Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Region: Western Europe

Great Britain in Europe. The Effects of Devolution on EU-UK Relations

Title: Great Britain in Europe. The Effects of Devolution on EU-UK Relations

Term Paper (Advanced seminar) , 2011 , 16 Pages , Grade: 1.7

Autor:in: Ron Böhler (Author)

Politics - Region: Western Europe
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Building upon the multi-level governance (MLG) approach, this paper seeks to analyze the impact of Scottish devolution on the British government´s strategic position in relation with Europe.

The first section will therefore detail the concept of multi-level governance and the domestic impact of EU politics. This perspective is supplemented by theoretical considerations about devolution and its implications for the British Westminster system. Afterwards, an analysis of Scottish rights and obligations as a devolved polity shall shed light on de facto alterations that came along with the 1998 Scotland Act. The paper restricts itself to the purely structural adaptations. A discussion, why devolution towards Edinburgh has led to a win-win-outcome for Whitehall, will complete the argumentation.

Indeed, the Scotland Act of 1998, for instance, meant serious changes in the British political system and the bureaucratic state whilst political competencies over various policy areas were shifted from central government to subnational authorities. This kind of decentralization away from the British executive in Whitehall was the most radical constitutional change this country has seen since the Great Reform Act of 1832. The United Kingdom (UK) is therewith much influenced by a new European paradigm, referred to as MLG. In this post-national polity, the nation state does not any longer appear as the epicenter of domestic decision-making and foreign policy representation. The old Westminster model (WM) had served its time and was henceforth replaced by a quasi-federal state, rather than a unitary state. New actors, above all the regional governments, gain power and may bypass London as the gatekeeper of UK European policy formulation.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Applies multi-level governance to Scottish devolution and Britain's European policy
  • Examines Scottish fisheries policy within the European Common Fisheries Policy
  • Examines the Joint Ministerial Committee's role in coordinating devolved EU issues
  • 35 sources in the bibliography

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

2. The British State & European Union Governance

3. EU Politics Between Edinburgh, London And Brussels

4. From Scottish Office To Scottish Executive

5. Scottish-EU Relations: A Westminster Bypass?

6. Conclusion

Objectives and Topics

This work examines how Scottish devolution affected the British government's position in European politics. Using multi-level governance as its analytical framework, it asks how the redistribution of domestic powers changed relations among Edinburgh, London and Brussels and the central government's role in EU policy-making.

  • Multi-level governance and the Westminster model
  • Europeanisation and the distribution of political authority
  • The Scotland Act 1998 and devolved responsibilities
  • Coordination between Scottish and UK executives
  • Scottish representation and access to EU institutions

Excerpt from the Book

From Scottish Office To Scottish Executive

Devolution is in all its facets a Labour project, after the Conservatives in particular under Thatcher (1979-1990) 'showed no appetite for devolution and rejected interventionist regional policies on principle' (ibid., p.8). Since 1992, Labour reacted on rising Scottish demands with the promise of implementing devolution within the first year of government (Keating 1998, p.224) and even argued that this step would reinforce the UK as a whole (Mitchell 2000). After the electoral victory of 1997, the new government acquitted itself to this promise. It became the most significant aspect of a programme of constitutional reform, which was launched under Prime Minister Tony Blair. The Scotland Act of 1998, establishing a Scottish Parliament and an associated executive, 'created a new, sub-state tier of government – the devolved administrations – charged with advising, devising, delivering and auditing a range of legislative and related duties that, hitherto, were the responsibility of UK governments' (Bulmer et al. 2002, p. xviii). Devolved policy fields embraced education, justice and police affairs, agriculture and fisheries, environmental initiatives, tourism as well as economic and transport infrastructure. These areas were not clearly named, but those reserved to Westminster Parliament were specified (Scotland Act 1998, Schedule 5). Of importance here are issues related to European Union policy – a key area of British foreign relations – which are still reserved to the Westminster-Whitehall authorities. For many of the devolved powers are affected by European policy-making, a new institutionalised forum for coordination, consultation and cooperation between Whitehall and the devolved administrations became necessary.

From that point, the question is how the British policy-making machinery reacted to this changing institutional environment in order to maintain government effectiveness and a certain degree of state control. If we follow the assumption that regionalism empowers and further strengthens subnational authorities, in relation to both the national government and the European polity, the question remains which impact devolution had on Scottish-EU relations and how, if at all, this has altered Britains role in Brussels. The puzzle here is that, although responsibilities in certain policy areas has been devolved from London to the Scottish region, all EU-related issues are exclusively reserved to Westminster under the Scotland Act of 1998. Eventually, British devolution has far more a power sharing character than resulting in strict separation of authority. As an example, Scottish fisheries policy is defined and implemented by the Scottish Parliament, although overall predetermined by the European Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) and as an EU-related matter supervised by the national British government, 'necessitating cooperation and discussions between all three sides of this policy triangle' (Lynch 2001, p.147).

Chapter Summaries

Introduction: The introduction presents devolution and EU membership as challenges to the traditional unitary British state. It sets out the question of how Scottish devolution affects the UK government's position in Europe.

The British State & European Union Governance: This chapter contrasts multi-level governance with state-centred approaches and discusses Europeanisation, the Westminster model and pressures for decentralisation.

EU Politics Between Edinburgh, London And Brussels: The author considers the relative importance of domestic and European influences on British regionalism and devolution.

From Scottish Office To Scottish Executive: This chapter examines the Scotland Act 1998, the division of responsibilities and arrangements for cooperation between the Scottish and UK executives.

Scottish-EU Relations: A Westminster Bypass?: The chapter discusses Scottish offices in Brussels, their relationship with UK representation and the constraints on Scottish influence in European policy.

Conclusion: The conclusion brings together the discussion of devolution, central government capacity and British authority over EU affairs.

Keywords

Scottish devolution, multi-level governance, European Union, Westminster model, Scotland Act 1998, Europeanisation, Scottish Executive, Whitehall, EU policy-making, intergovernmental relations, Scotland Europa, regional representation

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this work about?

It examines the relationship between Scottish devolution, British government and European Union policy-making.

What are its central themes?

Its main themes include multi-level governance, Europeanisation, the distribution of powers within the UK and Scotland's access to EU institutions.

What is the main research question?

The work asks how Scottish devolution affects the British government's strategic position in relation to Europe.

What method does the author use?

The author develops a structural analysis using the multi-level governance approach, drawing on academic literature, legislation and government documents.

What does the main discussion cover?

It moves from theories of governance and Europeanisation to Scottish devolution, intergovernmental coordination and Scotland's representation in Brussels.

Which keywords characterise the work?

Key terms include Scottish devolution, multi-level governance, Europeanisation, the Westminster model and EU policy-making.

How does the work use fisheries policy?

It uses fisheries to illustrate how devolved Scottish responsibilities intersect with UK oversight and the European Common Fisheries Policy.

Which institutions are discussed as channels for Scottish interests in Brussels?

The discussion considers Scotland Europa, the Scottish Executive's EU Office and the UK's permanent representation.

Excerpt out of 16 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Great Britain in Europe. The Effects of Devolution on EU-UK Relations
College
University of Bath
Grade
1.7
Author
Ron Böhler (Author)
Publication Year
2011
Pages
16
Catalog Number
V376557
ISBN (eBook)
9783668537934
ISBN (Book)
9783668537941
Language
English
Tags
great britain europe effects devolution eu-uk relations
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Ron Böhler (Author), 2011, Great Britain in Europe. The Effects of Devolution on EU-UK Relations, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/376557
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  16  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract