Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › African Studies

Tracking Rwandan Progress in Addressing Learning Crisis in Madagascar (2009–2023)

Comparative study of Madagascar and Rwanda

Summary Excerpt Details

Madagascar is one of the poorest countries in the world. This phrase is ubiquitous, in newspapers, documentaries and books of all kinds. For anyone with common sense, this fact can only be alarming and should, more than ever, spur us all on to find a lasting remedy. The present research ambitions to make a small contribution to this pharaonic task of combating poverty. However, when it comes to development, we often take countries like the United States of America, China and many others as benchmarks. Although they are developed, their socio-historical and cultural contexts are distinct from those of African countries. It is no surprise, therefore, that a development model that has been crowned with success in those nations may, to some extent, turn out be a spectacular failure in the particular world of Africa. Which, by the same token, justifies our choice of Rwanda as subject of study. In this sense, the socio-economic development of the country steams from these following six factors, such as: visionary leadership, unparalleled political stability, intolerance to corruption, an attractive and secure business environment, firm determination to join the Commonwealth and, finally, revolutionary social security reforms. Aware of the country's strengths and weaknesses as being landlocked, the Rwandan government has tailored its programmes to match the country's potentials. What's more, in the absence of political upheaval since the 1994 genocide, Rwanda has become a haven of peace for national and international investors, which subsequently contributed to improving their business environment. Besides, unlike in numerous African countries where impunity reigns supreme, Kagame administration has an uncompromising stance towards public funds embezzlement or other forms of corruption, and imposes heavy penalties for those found guilty. Ergo, aids or budgets allocated to development have the luxury and privilege of being put to good use. Furthermore, Rwanda broke free from the stranglehold of ‘Françafrique’ by joining the Commonwealth in 2009, without which its economy would remain extroverted, like most of former French colonies. Finally, in an effort to protect the population against financial risks associated with ailments, the Rwandan regime has set itself the task of making health insurance accessible to the general public. In short, Rwanda's economic, social and political success could be attributable to the harmonious synergy of all these elements.

Excerpt


TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

ABSTRACT

RESUME

FINTINA

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

LIST OF MAPS

LIST OF TABLES

LIST OF PHOTOS

LIST OF FIGURES

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

CHAPTER I:

BACKGROUND CONTEXT OF THE REPUBLIC OF RWANDA
1. DESCRIPTION OF THE PLACE
1.1. Overview of Rwanda’s geography
1.2. Historical background of Rwanda
1.2.1. Rwanda under German (1890-1916) and Belgian (1916-1962) occupation
1.2.2. The 1994 Genocide

CHAPTER II:

CONCEPTUAL, THEORITICAL FRAMEWORKS AND LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Developmental state theory
2.1.1. Historical background of developmental state theory
2.1.2. Definitions of developmental state or developmentalism
2.2. Literature review
2.2.1. Rwandan strategies and enforcement of developmentalism
2.2.2. Impact of developmentalism strategies on Rwandan population

CHAPTER III:

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1. Data collection methods
3.1.1. Bibliographical study
3.1.2. Video content analysis
3.1.3. Questionnaires
3.1.4. Interviews

CHAPTER IV:

FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS OF RESULTS
4.1. Results from primary data collection
4.1.1. Visionary leadership
4.1.2. Political stability
4.1.3. Zero tolerance for corruption
4.1.4. Business environment
4.1.5. Adhesion to the Commonwealth
4.1.6. Social security reform
4.2. Results from secondary data collection
4.2.1. Questionnaires
4.2.2. Interpretation of questionnaire’s results
4.2.3. Interviews
4.3. Observing the Malagasy situation through the lens of Rwanda
4.3.1. Leadership
4.3.2. Political stability
4.3.3. Business environment
4.3.4. Corruption level
4.3.5. Social security conditions
4.3.6. Membership to the Commonwealth

CONCLUSION

BIBLIOGRAPHY

WEBOGRAPHY

APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Questionnaires in English version for the English department students
Appendix 2: Questionnaires in the History and French department students
Appendix 3: An excerpt of transcript of President Kagame’s interview with Aljazeera’s journalist Riz Khan, 28 January 2011
Appendix 4: An excerpt of transcript of President Kagame speaking as guest lecturer at Harvard Business School, Boston, 26 February 2016
Appendix 5: Summary of Interview with Hemerson Andrianetrazafy (Mahamasina - September 27, 2024)

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

First and foremost, praise and glory be to God the Almighty, whose abundant blessings have sustained me throughout this journey. His generous endowment of health and strength was indispensable to the successful completion of this research work.

In addition, I am deeply indebted to my research supervisor, Dr. Harilala Miaratiana ANDRIANARIVELO, for her exceptional guidance and unwavering availability. Her astute insights and encouragement have inspired me to transcend my limits and pursue excellence. It has been a true honor to work and learn under her mentorship.

I also extend my heartfelt thanks to Hemerson ANDRIANETRAZAFY, academic, professor of art history, poet, and artist for graciously consenting to participate in an interview.

On top of that, I would like to convey my sincere appreciation to all lecturers and educators within the Department of Anglophone Studies. Their wisdom and expertise have significantly contributed to shaping my intellectual and personal growth.

I am profoundly grateful to my parents for their boundless love and sacrifices throughout my education. Their unfaltering support has been pivotal in my educational journey.

Lastly, I wish to acknowledge all those who have provided support, whether directly or indirectly, in the completion of this research. Your contributions have been invaluable.

ABSTRACT

Madagascar is one of the poorest countries in the world (World Bank, 2023). This phrase is ubiquitous, in newspapers, documentaries and books of all kinds. For anyone with common sense, this fact can only be alarming and should, more than ever, spur us all on to find a lasting remedy. The present research ambitions to make a small contribution to this pharaonic task of combating poverty. However, when it comes to development, we often take countries like the United States of America, China and many others as benchmarks. Although they are developed, their socio- historical and cultural contexts are distinct from those of African countries. It is no surprise, therefore, that a development model that has been crowned with success in those nations may, to some extent, turn out be a spectacular failure in the particular world of Africa. Which, by the same token, justifies our choice of Rwanda as subject of study. In this sense, the socio-economic development of the country steams from these following six factors, such as: visionary leadership, unparalleled political stability, intolerance to corruption, an attractive and secure business environment, firm determination to join the Commonwealth and, finally, revolutionary social security reforms. Aware of the country's strengths and weaknesses as being landlocked, the Rwandan government has tailored its programmes to match the country's potentials. What's more, in the absence of political upheaval since the 1994 genocide, Rwanda has become a haven of peace for national and international investors, which subsequently contributed to improving their business environment. Besides, unlike in numerous African countries where impunity reigns supreme, Kagame administration has an uncompromising stance towards public funds embezzlement or other forms of corruption, and imposes heavy penalties for those found guilty. Ergo, aids or budgets allocated to development have the luxury and privilege of being put to good use. Furthermore, Rwanda broke free from the stranglehold of ‘Francai'rique’ by joining the Commonwealth in 2009, without which its economy would remain extroverted, like most of former French colonies. Finally, in an effort to protect the population against financial risks associated with ailments, the Rwandan regime has set itself the task of making health insurance accessible to the general public. In short, Rwanda's economic, social and political success could be attributable to the harmonious synergy of all these elements.

Key words: Rwanda, genocide, developmental state, economy, democracy, commonwealth

RESUME

Madagascar est l’un des pays les plus pauvres du monde (Banque Mondiale, 2023). Cette phrase résonne partout, dans les journaux, documentaires ou ouvrages de toutes sortes. Pour toute personne dotée de bon sens, ce fait ne peut qu'être alarmant et devrait, de surcroît, pousser les uns les autres à trouver un remède. Ce travail de recherche aspire, ainsi, à apporter sa petite pierre à l'édifice, dans ce chantier pharaonique qu'est la lutte contre la pauvreté. Cependant, force est de constater qu’en matière de développement, nous avons coutume de prendre les pays comme les États-Unis, la Chine et tant d’autres comme références. Bien qu’ils soient développés, leurs contextes socio-historico-culturels sont distincts de ceux des pays africains. Il n'est pas surprenant, dès lors, qu'un modèle de développement qui a été couronné de succès dans ces pays puisse, dans une certaine mesure, être un échec spectaculaire dans le monde particulier de l'Afrique. Ce qui, par la même, justifie notre choix du Rwanda comme objet d’études. À ce titre, l’essor socioéconomique de ce pays dit « des mille collines » tient à ces six considérations ci-après, à savoir le leadership visionnaire, une stabilité politique hors pair, l’intolérance à l’égard de la corruption, un environnement des affaires attractif et sécurisé, leur ferme détermination d’adhérer au Commonwealth et finalement, les réformes révolutionnaires en matière de sécurité sociale. Conscient des forces et faiblesses du pays, comme étant « enclavé », le gouvernement Rwandais a su aligner leurs programmes en affinité avec les potentialités du pays. En outre, faute de branle-bas à caractère politique depuis le génocide de 1994, le Rwanda est devenu un havre de paix pour les investisseurs nationaux et internationaux ; ce qui a, par la suite, largement contribué à améliorer l’environnement des affaires du pays. D’autre part, contrairement à ce qui se passe dans de nombreux pays africains où l’impunité est devenue la règle, le régime Kagame est intransigeant quand il est question de détournement de deniers publics ou d’autres formes de corruptions et fait feu de tout bois pour lourdement sanctionner les reconnus coupables. Ergo, les aides et les budgets alloués au développement ont le luxe et le privilège d'être utilisés à bon escient. Par ailleurs, le Rwanda a aussi su s’extirper de la griffe de « Françafrique » en joignant le Commonwealth en 2009, sans quoi son économie aurait toujours été extravertie, comme la plupart des pays ex-colonies françaises. Pour finir, afin de protéger la population contre les risques financiers liés aux maladies, l'État Rwandais s'est donné pour mission de rendre l'assurance santé accessible au plus grand public. Bref, le succès économique, social et politique du Rwanda s’explique par la synergie harmonieuse de tous ses éléments.

Mots- clés : Rwanda, génocide, développementalisme, économie, démocratie, Commonwealth

FINTINA

Ny nosy Madagasikara dia iray amin’ireo firenena mahantra indrindra maneran-tany (Banky Iraisam-pirenena, 2023). Io fehezanteny io dia hita foana na aiza na aiza, amin’ny gazety, horonantsary fanadihadiana na asa soratra maro samihafa. Tranga tokony hanaitra sy hanosika ny tsirairay hikaroka vahaolana anefa izany. Natao ity asa fikarohana ity mba hitondrana anjara biriky kely ho amin’ny fandrosoana vahaolana manoloana an’ity ady goavambe amin’ny fahantrana ity. Matetika anefa, rehefa miresaka ny atao hoe fampandrosoana isika dia ny firenena toy ny Etazonia na Sina no raisina ho modely. Ekena fa mandroso tokoa ireny firenena ireny, kanefa samy hafa ny zava-misy eo amin’ny endri-piarahamonina, ny tontolon’ny kolontsaina sy ny tantara izay nolalovan’ireny firenena ireny ka tsy voatery hifanaraka amin’ny zava-misy aty Afrika. Izay no nahatonga an’ny Rwanda nosafidiana manokana hanompanana an’ity asa fikarohana ity. Ireto avy, noho izany, ireo antony enina lehibe nampandroso an’io firenena voalaza io: haitarika mijery lavitra, fitoniana ara-politika tsy manam-paharoa, tsy fileferana manoloana ny kolikoly, tontolon’ny fandraharahana milamina sy azo antoka, ny fidirany ho mpikambana ao amin’ny “Commonwealth”, fanavaozana ifotony ny fiahiana ara-tsosialy. Noho ny fahatsapany ny maha firenena tsy manana sisi-dranomasina azy, dia nanitsy ny programam-pampandrosoany izy ireo mba mifanaraka amin’ny izay zava-misy any antoerana. Manarak’izay, noho ny tsy fisian’ny fikorontanana ara-politika taorian’ny fandripahana foko ny taona 1994, dia tsapa fa nitombo ny isan’ireo mpampiasa vola zana-tany sy vahiny nisafidy handraharaha ao Rwanda ary izany fitoniana izany ihany koa no isany nanatsara ny tontolon’ny fandraharahana tamin’io firenena io. Tsy tahaky ny firenena Afrikanina maro izay anjakan’ny tsy maty manonta i Rwanda. Hentitra manoloana ny tranga fanodikodinam- bolampanjakana na kolikoly amin’ny endriny maro samihafa io firenena io ary manasazy henjana ireo izay voamarina fa nanao izany. Vokany, mba mandeha amin’ny tokony alehany ny fanampiana na teti-bola natokana hoan’ny fampandrosoana. Fanampiny, tafahala teo ambany vahohon’ny “Franpafrique” i Rwanda tamin’ny nidirany ho mpikambana tao amin’ny “Commonwealth” ny taona 2009, raha tsy izay dia mbola nikorosofahana tahaky ny toekaren’ny ankamaroan’ny firenena zanatany Frantsay teo aloha ihany ny toekareny. Farany, mba hiarovany ny vahoaka “Rwandais” amin’ireo voka-dratsy ara-bola ateraky ny tsy fahasalamana, dia nanao ho vaindohandraharaha ny hisitrahan’ny sarababem-bahoaka ny fiahiana ara-tsosialy ny fitondrana. Raha akapoka, ireo rehetra ireo mitambatra no azo anazavana ny fahombiazana ara-toekarena, sosialy sy ara-politika an’ny “Rwanda”.

Teny manan-danja: Rwanda, fandripahana foko, ‘développementalisme’, toekarena, demokrasia, ‘Commonwealth’

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

Illustrations are not included in the reading sample

LIST OF MAPS

Map 1: General localization of Rwanda in Africa

Map 2: The territory of the Republic of Rwanda

[Note: The maps are not included for copyright reasons.]

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1: Details of the questionnaire participants

Table 2: Results of the questionnaire conducted with Faculty of Arts and Humanities students, University of Antananarivo

Table 3: Madagascar Gross Domestic Product growth rate

LIST OF PHOTOS

Photo 1: Kigali, Rwanda capital city

Photo 2: Tutsi and Hutu morphological differences

Photo 3: Grégoire Kayibanda, the first president of Rwanda

Photo 4: Juvénal Habyarimana, the second president of Rwanda

[Note: The photos are not included for copyright reasons.]

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1: Women Representation in the Chamber of Deputies of Rwanda

Figure 2: Average GDP per capita (1960-2015) in British, French and Other Colonies

Figure 3: Madagascar Gross Domestic Product growth rate

INTRODUCTION

Rwanda, fondly known as “the land of thousand hills” (Ggombe & Newfarmer, 2018), has undergone a remarkable economic, social and political transformation, over the last two decades or so. This East-African country managed to live out the dream of Africa in terms of development and was even hailed as the “Singapore of Africa” (Uwizeyimana, 2019). However, before being a success story, the country has also known one of most horrific civil war and genocide in recent memory, from April 7th 1994, which lasted 100 days and left 800 000 of its populace dead (Britannica, 2024). By mid-July 1994, a rebel group Rwandan Patriotic Front led by General Paul Kagame, a Tutsi1, succeeded to stop the killing spree and overthrew Juvenal Habyarimana’s regime, dominated primarily by Hutus (Waugh, 2004). Therefore, a war is not devoid of consequences particularly on the economy. For a fear of reprisal from the newly established regime, most of the former government’s elites and intellects fled the country and sought asylum abroad, instigating an unprecedented brain drain. Truly, the country was in a despaired state. Hence, even the most optimistic analysts doubted any possible recovery of Rwanda from the tragic event.

Unexpectedly, Rwanda’s economy sprang back and grew at an exponential rate. According to the World Bank, their Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was estimated at 10.17 billion US dollars in 2020, as opposed to 753.6 million US dollars in 1994. In this regard, it only took 26 years for their GDP to raise up to ten-fold, which is simply phenomenal for a sub-Saharan African country. Moreover, it is worthwhile to pinpoint that the Republic of Rwanda (RoR) also met most of the 8 United Nations Millennium Development Goals2 (MDGs) by the end of 2015 (UNDP 2016), such as “1. Eradication of extreme poverty and hunger, 2. Universal primary education, 3. Promoting gender equality and empower women, 4. Reduction of child mortality, 5. Improvement of maternal health, 6. Combating HIV/AIDS, malaria, and other diseases, 7. Ensuring environmental sustainability, 8. Develop a global partnership for development.” While, most of its African peers did not even manage to attain one. In President Paul KAGAME’s own words,

Rwandan economic growth is “[It] a growth that transits to the development of the citizen, which affects the well-being of the population.” as he put it during a lecture at Harvard Business School in Boston on February 26, 2016.

Therefore, along with economic growth, human development index such as literacy rate and life expectancy have also seen a tremendous enhancement. Between 1990 and 2017, Rwanda’s Human Development Index (HDI) has more than doubled, from 0.250 to 0.524, which is amongst the highest average annual HDI growth in the world (UNDP, 2021). In sum, Rwanda represents a ray of hope for developing African countries to achieve their long-awaited economic, social and political development.

Ipso facto, the very ambition of the present research is to shed some light on the mechanisms at play in Rwanda’s sudden, huge and sustainable economic growth, from 2009 to 2023”. In this regard, it endeavors to comprehend the functioning mechanisms behind strategies or measures that the government of Rwanda adopted to lift their country out of poverty. Then, come up with some guidelines or recommendations, which could serve as a road map for other African countries like Madagascar to achieve a similar or even better performance in terms of economic development.

In the interest of clarity, let us go through these following research questions:

1) What strategies or measures did Rwandan government implement to tackle poverty?

2) How could these measures be adapted and applied in a country like Madagascar?

3) Would it be more beneficial for an African country to be part of the Commonwealth or Francophony?

As a response to the question, Rwandan government's strategies for addressing poverty are embedded in the Vision 2020 and the EDPRS (Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy). These initiatives focus on transforming the country into a middle-income economy through investments in agriculture, infrastructure, education, and healthcare. By way of hypothesis, Madagascar, much like Rwanda, has a similar historical background. Both nations had monarchies before European occupation and share French colonial heritage. Thus, a solution that proved to be successful in Rwanda is likely to stand a good chance of working, as well, in Madagascar. Our next hypothesis posits that it is more beneficial for an African country to be part of the Commonwealth than Francophony (Connolly, 2022). For it provides a broader range of opportunities in terms of economic cooperation and education, among many other things. As far as the limitation of the study is concerned, geographical separation between Rwanda and Madagascar constituted a sizable restraint to this research. Understanding realities on the ground through the internet is not as effective as a direct and on-site experience. Additionally, for financial reasons, certain relevant books were inaccessible, as they were all behind paywalls, which somehow affected the richness of the bibliography. Please note that we used mixed-methods approach, incorporating both qualitative methods like bibliographical study, video content analysis and interviews; as well as quantitative methods such as questionnaires in the course of the present research.

For the sake of understanding, we had this work divided into five chapters. The first part presents the background context of Rwanda including a short description of the research location and a historical overview i.e., from colonization period, all the way through the 1994 genocide to their independence. The second chapter deals with literature review, conceptual and theoretical frameworks. This particular section displays theories and concepts from various authors that explains Rwanda’s economic, social and political success. On the third chapter, we will focus on research methodology that we resorted to during the course of the study. The fourth and last chapter discusses the findings and analysis of results. That part throws light on strategies applied by the government of Rwanda to tackle poorness in the country; coupled with thorough examination of the situation in Rwanda and Madagascar. Results from different surveys and interviews will be presented in this section.

CHAPTER I:

BACKGROUND CONTEXT OF THE REPUBLIC OF RWANDA

1. DESCRIPTION OF THE PLACE

1.1. Overview of Rwanda’s geography

Rwanda is a small landlocked country, located in East-Central Africa between 1°04’ and 2°51' south latitude, and between 28°45' and 31°15' east longitude. It measures 26,338.00 km[2] and situated in the Great Lakes region of East Africa. It is the most densely populated country in Africa (Mutabazi, 2011). It lies 121 km South (75 miles) of the equator in the Tropic of Capricorn, 1416 kilometres (880Miles) west of the Indian Ocean and 1250 km (777Miles) east of the Atlantic Ocean (DGIE, 2024).

Map 1: General localization of Rwanda in Africa

[The map is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source: Mapsland, 2024

Geographically, Rwanda is bordered by Uganda to the north, Tanzania to the east, Burundi to the south, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo to the west (DGIE, 2024).

Map 2: The territory of the Republic of Rwanda

[The map is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source: Rainer Lesniewski, 2018

The country’s topography is marked by a hilly and mountainous landscape; thus, the famous nickname “Land of a thousand hills". Despite its modest size, Rwanda is widely known for its rich biodiversity. In fact, it is home to several national parks, including Volcanoes National Park, Nyungwe Forest National Park, and Akagera National Park. These parks preserve diverse ecosystems and support a wide range of wildlife, including mountain gorillas, golden monkeys, chimpanzees, elephants, and various bird species (REMA, 2018). Its capital city: Kigali, which lays in the central part of the country, is a vibrant and modern metropolis known for its cleanliness and well-planned infrastructure.

Photo 1: Kigali, Rwanda capital city.

[The photo is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source: https://africanleadersmagazine.com/kigali-rwanda-the-most-inviting-city-in-africa-2/

According to 2021 census, Rwanda has a population of approximately 13.46 million people (NISR). The majority of the population is of Bantu ethnicity and mainly speaks Kinyarwanda as mother tongue (UNESCO, 2022).

1.2. Historical background of Rwanda

1.2.1. Rwanda under German (1890-1916) and Belgian (1916-1962) occupation

The end of 19th century marks the beginning of European colonization era in many parts of Africa and Rwanda was no exception. In 1858, a British explorer John Hanning Speke was the first known European to discover the great lakes region (Britannica, 2024). Then, the Scramble for Africa, that is to say, invasion and occupation of African territories by European powers commenced in 1880s. However, to avoid unnecessary bloodshed between them, the Berlin Conference was held on November 15, 1884 (Gates & Appiah, 2010). The purpose of the actual conference was to share Africa in a “fair” and “civilized” manner between European countries and the United States of America. Subsequently, German explorers made their way to Rwanda and catholic missionaries were established. Aside from their religious goal, missionaries became an important driving force in the advancement of colonial conquests. Indeed, German colonizers were very crafty and often resorted to deceptive schemes. On March 22, 1897, Captain Hans Ramsay, peacefully managed to form a “pact of friendship” with Mpamarugamba, King Yuhi Musinga’s cousin. However, German colonizers betrayed the King and sized Rwanda by surprise with the help of only 112 soldiers. Therefore, Ramsay provided the King with a letter of protection, a German flag and officially declared Rwanda as a German colony.

In 1914, with World War I, Germany had less men and equipment left in Ruanda-Urundi (Rwanda and Burundi territory combined). Belgian colonists who already occupied Congo, seeing the weaker presence of German in the country, set off to orchestrate several invasions. On October 27, 1914, Belgian attempted to size Ruhengeri, a north-western region of Rwanda, but in vain. Following several raid operations, Belgian succeeded to take control of Gisenyi, a region bordering Rwanda and Congo to the west and Ruhengeri region. At the same instant, King Musinga mightily supported the Germans but his efforts bore no fruit (Byanafashe & Rutayisire, 2016).

During a conference of Kibati (DRC) in October 1914, Great Britain and Belgium signed an accord of mutual assistance. By the virtue of this accord, British troops in Uganda, Kenya and Rhodesia (Zimbabwe) came together to help Belgian to kick out German colonizer. The joint military operations were launched on April 21, 1916. On May 5, 1916, German forces surrendered and left the country. This period marked the end of German colonization era and the beginning of Belgium reign in Rwanda.

1.2.2. The 1994 Genocide

The root of the Rwandan genocide dates back as far as their colonial period. To anchor their dominance, Belgian colonizers instituted a divisive identity policy. In 1934, all Rwandan male adults were issued “ethnic” identity cards, which indicate whether they are a Tutsi, Hutu or Twas. Morphologically, Tutsis are taller and have longer noses compared to Hutus and Twas. Henceforth, Belgian colonists favored Tutsis more and considered them as a superior race compared to the other two, who are shorter in terms of size and deemed, contrastingly, as inferior. Therefore, colonists treated those ethnic groups differently. For instance, Tutsis were granted access to education while Hutus were completely deprived of, since they were believed to be less intelligent. Consequently, these glaring unequal treatments fueled considerable hatred against Tutsis (Maron, 2019).

Photo 2: Tutsi and Hutu morphological differences

[The photo is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source : http://44226196.weebly.com/hutu-vs-tutsi.html

By the end of the colonial era, democracy played at the favor of Hutus since they form the majority of Rwandan inhabitants. In October 26, 1961, Parmehutu (the Hutu Emancipation Movement Party) won the presidential election with 78% of the vote and Grégoire Kayibanda, its leader, became the first commander in chief of the Republic of Rwanda (Zuber, 2022).

After Hutus’ ascension into power, Tutsis bore the brunt of ill-treatments and many were forced to go into exile to neighboring countries. Thereafter, President Kayibanda completed a third term before being overthrown by his own minister of Defense, General Juvénal Habyarimana, in July 1973.

Photo 3: Grégoire Kayibanda, the first president of Rwanda

[The photo is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source : https://www.blackpast.org/global-african-history/people-global-african-history/gregoire- kayibanda-1924-1976/

In 1975, Habyarimana founded his own political party NRMD (National Revolutionary Movement for Development) and a new constitution was adopted in 1978, which established a one-party regime, i.e., a “non-democratic” ruling. Later, President Habyarimana was re-elected in 1983 and 1988 for a third term.

From 1990, his regime faced a rebellion led by troops of former Tutsi exiles from Uganda: The Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), under the leadership of General Paul Kagame (East Africa Living Encyclopedia).

Photo 4: Juvénal Habyarimana, the second president of Rwanda.

[The photo is not included for copyright reasons.]

