China’s rapid transition to a market-oriented economy has led to a mass migration from the countryside to the cities. Chinese rural-urban migrant workers constitute the largest ever labor force in human history. Approximately a third of them are female. Even though migration is a gendered phenomenon and gender cannot be treated as a mere variable of many, the experiences of Chinese women as migrant workers are underrepresented. Many are faced with different challenges than men, such as sexual exploitation, discrimination and abuse. And even though migration can help women to gain autonomy and independence through their increased social, economic and physical mobility, the gender-specific dynamics of migration can also force women into contexts of suppression and dependence.
One of the central questions in the debate surrounding gender and migration in China is, whether Chinese female rural-urban migrant workers should be seen as marginalised victims or rather as agents of social change. However all too often the debate remains caught up in a rigid dichotomy, neglecting the complex interwoven net of identity, economic (in)dependence and social networks these women live and work in. I argue that while there is ground for either one of these characterisations of Chinese female migrant workers – as victims as well as agents of social change – this binary approach is not beneficial to a fruitful discussion. Rather than defending one of these viewpoints, the debate should focus more on acknowledging the complex diversity of this issue as well as on eliminating current research deficits through further qualitative and quantitative analysis and fieldwork.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Context: Rural-urban migrant workers in contemporary China
2.1. The hukou (household registration) system
2.2.1 Reform and the lack thereof
2.2. China’s rapid economic transition
2.3. Gender segregation of the Chinese labour market
3. Female rural-urban migrant workers in China: Between marginalisation and independence
3.1. Marginalised victims or agents of social change? Public discourse and narrated reality
3.2. Challenges of female rural-urban migrant workers
3.3. The effects of migration on female rural-urban migrant workers
4. Conclusion
Research Objectives and Key Themes
This paper investigates the experiences of female rural-urban migrant workers in contemporary China, critically examining whether they should be characterized primarily as marginalized victims of the system or as active agents of social change. By challenging binary representations, the research highlights the complex intersections of identity, economic dependency, and social structures that define these women's lives.
- The impact of the hukou (household registration) system on migrant mobility and rights.
- Structural factors contributing to the gender segregation of the Chinese labor market.
- The prevalence of gender-specific challenges, including discrimination, sexual exploitation, and limited social security.
- The transformative potential of migration on women's autonomy, family planning, and personal decision-making.
- The role of media discourse in shaping the identity and social status of migrant women.
Excerpt from the Book
3.2. Challenges of female rural-urban migrant workers
In the following I will briefly address the most central challenges faced by female rural-urban migrant workers in China. Many of these challenges naturally also apply to male migrant workers. One could undoubtedly expand on either one of these aspects for whole academic papers and independent fieldwork. But in order to situate the question of whether female rural-urban migrant workers should rather be seen as victims or agents of social change, it is important to at least have an overview of their concrete living and working conditions.
A central challenge for practically all rural-urban migrant workers is their low income and income inequality. In 2002 the average monthly wage of migrant workers was 100 US Dollars, which is 58 per cent of an urban worker’s average wage (Shi 2008:12), that is in addition to the persisting gender pay gap between male and female migrant workers which has already been mentioned above. Migrant workers are also faced with a substantial income and job insecurity. Because of their illegitimate residence status they rarely have written contracts with their employers which means they could lose their job any time and at the same time cannot rely on legal counsel for support. Often they have to work overtime, one third of migrant workers work 9 to 10 hours a day, almost one quarter 11 to 12 hours and 12 per cent 13 or more hours per day. This means that more than two thirds of migrant workers have working hours exceeding the legal maximum working time of 8 hours per day by far (Shi 2008:14-15).
Summary of Chapters
1. Introduction: Outlines the research scope regarding female rural-urban migrant workers in China and introduces the central debate regarding their status as victims or agents of social change.
2. Context: Rural-urban migrant workers in contemporary China: Provides the structural background of the migration phenomenon, focusing on the hukou system and economic transitions.
2.1. The hukou (household registration) system: Analyzes the household registration system as a tool for social control and the division of citizenship classes.
2.2.1 Reform and the lack thereof: Discusses the limited impact of recent reform attempts on the fundamental exclusionary nature of the hukou system.
2.2. China’s rapid economic transition: Examines how the shift to a market-oriented economy fueled rural-urban migration to support the manufacturing and export sectors.
2.3. Gender segregation of the Chinese labour market: Details the economic and social disadvantages faced by women, including the gender pay gap and limited access to social benefits.
3. Female rural-urban migrant workers in China: Between marginalisation and independence: Introduces the core tension between victimhood and agency in the lives of female migrants.
3.1. Marginalised victims or agents of social change? Public discourse and narrated reality: Critically evaluates how public media constructs migrant identities against their own lived experiences.
3.2. Challenges of female rural-urban migrant workers: Offers an overview of concrete hardships such as low wages, long working hours, and lack of legal security.
3.3. The effects of migration on female rural-urban migrant workers: Investigates the positive outcomes of migration, such as increased personal autonomy and changing family planning attitudes.
4. Conclusion: Summarizes findings and argues for the necessity of systemic policy reforms and further research that centers the voices of migrant women.
Keywords
China, rural-urban migration, female migrant workers, hukou system, labor market, gender segregation, social change, marginalization, autonomy, economic transition, household registration, migrant experiences, public discourse, human rights, social policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core focus of this research?
The work examines the situation of female rural-urban migrant workers in China, exploring the dichotomy between seeing them as vulnerable victims and recognizing their role as catalysts for social change.
Which specific themes are addressed?
Central themes include the restrictive hukou system, gender-based labor market segregation, the impact of media representation on migrant status, and the personal autonomy gained through the migration experience.
What is the primary objective of this paper?
The objective is to move beyond a binary view of migrant women as either victims or empowered agents, advocating for a nuanced understanding of their complex social, economic, and identity-based realities.
What scientific methods does the author employ?
The author primarily utilizes a qualitative review of existing fieldwork, academic studies, and media reports to synthesize the current discourse and identify research deficits regarding female migrant experiences.
What topics are discussed in the main body?
The main body covers the historical and structural context of Chinese migration, the specific economic and social challenges faced by women, and evidence of shifting life aspirations resulting from urban migration.
Which keywords best describe this study?
Key terms include China, rural-urban migration, female migrant workers, hukou system, gender segregation, autonomy, social change, and human rights.
How does the hukou system specifically impact migrant women?
The system restricts access to urban social services, healthcare, and education, forcing many women into precarious employment and informal living arrangements, which exacerbates their vulnerability.
What does the author suggest regarding future policy?
The author argues that systemic policy reforms, particularly regarding the hukou status and social integration, are essential to systematically improve the living conditions of migrants in Chinese cities.
What is the significance of the "mobile clinic" example?
This example demonstrates how non-governmental initiatives fill gaps in state-provided healthcare and how such social engagement can contribute to the growing independence of female rural migrants.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Dorina Marlen Heller (Autor:in), 2018, Agents of social change or marginalised victims? Female rural-urban migrant workers in contemporary China, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/505933
