Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › English Language and Literature Studies - Culture and Applied Geography

A Comparison of James Fenimore Cooper's "The Last of the Mohicans" and Robert Montgomery Bird's "Nick of the Woods"

Title: A Comparison of James Fenimore Cooper's "The Last of the Mohicans" and Robert Montgomery Bird's "Nick of the Woods"

Term Paper (Advanced seminar) , 2005 , 21 Pages , Grade: 1,3

Autor:in: Anonym (Author)

English Language and Literature Studies - Culture and Applied Geography
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Native Americans have played an important role in early American literature. After all, the Pilgrim Fathers and their descendants have had to deal with Native Americans from the very beginning, since the land on which the United States of America would be proclaimed in 1776 was already inhabited by tribes which were generally referred to as “Indians.” Over the decades and centuries, the image of Native Americans as depicted in novels and reports underwent quite a lot of dramatic changes. In this paper, the main focus will be laid on the image of Native Americans as it was drawn by two major novels of American literature: James Fenimore Cooper's “the Last of the Mohicans,” which was first published in 1826, and Robert Montgomery Bird's “Nick of the Woods,” which was published, eleven years after Cooper's work, in 1837. A reader familiar with both novels might notice that they represent two different approaches and attitudes towards Native Americans. On the one hand, there is Cooper who coined the term and image of the “Noble Savage,” depicting Native Americans as dignified, noble, honorable and beautiful “sons of the forest.” His work shows a comprehending attitude towards Native Americans, an attitude that is indicated in the introduction of his novel, where he claims that the native tribes were robbed of their territories by white settlers (Cooper 2). His image of Native Americans could be referred to as the “Eastern point of view.” On the other hand, there is Bird and what we could call the “Western point of view.” Bird directly attacks the image of Native Americans as Cooper drew it when he says in his introduction that
Cooper [...] had thrown a poetical illusion over the Indian character, [...]
[creating] a new style of the beau ideal – brave, gentle, loving, refined,
honorable romantic personages – nature's nobles (Bird 7). He claims that this picture is by no means an appropriate description of Native Americans and “that such conceptions as Uncas [...] are beautiful unrealities and fictions” (Bird 7). Another more subtle attack on Cooper's depiction of natives is found on page 43, where Bird mentions the tribes of the Delawares, Hurons and Shawnee. [...]

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Compares Native American representation in novels by Cooper and Bird

Contents

0 Introduction

1 Similarities and Differences of both Novels

1.1 Themes

1.1.1 The Theme of Flight

1.1.2 Aristocratic Romance

1.2 Equivalent Characters

1.3 Interracial Relationships

2 Native American Stereotypes – Racism in both Novels

2.1 Native Americans in Bird's “Nick of the Woods”

2.2 Native Americans in Cooper's “the Last of the Mohicans”

2.2.1 Cooper's “bad Indians” - the Hurons

2.2.2 Cooper's Prototype of the “bad Indian” - Magua

2.3 Cooper's “good Indians”

2.3.1 Chingachcook

2.3.2 Uncas

2.3.3 What makes an Indian “good?”

3 Conclusion

Objectives and Themes

This comparative literary study examines how James Fenimore Cooper's “the Last of the Mohicans” and Robert Montgomery Bird's “Nick of the Woods” represent Native Americans. It asks how far their apparently different portrayals overlap in their themes, characterisation and racial stereotypes.

  • Flight and aristocratic romance in the two novels
  • Correspondences between characters and their roles
  • Representations of interracial relationships
  • Racial stereotyping in Bird's novel
  • Cooper's contrasting portrayals of Native American characters
  • European cultural assumptions and the “Noble Savage”

Excerpt from the Book

1.2 Equivalent Characters

Duncan Heyward and Roland Forrester share many similarities. They are both enlisted in the respective armies of their times and both share the same rank, that of Captain. Moreover, they both derive from aristocratic origins and can be regarded as prototypes of the chivalrous gentleman, as they are depicted as proud, honorable, and so on. In fact, at one point Duncan even dreams about being a medieval “knight of ancient chivalry,” keeping guard over the princess he has rescued (Cooper 117). Additionally Roland does not drink, a trait of character that is not explicitly pointed out in Duncan, but can be assumed nonetheless, since it would perfectly fit into the rest of the galant picture drawn of his character. Both characters are said to be brave fighters and both have to rescue their lovers from the natives. Moreover, both of them are Easterners, with the slight difference that Duncan is depicted as a complete “greenhorn” who is quite naive and still has to learn a lot about frontier life. This is shown very clearly in his failed attempt to apprehend Magua (Cooper 33). While Roland shows traits of being a greenhorn, too, he is a little more accustomed to frontier life, since he is depicted as always being on the alert, as for example in the episode when his party encounters the almost dead native slaughtered by the Jibbenainosay and he instantly, almost without thinking, points his weapon at the alleged source of danger. Nonetheless, he gets the whole party lost in the woods.

