The aim of this paper is to outline the complexity of the representations of the ‘fallen woman.’ All representations involved the fear of deviancy and the attempt to preserve the social and moral order. However, the strategies to deal with the ‘problem’ called ‘fallen woman’ were divergent.
This paper is structured along modern forms of thinking. In Victorian times the differentiation of the religious, medical, judicial and literary fields was not as clear-cut as it is today. For this reason, the primary texts selected for the distinctive chapters might appear to belong to several discourses, not just the one assigned to them. It will become evident that the discourses on the ‘fallen woman’ reveal similar representations as well as contradictory ones. Even though the structure proposes the separation of the representations as victim and as threat, there are overlaps and the distinctions are not as definite as the outline suggests.
In order to demonstrate basic ideas about the ‘fallen woman,’ there will be a strong focus on the female prostitute. Many aspects of the discourse on the ‘fallen woman’ become clear when looking at the topic of prostitution, which was thematized in Victorian culture and politics. Moreover, the term ‘stereotype’ will play a major role in this analysis.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Victorian Background
2.1 Definition of the ‘Fallen Woman’
2.2 The Norm of ‘Respectable’ Femininity
3. The ‘Fallen Woman’ as a Social Threat
3.1 Representations of the ‘Fallen Woman’ in Medical Discourse
3.1.1 The ‘Unnaturalness’ of the ‘Fallen Woman’
3.1.2 The ‘Fallen Woman’ as a Warning and as a Scapegoat
3.2 Representations of the ‘Fallen Woman’ in Legal Discourse
3.2.1 The ‘Fallen Woman’ as an Object of Desire
3.2.2 The ‘Fallen Woman’ as Demonic and Criminal
4. The ‘Fallen Woman’ as a Victim
4.1 Representations of the ‘Fallen Woman’ in Religious Discourse
4.1.1 The ‘Woman’ in the Prostitute
4.1.2 Emotional Excess in Representing the ‘Fallen Woman’
4.2 Representations of the ‘Fallen Woman’ in Literary Discourse
4.2.1 Nancy as the ‘Fallen Woman’
4.2.2 Nancy as a Victim
5. Conclusion
6. Bibliography
Objectives & Themes
This paper explores the multifaceted representations of the ‘fallen woman’ within Victorian discourse, investigating how medicine, law, religion, and literature constructed this figure to maintain social and moral order. By examining the tension between the 'fallen woman' as a dangerous social threat and as a helpless victim in need of rescue, the study analyzes how these disparate portrayals served to reinforce bourgeois identity and the patriarchal status quo.
- Construction of femininity and the ‘fallen woman’ in Victorian society.
- Medical and legal pathologization of prostitution as a social threat.
- Religious and literary frameworks portraying the 'fallen woman' as a victim.
- The role of the 'harlot's progress' myth in shaping public and moral discourse.
- Analysis of Dickens’ literary representation of Nancy in Oliver Twist.
Excerpt from the Book
3.1.1 The ‘Unnaturalness’ of the ‘Fallen Woman’
Lamenting on “man’s degeneration,” the physician Edward John Tilt quotes Descartes: “If it be possible to perfect human nature, the means must be sought in the study of medicine.” Historians have been using medical discussions as a dominant discourse to portray constructions concerning sexuality as medical voices were heard in politics as well as in social affairs. The physical and moral ‘health’ of the woman determined the nation’s well-being as Edward Tilt said, the woman “is the matrix in which the human statue is cast. Improve her health of body, of mind, and of heart, and the human race would advance to perfection; deteriorate her, on the contrary, and in the same ratio does it degenerate.” In the same respect, Wardlaw stated:
By all historically recorded experience we are borne out in the assertion that the prevalence of this vice [prostitution] tends, in a variety of ways, to the deterioration of national character, - and to the consequent exposure of the nations among whom it abound to weakness, decline and fall.
The ‘fall’ of women, thus, was expected to result in the ‘fall’ of the entire nation. This myth created an enormous responsibility of women to be morally pure and chaste. At the same time, anxieties about women’s potential failures were produced with irresistible force. These concerns were projected onto women’s bodies in particular.
Summary of Chapters
1. Introduction: Outlines the complexity of representations of the 'fallen woman' as an outcast and threat, establishing the discursive and constructivist approach of the paper.
2. Victorian Background: Contextualizes the definition of the 'fallen woman' within the intersection of class and middle-class ideals of feminine purity and submissiveness.
3. The ‘Fallen Woman’ as a Social Threat: Examines how medical and legal discourses pathologized the 'fallen woman' as a source of physical and moral contamination.
4. The ‘Fallen Woman’ as a Victim: Analyzes the religious and literary strategies that recast the 'fallen woman' as a sympathetic victim to facilitate charitable intervention and social reform.
5. Conclusion: Summarizes how both the ‘threat’ and ‘victim’ narratives served to legitimize the Victorian ideological system by ostracizing the 'unnatural' woman.
6. Bibliography: Lists the academic, primary, and secondary sources used to support the discourse analysis.
Keywords
Fallen woman, Victorian era, discourse analysis, prostitution, femininity, social threat, victimhood, respectability, medical discourse, legal discourse, religious discourse, literature, Oliver Twist, gender roles, bourgeois identity
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the core subject of this research paper?
The paper examines how Victorian society constructed the concept of the 'fallen woman' through various key discourses—medicine, law, religion, and literature—to uphold moral and social order.
What are the primary thematic areas explored?
The study focuses on the 'fallen woman' as both a social threat, who endangers the national and moral fabric, and as a victim, who represents an unfortunate soul in need of redemption.
What is the central research aim?
The aim is to outline the complexity of these representations and to demonstrate that they were active constructions designed to manage anxieties regarding deviancy and femininity.
Which methodology is employed in this analysis?
The author uses a social approach to critical discourse analysis, viewing identity and concepts like the 'fallen woman' as constructed through societal texts and power-laden language.
What does the main body of the work cover?
The main sections move from the 'fallen woman' as a medical and legal 'threat' (scapegoating and criminalization) to her representation in religious and literary contexts as a 'victim' (the seduction myth and charity).
Which keywords define the scope of this work?
Key terms include 'fallen woman,' Victorian era, prostitution, femininity, social threat, victimhood, and discourse analysis.
How does the Victorian medical discourse frame the 'fallen woman'?
Medical discourse frequently pathologized the prostitute as 'unnatural' and 'contagious,' equating her sexual non-conformity with physical and societal disease.
What role does the 'seduction myth' play in the study?
The seduction myth is presented as a strategic narrative that frames the 'fallen woman' as a passive victim of external male vice, thereby allowing society to offer forgiveness and rehabilitation.
How does Charles Dickens characterize the 'fallen woman' in his work?
In Oliver Twist, the character Nancy is used to highlight the contradictions of Victorian morality; while she conforms to the 'harlot's progress' narrative through her death, Dickens also portrays her as a heroic and tender-hearted 'woman' worthy of compassion.
Why were 'fallen women' considered a threat to Victorian men?
They threatened to destabilize the social hierarchy and male control over sexuality, especially because men themselves were active participants in the trade of prostitution despite societal restrictions.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Tabea Halbmeyer (Autor:in), 2013, The fallen woman. Representations in dominant victorian discourses, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/926318
