In her novel “Baumgartner’s Bombay’ Anita Desai confronts the reader with a protagonist whose life is a chain of happenings not intended, wished for or fought against by him. It seems Hugo Baumgartner is not even aware of the probability that his own willful intervention into the course of his personal history could change matters for him. When he is murdered eventually the reader asks herself if this sudden and drastic end really differs from a natural death since Baumgartner’s life without social relations, active engagement in anything he is dedicated to or even a plain economic use for society did not appear to be important or of a unique value for many people. The brutal and cold fact is: Hugo Baumgartner will not be missed
The young Hugo Baumgartner is referred to by his first name. His mother and father call him “Hugo” or give him pet names (“you booby” (25); “Hugo, Liebling” (29)) and even the heterodiegetic narrator joins in this very familiar, caring and friendly form of address. Later on only Lotte will continue calling him “Hugo” (“Ach, du lieber Gott, Hugo” (68)) since she is the only one of his acquaintances in life who is present continuously, except for the time he is interned. Furst even calls her “a grotesque substitute mother” (Furst 171), an interpretation made possible by the end when she is (involuntarily) left by Baumgartner but keeps the letters of his natural mother. The facts that she is also a German and did not succeed in the Indian society create a bond between them although their lifestyles differ drastically.
This paper wants to examine possible reasons why he failed to live a fulfilled life after he had escaped the brutal Nazi regime. Major points of interest will be the psychological dysfunctions related to survivor guilt and melancholia, the impact of religion on integration and disintegration and his general problem to develop and administer his own will.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Applies Alejandro Portes’s three levels of immigrant reception to Baumgartner
- Uses Peter Bieri’s account of will to examine Baumgartner’s decisions
- Examines the Wandering Jew motif in Anita Desai’s novel
- 15 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Survivor Guilt
3. Melancholy
4. Hugo Baumgartner’s Will
5. Baumgartner’s Mode of Incorporation
6. Religion and Integration – The Wandering Jew as an Anaphoric Device
7. Rudiments of Ethnocentrism in Baumgartner’s Bombay
8. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This literary study asks why Hugo Baumgartner, the protagonist of Anita Desai’s Baumgartner’s Bombay, struggles to lead a fulfilled life after escaping Nazi Germany. It examines how psychological distress, personal agency, religion and social conditions shape his experience of exile and integration in India.
- Survivor guilt and the memory of family loss
- Melancholy, passivity and personal agency
- Immigrant reception and social incorporation
- Jewish identity and the Wandering Jew motif
- Ethnocentrism, belonging and exclusion
Excerpt from the Book
3. Melancholy
After being released from the internment camp, Baumgartner returns to Calcutta where he had found a job and amused himself in bars and night clubs just as other young men before he was caught by British authorities. The description of the city where revolution rages foreshadows Baumgartner’s fate: “The streets were black with litter, the lights broken, the odour of decay strong.” (162) Just as the town lost its desirable atmosphere of light pleasure and ease, Baumgartner will not find back to the peaceful, innocent life he has led for a short while there, “the hopelessness of Calcutta was to become a part of his own experience now”. (167) When he tries to find work with his former employer, Baumgartner has to learn that his Muslim friend is eager to leave himself and advises him to meet another salesman in Bombay. However, Baumgartner dismisses both the option to take over Habibullah’s business in Calcutta and the possibility of finding an occupation with Chimanlal in Bombay. Hehlmann translates the Greek term melancholia with gloom, megrim. Furthermore he defines it as weariness accompanied by a tendency to brood. He, similar to Rüsen, explains by referring to Binswanger that melancholic people do not have a future since their experience of the present is disturbed by a continuous operation of the past in their perceiving minds. In other words, Baumgartner is held back by the unchangeable events of his past and therefore ponders too much or simply freezes his active participation in society instead of deciding what his next steps should be in order to carry on a worthwhile life. Desai exemplifies his state of mind literally and metaphorically:
[H]e got up and went, promising to think over the matter of Bombay. Instead, he made his way to the old, crowded, slum‐like house off Free School Street, in the lane too narrow for traffic […] Baumgartner found no joy in the streets where he walked aimlessly, compulsively, in order to put off going back to his room. (171)
His unsatisfied restlessness, the repulsion he feels even of his own home and on top of this the description of dirty streets that guarantee to house desperately poor people and all their misery expose his resignation and mournfulness.
Consequently, what Furst calls Baumgartner’s “accepting” is not the just the willful capitulation before the course of history but rather an inward, emotional power that lets him resign from any active decision‐making out of frustration and weariness.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The study introduces Baumgartner’s apparent passivity and sets out its question about his life after escaping Nazi Germany.
2. Survivor Guilt: The author considers Baumgartner’s grief for his mother alongside psychological and social manifestations of survivor guilt, including his care for stray cats.
3. Melancholy: Baumgartner’s return to Calcutta is examined through accounts of melancholy and the continuing influence of the past on his present.
4. Hugo Baumgartner’s Will: Peter Bieri’s account of will provides a framework for discussing Baumgartner’s responses to opportunities for work and friendship.
5. Baumgartner’s Mode of Incorporation: The chapter applies Alejandro Portes’s model of immigrant reception to political, social and ethnic dimensions of Baumgartner’s life in India.
6. Religion and Integration – The Wandering Jew as an Anaphoric Device: The author explores Jewish identity, the Wandering Jew motif and encounters with religion and community in the novel.
7. Rudiments of Ethnocentrism in Baumgartner’s Bombay: Concepts of ethnocentrism and collective identity are used to discuss distinctions between belonging and exclusion.
8. Conclusion: The study brings together its psychological, religious and social explanations of Baumgartner’s difficulties with integration.
Keywords
Anita Desai, Baumgartner’s Bombay, Hugo Baumgartner, literary analysis, exile, survivor guilt, melancholy, personal agency, immigrant incorporation, Jewish identity, Wandering Jew, ethnocentrism, belonging, integration
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this study about?
It examines Hugo Baumgartner’s life in Anita Desai’s Baumgartner’s Bombay, focusing on his difficulties after fleeing Nazi Germany for India.
What are its central themes?
The study addresses survivor guilt, melancholy, personal agency, immigrant reception, religion, Jewish identity and ethnocentrism.
What is the main research question?
The author asks why Baumgartner struggles to lead a fulfilled life after escaping the Nazi regime.
What method does the author use?
The work uses literary analysis, interpreting scenes and character development through psychological, philosophical, sociological and cultural concepts.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers Baumgartner’s responses to family loss, his decisions about work and relationships, his reception in India, and the roles of religion and ethnocentrism.
Which keywords characterize the study?
Key terms include exile, survivor guilt, melancholy, personal agency, immigrant incorporation, Jewish identity and belonging.
How is Portes’s model used?
The study uses the model’s three levels of immigrant reception to examine government policy, social and economic reception, and ethnic community in Baumgartner’s experience.
Why does the study discuss the Wandering Jew?
It considers the literary motif in relation to Baumgartner’s Jewish origins, displacement and search for belonging.
How does the study approach Baumgartner’s care for cats?
It discusses his care for stray cats in relation to survivor guilt and his relationships with other people.
- Citar trabajo
- Ulrike Löbel (Autor), 2010, Inner and Outer Rejections of a refugee: Anita Desai´s "Baumgartner´s Bombay`", Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/165446