in 1960 without an armed independence war, though the North was initially reluctant. The paper links post-independence hopes to subsequent leadership failures and political instability.
Political Consequences of Amalgamation: The author recounts regional objections to the 1914 amalgamation and cites leaders and newspapers who questioned the union. These reactions illustrate enduring distrust and competing regional loyalties.
The Challenge of Leadership in Nigeria: This chapter connects corruption, misrule, and failures of governance with the country’s development difficulties. It also considers how religion and ethnicity can shield political actors from accountability.
Religion in Post-Independent Nigeria: The discussion examines religion’s role in Nigerian public life, including its political use, religious mobilization, and effects on social cohesion. It refers to constitutional secularism and the growth of religious tensions.
Ethnicity and the Struggle for Relevance in Nigeria: The chapter distinguishes ethnic identity from ethnicity as political action and explores how competition, perceptions, and colonial boundaries affect integration. It contrasts poly-ethnic and multinational states.
Vista of Hope in the Horizon: The author proposes renewed efforts toward nation-building, including patriotic leadership, reduced suspicion, and proactive peace-building. The chapter emphasizes the country’s plural composition as a basis for unity.
Conclusion: The conclusion calls for recognition of pluralism, dialogue, and consensus-building to address ethnic and religious challenges. It also stresses national citizenship and social democracy.
Keywords
Nigeria, nationhood, colonialism, amalgamation, leadership, corruption, religion, ethnicity, national integration, secularism, federalism, citizenship, diversity, peace-building
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It examines why Nigeria has struggled to develop a shared nationhood and discusses historical, political, religious, and ethnic factors shaping that challenge.
What are the paper’s central themes?
The main themes are colonial amalgamation, leadership and corruption, religion and secularism, ethnicity, and national integration.
What is the paper’s primary question or aim?
It traces Nigeria’s evolution from colonial rule through the democratic period and considers how the country might progress toward nationhood.
What research method does the author use?
The paper uses a historical and conceptual discussion, drawing on published sources and examples; it does not report original surveys or interviews.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers the political effects of amalgamation, post-independence leadership, religious politics, ethnic identity, and proposed approaches to integration.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Nigeria, nationhood, amalgamation, leadership, religion, ethnicity, secularism, and national integration are among its key terms.
How does the paper describe the 1914 amalgamation?
It presents the merger of northern and southern territories as an administrative act that brought together regions with different social, cultural, and religious structures.
How does the paper distinguish ethnic consciousness from ethnicity?
It treats ethnic consciousness as identity and belonging, while ethnicity describes that consciousness being acted out in competition or relations with other groups.
What does the paper propose for strengthening national integration?
It advocates recognizing Nigeria’s diversity, addressing citizenship, and using dialogue, negotiation, and consensus-building.
- Quote paper
- Stanley Kavwam (Author), 2011, The Evolution of the Nigerian State from the Colonial Era through the Present Democratic Dispensation, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/368980