The next pair of equivalent characters are Hawkeye and Nathan Slaughter. Both of them are experienced woodsmen who speak native languages. They both were raised with regard to Christian beliefs, which puts them into an awkward moral position, since they have to reconcile the Christian dogma of pacifism with their acts of violence. That both of them show signs of pacifism is very clearly indicated. For example does Hawkeye not kill Magua when he has the opportunity to do so in the cave in which Alice is held captive by the natives (Cooper 243f). Neither does he kill the medicine man form whom he steals the bear skin with which he disguises himself (Cooper 239). His pacifism is explicitly expressed on page 126, when, after Chingachcook killed the French sentinel, he says that “'Twould have been a cruel and unhuman act for a whiteskin” (Cooper 126). Thus, Hawkeyes's acts of violence derive from a necessity to do so in order not to be killed himself, because after all, life in the woods is full of dangers.

Chapter Summaries

0 Introduction: The introduction presents the two novels and their contrasting approaches to the representation of Native Americans. It establishes the basis for a closer comparison of their themes and characters.

1 Similarities and Differences of both Novels: This chapter compares flight, romance and equivalent characters across the novels. It also considers how both works portray interracial relationships.

2 Native American Stereotypes – Racism in both Novels: This chapter examines stereotypes in Bird's portrayal of Native Americans and in Cooper's depictions of the Hurons, Magua, Chingachcook and Uncas. It considers the cultural assumptions underlying Cooper's distinction between “good” and “bad” characters.

3 Conclusion: The conclusion brings together the study's assessment of racism and Eurocentrism in the two novels.

Keywords

Native American representation, James Fenimore Cooper, Robert Montgomery Bird, The Last of the Mohicans, Nick of the Woods, racial stereotypes, comparative literary analysis, Noble Savage, Eurocentrism, interracial relationships, frontier fiction, characterisation

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this work about?

It compares representations of Native Americans in James Fenimore Cooper's “the Last of the Mohicans” and Robert Montgomery Bird's “Nick of the Woods.”

What are its central themes?

The study addresses shared narrative themes, corresponding characters, interracial relationships, racial stereotypes and European cultural assumptions.

What is the main research question?

The work examines how the two novels portray Native Americans and how their apparently different approaches compare when their themes and characters are analysed more closely.

What method does the author use?

The author uses comparative literary analysis, discussing narrative themes, characters and passages from both novels.

What does the main analysis cover?

It compares the novels' plots and characters before examining Bird's depictions of Native Americans and Cooper's contrasting portrayals of the Hurons, Magua, Chingachcook and Uncas.

Which keywords characterise the work?

Key terms include Native American representation, racial stereotypes, comparative literary analysis, the Noble Savage, Eurocentrism and interracial relationships.

Which characters are compared across the novels?

The study pairs Duncan Heyward with Roland Forrester, Hawkeye with Nathan Slaughter, Alice Munro with Edith Forrester, and Cora Munro with Telie Doe.

How does the study approach Cooper's portrayal of Magua?

It examines Magua as Cooper's prototype of the “bad Indian,” considering both his characterisation and his criticism of white settlers.

Why are Chingachcook and Uncas discussed separately?

Their separate sections examine how each is characterised before the study considers the assumptions behind Cooper's portrayal of “good Indians.”

Excerpt out of 21 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
A Comparison of James Fenimore Cooper's "The Last of the Mohicans" and Robert Montgomery Bird's "Nick of the Woods"
College
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz  (FASK (Fachbereich für Angewandte Sprach- und Kulturwissenschaft))
Course
"White on Red" - Representation of Native Americans in US Film and Fiction
Grade
1,3
Author
Anonym (Author)
Publication Year
2005
Pages
21
Catalog Number
V58033
ISBN (eBook)
9783638523356
Language
English
Tags
James Fenimore Cooper Robert Montgomery Bird Nick of the Woods the Last of the Mohicans racism Native Americans racism in novels Noble Savage Injuns Cooper Bird Uncas Chingachcook Hawkeye
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Anonym (Author), 2005, A Comparison of James Fenimore Cooper's "The Last of the Mohicans" and Robert Montgomery Bird's "Nick of the Woods", Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/58033
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  21  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract