The rentier state theory has informed much scholarly research on the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. A main theorist of the rentier state theories argues that "in a rentier state, the government is the principal recipient of the external rent in the economy. This is a fact of paramount importance, cutting across the whole of the social fabric of the economy affecting the role of the state in the society" (Beblawi, 1990, p.88).
With several countries in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region ranking among the rentier states, it is important to consider the term, which has influenced political thinking of the past and the present. This argumentation raises the question of adequacy concerning the notion of the rentier state in analysing political processes in the major oil-producing states of the Middle East. In order to answer this question, this essay is divided into two main parts. In a first section, it will consider the main features that the rentier state theorists have set out and the implications that this theory brings about. In a second step, the main limitations of this theory will be elaborated, as well as some of its benefits will be considered.
Close reading of the theories by Hossein Mahdavy (1970), Giacomo Luciani (1987), and Hazem Beblawi (1990), the consideration of critical essays on theories of the rentier state, as well as a glance at countries ranking among rentier states by definition leads to the conclusion that the rentier state theory judges, generalises, and oversimplifies the respective states that rank among the definition of the rentier states. The theory focuses on the economy of a state and how a regime manages this economy, and excludes many elements that are essential to the analysis of the mentioned political processes and is therefore very problematic for this purpose.
At a glance
- Applies Luciani’s threshold of more than 40 percent of state revenue from abroad
- Examines seven Middle Eastern countries in a study of rentierism and democracy
- Discusses oil-related political struggles in Iraq, Palestine, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, and Iran
- 17 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. Introduction
2. The Rentier State
2.1 Emerging notion of the rentier state: rentier capitalism
2.2 Defining the rentier state theory
2.3 Country cases
3. The Rentier State Theory as a Theory of State
3.1 Implications of the rentier state theory
4. Limitations
4.1 A theory of state
4.2 Judgmental notions
4.3 Generalisation
4.4 Oversimplification
4.5 Historical background
5. Counter Examples to Rentier State Stereotypes
6. Benefits
7. Conclusion
Purpose and Themes
This essay assesses how adequate rentier state theory is for analysing political processes in the major oil-producing states of the Middle East. It examines the theory’s definitions and implications, evaluates its limitations and benefits, and considers whether economic explanations can account for political patterns without overlooking historical and country-specific factors.
- Definitions of rentier states by Mahdavy, Beblawi, and Luciani
- Allocation states, external revenues, and state-society relations
- Political assumptions about taxation, representation, and democracy
- Limitations involving state scope, judgment, generalisation, and oversimplification
- Historical, colonial, and United States influences on state formation
- Counterexamples and the theory’s potential analytical benefits
Excerpt from the Book
Historical background
It is therefore important to consider those factors, which may account for the "rentier" features that Beblawi as well as Luciani claim to recognise in the above mentioned countries. Here, it needs to be repeated that each country is unique, and in this context particularly so in their political setup, and in the factors which contributed to their development to this point. A main argument of this paper is that the rentier state theory contributes to the understanding of the economic base of rentier states, however, in order to complete this picture and to understand the actual functioning of the country, several other factors have to be taken into account. In order to do that, a number of factors may play a role. For instance, the colonial experience, the structures before the emergence of oil extraction to the extent of the 1960s and 1970s, as well as the impact of the international community, in particular by the United States have to be taken into consideration.
In terms of the historical background of the countries under investigation, two perspectives are important. Firstly, the authoritarian structure before the emergence of extensive oil extraction plays a role. Steffen Hertog (2007) discusses the state formation of Saudi Arabia. The author highlights additional factors accounting for the development of the Saudi state to its status quo, such as the impact of the United States and Saudi elite politics, whereas his article focuses on the internal politics of the formation from an institutional perspective. While the rentier state theory and much writing "overdetermine" the structural economic impact on the state formation, the author's account adds an important factor to which the rentier state theory turned a blind eye. Hertog states that "many of today's permanent features of the Saudi state can be traced back to early contingencies and the crucial juncture of 1962" (2007, p. 556). He promotes the "analysis of elite decisions in state creation in Saudi Arabia" (p. 539) as an alternative to the "structurally overdetermined accounts of the creation of Gulf states", i.e. to the rentier state theories. Lowi (2009) adds to this account by introducing the differences in the histories leading up to today's oil states.
Secondly, the colonial impact on state formation in the mentioned countries should not be ignored. The colonial setup allows for an interesting comparison to those features, which are highlighted as distinct for the rentier nature of the major oil-producing states: a system, which is based on external revenues, and is centralized as well as patrimonial, violent and authoritarian (Tripp, 2017).
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: Introduces rentier state theory and asks whether it adequately analyses political processes in major Middle Eastern oil-producing states. It previews the discussion of the theory’s main features, limitations, and benefits.
2. The Rentier State: Explains the concept of rentier capitalism and reviews definitions of the rentier state associated with Mahdavy, Beblawi, and Luciani. It also identifies countries discussed as rentier or allocation states.
3. The Rentier State Theory as a Theory of State: Describes political expectations associated with rentier theory, including claims about democracy, autonomy, gender, and regime stability.
4. Limitations: Examines the theory’s broad claims about the state and its judgmental framing, generalisations, and economic oversimplification. It also considers historical, colonial, and international factors in state formation.
5. Counter Examples to Rentier State Stereotypes: Uses political events in Libya and Iraq to question expectations of detached citizens and oil-based regime stability.
6. Benefits: Considers the theory’s usefulness for analysing political economy and discusses the proposed “telescoping effect” of oil in historically shaped state systems.
7. Conclusion: Concludes that rentier state theory may help analyse political economy but should be treated cautiously as a general theory of state functioning. It stresses country-specific historical analysis and openness to political change.
Keywords
rentier state theory, Middle East, oil-producing states, political economy, external rent, allocation state, state-society relations, authoritarianism, democracy, economic determinism, state formation, colonialism, Saudi Arabia
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this essay about?
It evaluates how useful rentier state theory is for analysing political processes in the major oil-producing states of the Middle East.
What are the essay’s central themes?
Its themes include rent and state revenue, state-society relations, political representation, democracy, historical state formation, and the limits of economic explanations.
What is the main research question?
The essay asks how adequate the notion of the rentier state is for analysing political processes in the major oil-producing states of the Middle East.
What method does the author use?
The essay uses close reading of rentier state theories, consideration of critical essays, and discussion of country cases and cited scholarship.
What does the main body examine?
It sets out key definitions and implications, evaluates limitations and benefits, and considers historical influences and counterexamples to rentier-state expectations.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include rentier state theory, political economy, external rent, allocation state, authoritarianism, democracy, and state formation.
Which theorists’ definitions are discussed?
The essay examines the contributions of Hossein Mahdavy, Hazem Beblawi, and Giacomo Luciani.
What historical factors does the essay say should be considered?
It points to colonial experience, political structures predating extensive oil extraction, and the influence of the international community, particularly the United States.
Which cases are used to challenge rentier-state stereotypes?
The essay refers to the overthrows of King Idris and Gaddafi in Libya and to the survival of Saddam Hussein’s regime under sanctions against Iraq.
- Quote paper
- Rebekka Schliep (Author), 2017, The implications of the rentier state theory regarding the major oil-producing states of the Middle East, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/369472