My paper will illustrate the researcher´s (Nick Ellis) attempt to uncover the interplay of classroom humor, learners’ interaction, and incidental learning and explore how reliable and valid her study is in answering her research question. The second part of this paper discusses the theoretical basis of the study. The third part introduces the research design along with my reflections upon its upside and downside. Lastly, I will conclude with a discussion on the implication of the study and provide areas of further consideration for future studies on this topic.
Based on theories of psycholinguistics on how L2 learners could better internalize their target linguistic knowledge, this paper is a critical review of a resent instructed second language acquisition study on the different effect of playful and nonplayful incidental vocabulary learning during classroom instruction. This paper lays out a solid theoretical basis for the issue in focus, including a summary of studies on playful instructions and the role of incidental focus on form. The strengths and weaknesses of the target research are then discussed, from the perspective of its data collection and coding methods, and resluts analysis.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Critically reviews Bell’s study of playful and serious language-related episodes
- Examines a classroom study involving 16 international students
- 24 sources in the bibliography
- 3 figures
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Theoretical Basis
2.1 Cases of Humor Studies in ISLA and Psychological Research
2.2 The Role of Interaction and Playful Interaction
2.3 Incidental Focus on Form
3. A Critical Introduction of the Empirical Study
3.1 Information about the Research Site and Participants
3.2 Data Collection and Coding Methods
3.2.1 Description
3.2.2 Reflections
3.3 Post-test Results and Statistical Analysis
4. Conclusion
Objective and Topics
This paper critically reviews an instructed second language acquisition study that asks whether playful classroom interaction supports the incidental learning of language features. It examines the study’s theoretical foundations, research design and analysis to assess how reliably and validly it addresses that question.
- Humor, attention and memory in language learning
- Peer interaction and incidental focus on form
- Classroom observation and the coding of language-related episodes
- Post-tests and statistical analysis
- Validity, coder reliability and possible methodological improvements
Excerpt from the Book
3.2.1 Description
To examine the effect of playful and non-playful incidental focus on form, the researcher audio-recorded 12 of the 75-minute sessions using five digital voice recorders. The recording devices were used to capture multiple classroom group interactions that occurred simultaneously. That yielded a cumbersome set of data, with an average of 3.6 hours of conversation recorded per class session. Meanwhile, the researcher, along with two assistants, took observational notes of learners’ interactions in each class, paying particular attention to their acts of incidental focus-on-form (i.e., LREs) (Bell 2012: 246).
After each session, they listened to the recordings and identified all language-related episodes (LREs) that the participants spontaneously initiated. The data were then coded as interactions that were done playfully (PLREs) (e.g., learners making fun in conversations with the new words they have initiated.) and seriously (LREs). During the coding, cases that the researchers could not agree on were excluded (ibid. :247). Interestingly, probably due to a lack of existing coding systems, the researchers developed a coding scheme of their own, in which they attended to certain verbal and nonverbal cues suggesting playfulness. Instances of such cues include “register shifts, marked vocabulary choices, exaggerated intonation and nonverbal features such as laughter and smiling”(ibid. :250). The same classroom data were also coded as Meaning-focused (P)LREs and Form-focused (P)LREs. That coding follows another classroom study on the intentional teaching of humorous items (see Tocalli-Beller and Swain 2007: 154). Meaning-focused (P)LREs refer to a negotiation of language focusing on what a specific item means, and Form-focused (P)LREs refer to the discussion on the pronunciation, morphology, spelling of an item.
In the course of classroom observation, post-tests were conducted every three sessions. The tests were tailor-made based on the exact L2 items that the learners had talked about during their (P)LREs. The tests included only written tasks such as naming items in a picture or filling in the blank with the appropriate L2 items. The purpose is to see if the learners can recall the language items they have initiated in the previous class as a means to measure the effectiveness of (P)LREs on L2 learning (Bell 2012: 247). Notably, according to the researcher (ibid. :248), participants who were silent during the activities were excluded from the test, as “it was uncertain if they were paying attention in class”. Also, students who provided meta-lingual explanations were excluded, as they may have acquired the item under investigation.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The paper introduces the question of how classroom interaction and humor might contribute to incidental second language learning. It outlines the critical review’s focus on a non-interventionist empirical study.
2. Theoretical Basis: This chapter discusses research on humor and memory, interaction in second language acquisition, and incidental focus on form. It explains the theoretical concepts used to interpret language-related episodes.
3. A Critical Introduction of the Empirical Study: The author reviews the study’s participants, classroom setting, data collection, coding and post-tests. The chapter also considers methodological limitations and the interpretation of its statistical analysis.
4. Conclusion: The conclusion brings together the review’s assessment of the study’s theoretical and methodological contributions. It identifies limitations and suggests directions for future research.
Keywords
instructed second language acquisition, psycholinguistics, classroom interaction, humor, playful interaction, incidental learning, focus on form, language-related episodes, classroom observation, post-tests, coding reliability, research validity, statistical analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It critically reviews a study of whether playful classroom interactions can support the incidental learning of second language features.
What are its central topics?
The paper focuses on humor, peer interaction, incidental attention to language form and the methods used to study learning in a classroom.
What is the main research question?
The reviewed study investigates whether language items encountered in playful interactions are recalled differently from items encountered in serious interactions, including differences between attention to meaning and form.
What research method does the paper use?
The author conducts a critical review of a published empirical study, examining its theoretical basis, observational design, coding procedures, post-tests and statistical analysis. The reviewed study itself uses a non-interventionist classroom design.
What does the main body discuss?
It examines the study’s classroom context and participants, the collection and coding of interaction data, the post-tests and the statistical treatment of their results.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include instructed second language acquisition, playful interaction, incidental focus on form, language-related episodes, classroom observation and research validity.
How were playful interactions identified in the reviewed study?
Researchers coded language-related episodes using verbal and nonverbal cues of playfulness, including register shifts, intonation, laughter and smiling.
Why does the author discuss silent learners?
The reviewed study excluded silent participants from post-testing when their attention was uncertain. The author questions this choice and discusses whether observation methods could better identify attentive silent learners.
What statistical issue does the paper consider?
The author discusses whether small counts in some categories limit the use of a chi-square test when comparing recall associated with different types of interaction.
- Quote paper
- Minjie Song (Author), 2020, Playful Interactions and the Intake of Incidental Language Knowledge in the Classroom, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/947534