This thesis breaks down the reason for deep economic integration to two main structures: trade asymmetry and actorness.
The data for trade asymmetry and actorness were gathered for 10 dyads of regional organizations or groups of countries that trade with each other.
These data form the base of a QCA model that brings the result that actorness and asymmetry both are sufficient for a deep integration among the trade relations of regional organizations.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Fuzzy-set comparative analysis of 10 interregional trade agreements
- Case study of the EFTA–Central America agreement
- Combines document analysis and process tracing for the case study
- 179 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1 Introduction
1.1 Problem
1.2 Goal of the Thesis
1.3 Methodology
2 Literature
2.1 Asymmetries and Power
2.2 Actorness in Interregionalism
2.2.1 Types of Interregional Relations
2.2.2 Institutionalization
3 Methodology
3.1 Qualitative Comparative Analysis
3.2 Fuzzy-Set QCA
3.2 Operationalization of Depth
3.3 Sample and Case Selection
3.4 Methodology for the case study
4 The Empirical Chapter
4.1 Measurement of the Conditions
4.1.1 Condition 1: Asymmetric Power
4.1.2 Condition 2: Actorness
4.2 Results of the QCA-Model
4.2.1 Fuzzy-set membership and calibration
4.2.2 Tests for Necessity and Sufficiency – transformational calibration
4.2.3 Tests for direct calibration
4.2.4 Assessment of the Results
4.3 Case Study: The EFTA-Central America PTA
4.4 Future PTAs: A short prognosis
5 Conclusion and further remarks
Objectives and Themes
This thesis asks which conditions contribute to deep integration in preferential trade agreements between regions. It examines whether asymmetric trade dependence and the actorness of regional organizations help explain differences in agreement depth, combining a comparative analysis with a focused case study.
- Interregional trade and the relationship between regionalism and multilateralism
- Power asymmetries and trade dependence between negotiating blocs
- Institutionalization, recognition and regional actorness
- Fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis of ten agreements
- The EFTA–Central America negotiations and alternative explanations
- Prospects for agreements involving MERCOSUR
Excerpt from the Book
3.1 Qualitative Comparative Analysis
QCA is a rather young method in social science. It was designed by Charles Ragin to finally close the gap between qualitative and quantitative methods. QCA focuses on causal relations and tries to explain an outcome under certain conditions. These conditions are the QCA equivalent to variables in classical methodology. QCA promises to find sufficient and necessary conditions for a certain outcome, whereas statistical methods deliver statements about the probability of outcomes. Furthermore, the method developed to be very useful for middle-sized-n samples. It also closes a gap in this case. While statistical methods traditionally analyze high-n-samples with hundreds if not thousands of cases, qualitative research as in case studies usually sticks to one or two cases. But for QCA, this is exactly the gap it wants to close (Schneider and Wagemann 2007: 19-27).
QCA has already been applied in more than 750 studies and showed its worth in many different research purposes. The method also gains popularity among political scientists. In this discipline, applications of QCA are steadily on the rise (Marx, Rihoux and Ragin 2014: 116, 125). QCA is not only one method, it rather developed over time in a family of technics with some varieties. To name the most important ones, there are Crisp-Set QCA and Fuzzy-Set QCA. In Crisp-Set QCA all conditions are dichotomized. While binary coding offers an easy way to describe clear causal mechanisms, its application in the real world tends to be difficult. The world normally is not working in a binary way, as all matters are usually not black or white, but come in all shades of grey. Fuzzy-Set QCA is the next step on this matter and allows the user to dig deeper. Its operationalization is technically more difficult, but it leads to more valid results (Schneider and Wagemann 2007: 20,21).
Hence, QCA can also be seen as an extension to the classical methods of Mill. QCA allows to use Mill’s principles on larger samples and simplifies to find equifinality and the effects of connected conditions. This also gives QCA advantages over conventional quantitative statistical methods. Conventional methods seek to explain causalities by probabilities in an unifinal way. QCA shows complex varieties of necessary and sufficient conditions that can lead to a certain outcome.
Chapter Summaries
1 Introduction: Introduces interregional trade agreements, the research question and the hypotheses concerning asymmetric power and actorness.
2 Literature: Reviews research on regionalism, trade dependence and interregional relations, and develops the theoretical basis for the two hypotheses.
3 Methodology: Explains fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis, the measurement of agreement depth, case selection and the methods used for the case study.
4 The Empirical Chapter: Measures the conditions across the selected agreements, presents and assesses the comparative model, and examines the EFTA–Central America negotiations. It also considers prospective agreements involving MERCOSUR.
5 Conclusion and further remarks: Discusses the analysis, its limitations and possible directions for further research.
Keywords
interregionalism, preferential trade agreements, regional integration, trade dependence, power asymmetry, actorness, institutionalization, fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis, agreement depth, DESTA, EFTA, Central America, MERCOSUR
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the thesis about?
It examines the depth of preferential trade agreements negotiated between regional organizations or groups of countries.
What are its central themes?
The main themes are interregional trade, asymmetric power, regional actorness, institutionalization and the depth of trade agreements.
What is the primary research question?
The thesis asks which conditions contribute to deep integration in interregional preferential trade agreements, focusing on trade asymmetry and actorness.
Which research methods are used?
The author applies fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis to ten agreements and complements it with a case study using document analysis and process tracing.
What does the empirical chapter cover?
It presents measurements of trade asymmetry and actorness, compares the agreements, examines the EFTA–Central America negotiations and considers prospective agreements.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include interregionalism, preferential trade agreements, trade dependence, power asymmetry, actorness, institutionalization and fuzzy-set QCA.
How is agreement depth measured?
The analysis uses the DESTA database’s additive index, which scores agreements according to seven provisions covering tariffs and other areas of economic cooperation.
Why does the thesis examine the EFTA–Central America agreement?
The agreement is selected for closer study because it presents a case that differs from the expectations of the comparative model. The case study reconstructs the negotiations and considers alternative explanations.
How does the author assess regional actorness?
The author combines indicators of institutional decision-making, recognition at international institutions and the type of interregional relationship into an index.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Stefan Heinzmann (Autor:in), 2018, The Next Level of Regionalism. Deep Integration of Regio-Regio PTAs, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/449744