This paper discusses Gray’s statement: "Before we measure something, we must ask whether we understand what it is we are trying to measure", relating it to business performance management and management information system theories. With today’s knowledge of management - which involves the way of organizing humans and the use of computers to manage information systems - the paper highlights the importance of hidden values (intellectual capital) in business success, knowledge and performance management, measurement techniques and challenges as well as how communities of practice are managing to solve real firm’s problems and help it meet its goals.
It was argued by Gray (2015) that all businesses operate with specific sets of activities that result in their deliverables. The most challenging and important discussion topic, is how these business processes are effectively managed and measured against the firm’s objectives, as well as how companies measure the contribution of their intangible assets to business outcomes.
Intellectual capital is the intangible assets of an organization resulting from employees' physical efforts, knowledge assets and other results of human innovation and thoughts. Due to firms that have neglected intellectual capital to focus on finance and operations for many years, Leif E. (1991) describes intellectual capital as a hidden value and explains its importance on the company value. Intellectual capital, as argued by some scholars and authors, including Edvinsson, can take many forms.
At a glance
- Compares Bernard’s and Edvinsson and Malone’s intellectual capital classifications
- Uses the Essex police performance management framework as a measurement example
- 17 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Intellectual Capital
1.1. Intellectual capital categories
2. Knowledge Management
2.1. Aspect of Measurement
2.2. Communities of Practice/Interest
3. Performance Measurement and Challenges
4.1. Wrong Designing
4.2. Lack of leadership commitment
4.3 Ignoring change management in system implementation
4.4. Absence of Integration
4. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This paper critically considers Gray et al.’s proposition that understanding should precede measurement. It asks how organizations can understand and measure business performance and the contribution of intangible assets, drawing on discussions of intellectual capital, knowledge management, communities of practice and performance management.
- Categories of intellectual capital
- Knowledge sharing and information systems
- Measurement of knowledge and organizational performance
- Communities of practice and workplace learning
- Challenges in implementing performance management systems
Excerpt from the Book
Communities of Practice/Interest
Communities of practice are informal and self-selected groups of people who share the same expertise as well as the passion for a topic. For example in my organization, a team of project managers who meet regularly to exchange ideas on the actual humanitarian situation is a community of practice. Generally, they meet on a weekly basis but keep connected via emails and other social networks. Etienne C and William M (2000) argue that even if the community of practice may not have a clear agenda or the output knowledge are intangible, these communities of practice are known on the ability to improve the company’s performance. It is through these communities of practice that strategies are driven where participants can develop new business lines, develop professional skills, help the company to recruit and retain the best talents and share the best practices.
Even if the communities of practice add value to the company in several ways, the term itself is very recent in business vernacular. Although very few proactive companies have nurtured them, it’s not particularly easy to form, integrate communities of practice with the rest of organization and sustain them (Etienne and William, 2000). However, communities of practice are usually different depending on the reason for their existence. For instance people is the same company can choose to form a community of practice to maintain the connections with peers, due to the company’s decision to reorganize; people outside or inside the company may also form a community of practice, resulting the changes or new emergent strategy. In all cases, communities of practice can exist within the business unit or cross the divisional boundaries and there is no limit in the number of participants, except when larger communities of practice subdivide into geographical regions.
These commonly self-selected groups generate knowledge, especially if they are focusing on work related problems, they make the work easier. Even if, it requires investing time or money, Lesser J. Storc (2001) advise the managers to sustain communities of practice within their companies by identifying the potential groups able to enhance the company’s strategic capability, provide them with the necessary infrastructures and use the nontraditional methods to assess their values on the company’s progress. Here the best advised way is to listen to members ‘stories in a systematic way.
Chapter Summaries
Intellectual Capital: This chapter introduces intangible organizational assets and compares classifications of intellectual capital. It discusses human, structural and customer capital.
Knowledge Management: This chapter considers knowledge sharing, information technology and the coordination of people and resources. It also discusses approaches to measuring knowledge and performance.
Communities of Practice/Interest: This section describes self-selected groups that share expertise and address workplace problems, including an example involving project managers.
Performance Measurement and Challenges: This chapter outlines performance objectives and reviews, then examines challenges involving system design, leadership commitment, change management and integration.
Conclusion: The author brings together intellectual capital, communities of practice and information systems, emphasizing the need for measurements suited to each organization.
Keywords
intellectual capital, human capital, structural capital, customer capital, knowledge management, knowledge sharing, communities of practice, performance measurement, performance management, management information systems, key performance indicators, organizational objectives
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the paper about?
It examines the need to understand what is being measured in the context of business performance and intangible assets.
What are its central themes?
The paper addresses intellectual capital, knowledge management, communities of practice and performance measurement.
What is the paper’s primary objective?
It explores how organizations can understand their activities and intangible assets when developing performance measures aligned with their goals.
What scientific method does the author use?
The paper offers a conceptual discussion drawing on published literature and examples. It does not describe an original survey, experiment or formal empirical research method.
What does the main body cover?
It discusses forms of intellectual capital, knowledge management and measurement, communities of practice, and challenges in performance management.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include intellectual capital, knowledge management, communities of practice, performance measurement and management information systems.
How does the paper distinguish forms of intellectual capital?
It presents different classifications, including Edvinsson and Malone’s distinction between human, structural and customer capital.
What example of a community of practice does the author provide?
The author describes project managers in their organization who meet regularly to exchange ideas about the humanitarian situation.
Which performance management challenges are discussed?
The paper identifies problems with system design, leadership commitment, change management and integration with other organizational systems.
- Quote paper
- Dr. Sixbert Sangwa (Author), 2017, Intellectual Capital and Knowledge Management. Performance Measurement and Challenges, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1014897