Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Political systems in general and in comparison

A Response to Huntington´s "Clash of Civilizations": Civilizations vs Nation State

Title: A Response to Huntington´s "Clash of Civilizations": Civilizations vs Nation State

Essay , 2005 , 14 Pages , Grade: 1,7

Autor:in: Patrick Lubjuhn (Author)

Politics - Political systems in general and in comparison
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Samuel P. Huntington was born in 1927 and is at the moment director of the John- Olin Institute for strategic studies at the University of Harvard. He was the author of an article, first published in the Foreign Affairs magazine, which has, according to Russel, Oneal and Cox ( 2000, p.584) “turned into one of the most influential recent books on international relations”. This article was called “the Clash of Civilizations?” and afterwards was extended (in 1996) to his book, called “The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order”. This book was meant to be seen as a response to his highly polarising and provocative article mentioned above. In it, he tries to give answers to the questions which arose from his article and tries to clarify his standpoints and claims to underpin his thesis. Samuel P. Huntington has given new currency to the notion of a clash of civilizations. His 1993 article on the topic in Foreign Affairs and his book following this article has gained a global audience.

Huntington argues that the bipolar division of the world based on ideology is no longer relevant. The world was entering a new period of intense conflict among civilizations. He states: “It is my hypothesis that the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily economic. The great divisions among humankind and the dominating source of conflict will be cultural. Nation states will remain them most powerful actors in world affairs, but the principal conflicts of global politics will occur between nations and groups of different civilizations. The clash of civilizations will dominate global politics. The fault lines between civilizations will be the battle lines of the future.” (Huntington, 1993, p.22) In trying to understand the causes of actual events like the 9/11 terror attacks on the United States of America many authors have turned to Samuel P. Huntington’s provocative and controversial thesis of a ‘clash of civilizations’. In the following part of my essay I am going to comment on his main issues, presenting the main thesis and his general claims of his book and article, dealing with a possible “clash of civilizations”.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Examines Huntington’s Foreign Affairs article alongside his later book
  • Considers realist and liberal explanations alongside civilizational explanations of interstate violence

Table of Contents

Introduction: Huntington´s Clash of Civilizations

1) The Thesis of a “Clash of Civilizations”

2) Huntington´s “Civilizations” and the Reason for a Clash

3) Civilizations and Conflict

4) Conclusion

Objectives and Themes

This book review examines Samuel P. Huntington’s thesis that cultural and civilizational differences will shape major conflicts in the post-Cold War world. It considers how Huntington defines civilizations and explains conflict, while questioning the relative importance of civilizational identity, nation states and other influences on international relations.

  • The post-Cold War international order
  • Huntington’s definition and classification of civilizations
  • Religion, cultural identity and civilizational fault lines
  • Relations between the West and Islamic societies
  • Nation states, alliances and interstate conflict
  • Realist and liberal alternatives to civilizational explanations

Excerpt from the Book

2) Huntington’s “Civilizations” and the Reasons for a “Clash”

The concept of ‘civilization’ is understood by Huntington as a ‘culture writ large’: “It is defined both by common objective elements, such as language, history, religion, customs, institutions, and by the subjective self-identification of people.” (Huntington 1996, p. 41) And because culture and cultural identities are shaping future patterns of cohesion, disintegration and conflict in the post Cold War period (Huntington 1996, p.20) most new emerging conflicts will be across civilization cleavages and fault lines. Therefore the net world war, if there is one, will be a war between civilizations. I think that civilization and culture are related concepts. The identity o f a civilization is important. Also civilizations are dynamic. They raise and fall, they divide and merge, disappear and are buried. Historians tell us that civilizations rise and fall with some frequency. Many ancient civilizations, once glorious and powerful, exist no more. Today, the civilizations of Rome, Greece, Egypt, Persia all have disappeared? They are on the ash heap of history.

Nowadays, Huntington identifies seven or eight major civilizations. Those are: Western, Confucian, Japanese, Islamic, Hindu, Slavic-Orthodox, Latin-American and possibly African. Islam has the shortest history at 1,400 years. Huntington’s list of civilizations is to some degree arbitrary and, to the extend to which he acknowledges intracivilizational differences, the image of civilization is a source of international order begins to dissolve. He claims that in effect that civilizational identities are typically more decisive than nationalism in accounting for sources of conflict. This is particularly doubtful in the case of the Islamic civilization, “where interests tied to particular states have repeatedly triumphed over Islamic or pan-Arabs segments”. (Russel, Oneal & Cox 2000, p.7) Maybe we can argue here that the relative youth of Islam is the cause of its belligerence. Islam is said to be in its adolescence and therefore is the most dangerous civilization for future international politics. But it is doubtful, if the latter one is true. It is true, I think, that the most important conflicts will appear along fault lines separating those civilizations from another. Huntington presents several reasons for this development. Conflicts may arise because of different history and historical experiences. Also the space on our world gets smaller, which automatically lead to increased interaction between civilizations. Furthermore, economic modernization, social changes and phenomenons like globalisation are separating the world population.

Chapter Summaries

Introduction: Huntington´s Clash of Civilizations: The introduction presents Huntington’s article and subsequent book, outlining his claim that cultural divisions will become a major source of international conflict.

1) The Thesis of a “Clash of Civilizations”: This chapter discusses Huntington’s account of the post-Cold War order and considers competing interpretations of differences between Western and Islamic societies.

2) Huntington´s “Civilizations” and the Reason for a Clash: The author examines Huntington’s definition of civilization, his proposed civilizational groupings and his explanations for conflict. The discussion also questions the unity of civilizations and the division of the world into the West and the rest.

3) Civilizations and Conflict: This chapter considers whether civilizational identity directly or indirectly influences alliances, trade, political systems and interstate disputes, alongside liberal and realist explanations.

4) Conclusion: The conclusion revisits the relationship between civilizational identity and conflict, weighing Huntington’s thesis against alternative explanations based on political and economic interests.

Keywords

Samuel P. Huntington, clash of civilizations, international relations, civilizational identity, post-Cold War order, cultural conflict, nation states, religion, Western societies, Islamic societies, realism, liberalism, interstate conflict

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this work about?

It is a book review and critical discussion of Samuel P. Huntington’s clash-of-civilizations thesis and its implications for international relations.

What are the main themes?

The work addresses cultural identity, religion, the post-Cold War order, relations between civilizations, nation states and explanations of international conflict.

What is the primary objective?

The author aims to present and assess Huntington’s principal claims, including his definition of civilizations and his explanation of why they might clash.

What method does the author use?

The author uses a critical review and discussion of Huntington’s article and book, drawing on other scholars’ arguments and cited empirical research. The work does not describe an original survey or experiment.

What does the main discussion cover?

It examines Huntington’s account of the new world order, his proposed civilizations and fault lines, and the potential influence of civilizational identity on international conflict.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include clash of civilizations, cultural identity, nation states, religion, interstate conflict, realism and liberalism.

How does the review approach Huntington’s classification of civilizations?

It describes the major civilizations Huntington identifies and questions whether internal differences and state interests are adequately captured by those groupings.

What alternatives to civilizational explanations does the author consider?

The review discusses political and economic interests, democracy, economic interdependence, and realist and liberal approaches as alternative ways of examining conflict.

Excerpt out of 14 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
A Response to Huntington´s "Clash of Civilizations": Civilizations vs Nation State
College
University of Münster
Grade
1,7
Author
Patrick Lubjuhn (Author)
Publication Year
2005
Pages
14
Catalog Number
V56913
ISBN (eBook)
9783638514781
ISBN (Book)
9783640667512
Language
English
Tags
Response Huntington´s Clash Civilizations Nation State
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Patrick Lubjuhn (Author), 2005, A Response to Huntington´s "Clash of Civilizations": Civilizations vs Nation State, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/56913
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract