"Let them be sea-captains, if you will", Margaret Fuller stated in her main work
Woman in the Nineteenth Century (Woman 346). Although even nowadays there may
be only few female sea-captains, the quoted statement would hardly provoke anyone, at least not someone in our contemporary western culture. However, when regarded in its historical context, two questions arise: Firstly, what underlying gender concept encouraged Fuller to make such a statement, in "a time of excessive gender polarization" (Bomarito (vol2) 1), a time in which the ideal of domesticity and Republican Motherhood (Freedman 25) determined the role of woman? And secondly, how did antebellum American society react to such statements? The first question will be the main issue of part III, the main part of my work. I will begin with Fuller's general gender concept that involves ideas of androgynity and the "degendering" (Davis 182) of language. Next, the major influences on her concept, namely those of transcendentalism (with special consideration of Emerson), Goethe, Fourier and Swedenborg will be dealt with. Lastly, I will consider how Fuller applied her concept to the specific fields outlined in chapter II, that is, marriage, education and
economy. I will concentrate on her main work Woman in the Nineteenth Century
because Fuller describes her gender concept there in most detail, whereas her other works such as Summer on the Lakes do not contribute much additional information that is of special significance for the understanding of her gender concept. This is especially true in the case of her Memoirs, which was heavily edited and censored by Emerson and others. It rather distorted Fuller's reputation, as Urbanski states (5). Therefore I will only occasionally refer to them, whenever they provide further information that is relevant to my topic.
Regarding the second question, I will illustrate the historical and cultural
background first against which Fuller placed her gender concept, in order to clarify why her "idea of woman" (W 305) was considered provoking and unconventional in antebellum America. I will deal with the traditional gender concept, along with its ideals such as femininity, Republican Motherhood and domesticity. Then, I will describe the effect this concept had on marriage, evangelical movements, education and economy, and also with what is considered the initiation of the first women's rights movement in America, the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848.
At a glance
- Grade: 2.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Analyzes Fuller’s gender concept primarily through Woman in the Nineteenth Century
- Examines the influences of transcendentalism, Emerson, Goethe, Fourier and Swedenborg
- Applies a gender-studies perspective to women’s active formation of gender identity
- 51 sources in the bibliography
Contents
I. Introduction
II. Overview of the Traditional Gender Concept in Antebellum America, Its Consequences for Women and Women’s Resistance
1. Emergence of the Separate Spheres Ideology
1.1 Beginning of Gender Polarization
1.2 Motherhood and Domesticity
1.3 Marriage
2. The Role of Women in Religious Movements During the First and Second Great Awakening
2.1 First and Second Great Awakening
2.2 Women’s Role in the Abolitionist Movement
2.3 Women’s Role in the Temperance Movement
3. Women, Education and Economy
3.1 Education
3.2 Economy
4. The Women’s Rights Movement
III. Fuller’s Gender Concept
1. Criticism of the Prevailing Gender Concept
2. Femininity, Masculinity and the “De-Gendering” of Language
3. The Concept of the Multidimensional and Androgynous Soul
4. Major Influences
4.1 Transcendentalism, Emerson and Religion
4.2 Goethe, Fourier and Swedenborg
5. Application of the Gender Concept
5.1 Fuller’s Marriage Ideal
5.2 Education
5.3 Economy
IV. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This study asks what conception of gender underpinned Margaret Fuller’s challenges to conventional roles and how her ideas related to antebellum American society. It places her writing in its historical context and examines her intellectual influences and views on marriage, education and economic opportunity.
- Separate spheres, domesticity and Republican Motherhood
- Women’s participation in religious and reform movements
- Fuller’s account of femininity, masculinity and the androgynous soul
- Transcendentalism and other philosophical influences
- Marriage, education and work in Fuller’s thought
Excerpt from the Book
Beginning of Gender Polarization
In the following text, I will concentrate on north-eastern America during the antebellum period from around 1790 to 1850, or, to be more precise, the New England area, because here the changes in society were most exemplary and had a profound influence on Margaret Fuller. New England can be regarded as the intellectual center of nineteenth-century America (Epstein 2-3).
Soon after America had declared its independence from England in 1776 and had become an independent nation, several momentous processes, among them the emergence of the market economy and a middle, or "middling" class gradually began to transform society and had far-reaching influences: Religion, philosophy, politics and economy were profoundly influenced (Epstein 2-3). I will concentrate on those processes which were of special significance to the change of gender identities and relations that took place at that time.
As the processes of industrialization, urbanization and, as a result, the growth of the market economy dramatically accelerated in the beginning of the nineteenth century, family life was transformed considerably. There were changes in the economy due to the gradual transition from agricultural subsistence farming and family businesses to impersonal public markets, which peaked in the 1830s under President Andrew Jackson (Ross 113). Especially after the 1830s, the self-sustaining family economy was more and more replaced by workers who worked on the public market place (Bomarito (vol2) 1).
More and more men moved with their families from rural areas to cities. They did so because work in industries promised better wages and hence more comfort and wealth. Yet the market place also demanded men to become more competitive and self-assertive than ever. Wealth, power and fame were taken as measures of individual achievement which in turn defined one's self-worth (Epstein 69). Qualities such as morality, religiosity and fidelity were not considered men’s strengths though they were deemed desirable. Men were considered mentally and physically superior to women and thus regarded as her natural "protector” (Bomarito (vol2) 1-2; Theriot 17).
Women were from the beginning of industrialization excluded from the market economy and were expected to fully concentrate on their "domestic duties", at least in the cities. In rural areas women's participation in making a living for the family remained higher: They had to participate in their husband's field work and other chores, while women in cities could concentrate more fully on their roles as mother and housewives. It is generally agreed that the Victorian Age was one of “excessive gender polarisation” which brought with it the emergence of the separate spheres ideology (Bomarito (vol2) 1; Boyer 306). The problem of classifying certain traits into the strict categories of feminine and masculine became the subject of philosophy and science during this time of industrialization. Scholars of gender studies generally agree that until 1800 this had been no major issue (“Gender Studies”).
Chapter Summaries
I. Introduction: The author establishes the questions and historical scope of the study and explains its gender-studies perspective.
II. Overview of the Traditional Gender Concept in Antebellum America, Its Consequences for Women and Women’s Resistance: This chapter examines separate spheres, women’s roles in reform movements, education and work, and the emergence of organized women’s rights activism.
III. Fuller’s Gender Concept: The main chapter analyzes Fuller’s criticism of conventional gender roles, her concept of an androgynous soul, her intellectual influences and her views on marriage, education and the economy.
IV. Conclusion: The author brings together the analysis of Fuller’s ideas, their historical context and their relationship to later discussions of gender.
Keywords
Margaret Fuller, gender, antebellum America, separate spheres, androgyny, transcendentalism, self-reliance, women’s rights, Republican Motherhood, marriage, education, women’s work, gender studies
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the work about?
It examines Margaret Fuller’s conception of gender in relation to the social and intellectual context of antebellum America.
What are its central themes?
Its themes include gender roles, separate spheres, women’s rights, androgyny, self-reliance, marriage, education and work.
What is the main research question?
The study asks what gender concept informed Fuller’s challenges to conventional roles and how her ideas related to the society of her time.
What method does the author use?
The author uses a gender-studies perspective and interprets Fuller’s writing alongside historical and literary scholarship.
What does the main part of the work discuss?
It analyzes Fuller’s criticism of prevailing gender concepts, her account of femininity and masculinity, her intellectual influences and her views on marriage, education and the economy.
Which keywords characterize the study?
Key terms include Margaret Fuller, gender, androgyny, transcendentalism, separate spheres, self-reliance and women’s rights.
Which of Fuller’s works receives the closest attention?
The analysis concentrates on Woman in the Nineteenth Century, while occasionally referring to other writings, including Summer on the Lakes.
Which thinkers are considered as influences on Fuller?
The study examines transcendentalism and Ralph Waldo Emerson, as well as Goethe, Fourier and Swedenborg.
How does the study place Fuller in her historical setting?
It considers the separate spheres ideology and women’s involvement in religious revival, abolitionism, temperance and the early women’s rights movement.
- Citar trabajo
- M. A. Oliver Steinert-Lieschied (Autor), 2007, Margaret Fuller's Concept of “Gender” in the context of her time, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/113451