Especially after the recession, it is of interest whether electronic reverse auctions (eRAs), as e-procurement tool with a high cost saving potential, are attractive for companies. Therefore, the purpose of this study is the investigation of the current eRA adoption and future eRA prospects in terms of extent and way of usage in the Austrian automotive industry. Data were collected from purchasing managers and purchasing agents of 20 companies which belong to the 24 top-selling Austrian automotive companies. Quantitative data was collected from 20 companies regarding the extent of eRA usage. Furthermore, 18 of these participated in semi-structured interviews for qualitative data collection regarding reasons for (not) using eRAs and the way of eRA usage. Results of the data analysis show that the extent of eRA usage is and will remain quite low in the Austrian automotive industry and even adopters’ eRA spending is fairly low. In conclusion, eRAs do not seem to contribute a lot to achieve cost savings in the Austrian automotive industry and are considered to be rather disliked by Aus-trian automotive buyers. Although findings cannot be generalised to the whole Austrian automotive industry they still might have the implication that buyer-supplier cooperation will prevail in the Austrian automotive industry in the future as it obviously contributes more to gain a sustainable competitive supply chain advantage than eRAs. Moreover, if other industries and countries have similar attitudes towards eRAs as Austrian automotive buyers, it might have negative implications on eRA tool providers, though this needs to be investigated in further research.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Telephone survey of 20 companies and interviews with 18 of them
- Interview guides for auction adopters and non-adopters included
- 93 sources in the bibliography
- 6 figures and 2 tables
Table of Contents
MSC DISSERTATION LICENCE
DECLARATION
ABSTRACT
TABLE OF CONTENT
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND, SUBJECT AND REASONS FOR SUBJECT CHOICE
1.2 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES AND QUESTIONS
1.3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
1.4 LIMITATIONS OF THE RESEARCH
1.5 RESEARCH STRUCTURE
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 PROCUREMENT IN SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
2.1.1 e-procurement
2.1.2 e-auctions
2.2 ELECTRONIC REVERSE AUCTIONS
2.2.1 Mode of operation
2.2.2 Benefits and criticisms
2.2.3 Future prospects
2.2.4 Adopters
2.3 THE AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY
2.3.1 eRA adoption in the automotive industry
2.3.2 The Austrian automotive industry
3 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
4 METHODOLOGY
4.1 RESEARCH PURPOSE
4.2 RESEARCH APPROACH
4.3 RESEARCH STRATEGY
4.3.1 Sampling
4.4 DATA COLLECTION METHOD
4.4.1 Primary data collection through a telephone survey and semi-structured interviews
4.5 DATA ANALYSIS
4.5.1 Computer Assisted Qualitative Data Analysis
4.5.2 Data analysis with NVivo
5 FINDINGS, ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
5.1 CURRENT EXTENT OF ERA USAGE
5.1.1 Non-adoption reasons and criticisms
5.1.2 Adoption reasons and benefits
5.2 CURRENT WAY OF ERA USAGE
5.2.1 General way of usage
5.2.2 Before the auction
5.2.3 Auction
5.2.4 After the auction
5.3 FUTURE PROSPECTS FOR THE EXTENT OF ERA USAGE
5.4 FUTURE PROSPECTS FOR THE WAY OF ERA USAGE
6 CONCLUSION
6.1 CONCLUSION OF RESEARCH
6.2 RELIABILITY AND VALIDITY
6.3 CONSTRAINTS, LIMITATIONS AND IMPLICATIONS
6.4 FURTHER RESEARCH
Objectives and Themes
This dissertation investigates how extensively and in what ways Austrian automotive companies use electronic reverse auctions, why they adopt or avoid them, and how they intend to use them in the future.
- Electronic procurement and reverse auction procedures
- Benefits, criticisms and buyer-supplier relationships
- Current adoption and reasons for non-adoption
- Auction formats, sourced items and supplier selection
- Future adoption intentions and procurement practices
Excerpt from the Book
2.2.1 Mode of operation
In an eRA, one buyer, several suppliers and an auction software provider are involved (Parente et al., 2004; Arnold et al., 2005; Emiliani, 2005). Additionally, to providing the auction platform, software providers offer service-support for inexperienced auctioneers or ones with just a small auction spending. More experienced auctioneers or ones with a huge auction spending rather bring auctions in-house as this will be more cost efficient (Mabert and Skeels, 2002; Hur et al., 2006; Hur et al., 2007). The more service is consumed from an auction provider, the higher are the costs (Arnold et al., 2005). eRA costs have to be paid either as a monthly fee or as a commission percentage of the savings achieved (Kumar and Maher, 2008). Mabert and Skeels (2002) found, that in 2002 a monthly fee for an auction software provider was about $ 75,000 including consulting, support and commission. For another provider the fee was 5%-25% of the purchase price savings depending on their monetary value (Mabert and Skeels, 2002). When eRAs are adopted, not just the eRA fee but the total cost of ownership (TCO) should be taken into account (Jap, 2002; Arnold et al., 2005; Tassabehji et al., 2006; Hur et al., 2007). Thus, not just resource requirements, but also supplier switching costs have to be considered (Mabert and Skeels, 2002; Wagner and Schwab, 2004; Emiliani and Stec, 2005; Kumar and Chang, 2007; Amelinckx et al., 2008; Caniels and Raaij, 2009; Razuk et al., 2009). Once, eRAs are implemented in a company, several preparations need to made before the auction can take place.
The first step is the buyer’s decision which goods or services are intended to be sourced. Yet, not everything is suitable for sourcing via eRAs. Product or service requirements have to be clearly defined in an RFQ (request for quotation) which cannot be altered anymore once it is sent out to the suppliers (Mabert and Skeels, 2002; Carter et al., 2004; Kaufmann and Carter, 2004; Wagner and Schwab, 2004; Kumar and Chang, 2007; Amelinckx et al., 2008; Crane, 2008; Caniels and Raaij, 2009; Razuk et al., 2009; Hawkins et al., 2010). This makes the information exchange in eRAs between buyer and suppliers quite restricted (Nair, 2005; Lösch and Lambert, 2007). Hence, just items with exactly known buying parameters at the time of preparing the RFQ can be sourced via eRAs (Jap, 2002; Mabert and Skeels, 2002; Daly and Nath, 2005; Tassabehji et al., 2006; Lösch and Lambert, 2007; Amelinckx et al., 2008). Make-to-order goods are thus not suitable (Caniels and Raaij, 2009; Razuk et al., 2009; Hawkins et al., 2010). Apart from that, generally all kinds of goods and services can be sourced via eRAs (Kaufmann and Carter, 2004; Hur et al., 2006; Razuk et al., 2009).
Chapter Summaries
1 INTRODUCTION: Introduces the research context, objectives, questions, methodology and limitations.
2 LITERATURE REVIEW: Examines electronic procurement and reverse auctions, including their operation, benefits and criticisms, and considers the automotive industry.
3 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK: Develops a model of current adoption and future usage intentions and presents two propositions for investigation.
4 METHODOLOGY: Explains the exploratory design, company selection, telephone survey, interviews and NVivo-supported qualitative analysis.
5 FINDINGS, ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION: Compares participants’ accounts of adoption, auction practices and future intentions with the literature and propositions.
6 CONCLUSION: Answers the research questions and considers reliability, validity, limitations, implications and further research.
Keywords
electronic reverse auctions, e-procurement, Austrian automotive industry, supply chain management, sourcing, purchasing, auction adoption, buyer-supplier relationships, supplier selection, procurement strategy, semi-structured interviews, NVivo, future usage intentions
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the dissertation about?
It examines the adoption and prospective use of electronic reverse auctions by Austrian automotive companies.
What are its central themes?
Its themes include procurement practices, reasons for adoption and non-adoption, auction operation, supplier relationships and future intentions.
What is the main research objective?
The objective is to understand the extent and manner of current reverse auction use and companies’ intentions for future use.
What research methods are used?
The exploratory study combines a telephone survey of 20 companies with semi-structured interviews at 18 of those companies. Qualitative data are analysed with NVivo.
What does the main analysis cover?
It discusses current usage, adoption barriers and benefits, auction practices before, during and after bidding, and future prospects.
Which keywords characterise the study?
Key terms include electronic reverse auctions, e-procurement, Austrian automotive industry, sourcing, supplier relationships and adoption intentions.
How were companies selected?
The researcher selected automotive companies from the 2008 TREND list of Austria’s largest companies using a non-probability approach focused on likely adopters.
What role do buyer-supplier relationships play?
The study examines how auction use relates to existing supplier relationships, trust, supplier selection and cooperation.
What research material accompanies the analysis?
Interview guides for adopters and non-adopters are included, alongside a model of factors influencing auction reuse intentions.
- Quote paper
- Nora Rienhuber (Author), 2010, Current adoption and future prospects of electronic reverse auctions in the Austrian automotive industry, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/163954