Source : https://perspective.usherbrooke.ca/bilan/servlet/BMEve/601

Due to a wave of democratization across Africa and relentless pressures from oppositions, a new constitution was ratified in 1991, which instituted a multiparty democracy. Additionally, in July 1990, French President Mitterrand announced that France would suspend its public development aid unless the regime adopts democratic reforms. Thus, President Habyarimana had no choice but to give way to internal demands for political liberalization. Henceforward, a powersharing agreement between MRND, RPF and opposition parties was signed in August 1993 in Arusha, Tanzania. Owing to reluctance of Habyarimana’s government members to share power and intransigence of the RPF in the application of the Arusha accord, Prime Minister Faustin Twagiramungu, a moderate Hutu and President of the main opposition party: MDR (Republican

Democratic Movement), failed to form the coalition government foreseen within the aforementioned accord. On April 6 1994, a plane carrying the President Juvénal Habyarimana, and his Burundian counterpart, Cyprien Ntavyamira, was shot down as it was about to land at Kigali airport. The likely motives of the murder were the acceptance of the President Habyarimana to sign the Arusha accord and his decision to include Tutsis from the RPF within the government, together with his ambition to democratize the country. By and by, the death of President Habyarimana was immediately followed by a systematic extermination of Tutsi population and moderate Hutus by extremist Hutu militias called “Interahamwe”. Between April and June 1994, the massacre caused between 800.000 to one million deaths. By mid July 1994, the horrendous Rwandan genocide ended with the victory of the RPF (East Africa Living Encyclopedia).

In the same tread, a report issued by a commission of fourteen French historians led by Professor Vincent Duclert revealed a “damning role” of Paris and some political leaders at the time, including François Mitterrand, in the actual genocide. According to Radio France International (RFI) on 1st of June 2012:

“It is France, which trained and supplied equipment to the Rwandan army, backed the claim and argued that without missiles they could not have carried out the shot down of the presidential air craft. Moreover, the list of weapons has been handed over to French judge Marc Trévidic who is heading the latest French inquiry into the assassination. Meanwhile, the UN court for Rwanda handed a life sentence to a former youth minister found guilty of being among the top planners of the 1994 genocide. Callixte Nzabonimana was found guilty of genocide, plotting to commit genocide, incitement to commit genocide and extermination. The three judges found that Nzabonimana had incited people to exterminate Tutsi at public appearances in different parts of the province in April, May and June 1994”.

We can infer from the above allegation that the first responsible for the 1994 Rwandan mass murder was none other than Habyarimana’s government members, as a revenge for the presidential airplane attack which they have, surprisingly, carried out themselves, with a full support of “Quai d'Orsay”. All in all, the purpose of the 6th of April attack was twofold: first, to get rid of President Habyarimana who became too weak in the eyes of his political party members and second, to find a pretext to eliminate Tutsi ethnic group who became more powerful and threatens to take over the government.

Surprising it may seem, Mistral ground-air missile that was used to perpetrate the Presidential airplane attack belonged to French army and so as the other 15 missiles found at the Rwandan army arsenal, according to a UN document (Radio France International, 01/06/2012). In addition, on 27th of May 2021, President Emmanuel Macron publically acknowledged the role of France on his speech during Kwibuka 27, an event marking the 27th commemoration of 1994 genocide saying:

“The killers who haunted the marshes, the hills and the churches did not bear France’s face. But France has a role, a history and a political responsibility in Rwanda. It has a duty: it must look history in the face and recognize the share of suffering that it inflicted itself on the Rwandan people by opting for too long to keep silent instead of examining the truth. In joining, in 1990, a conflict in which it had no past, France was unable to hear the voice of those who warned it, or overestimated its strength in thinking that it could prevent what was already happening.”

Then, the President Macron further added:

“France did not understand that, in seeking to obstruct a regional conflict or civil war, in reality it remained alongside a genocidal regime. In ignoring the warnings of the most clear-sighted observers, France bore damning responsibility in a chain of events that led to the worst, at a time when it sought to prevent just that.”

Hence, the involvement of French government in the Rwandan ethnic massacre is beyond dispute.

However, it would be unfair to put all the blame to France alone, while the whole world stood by in quiet horror and watched Rwandan people killing each other, chiefly the United Nations Organization (Ban Ki-moon, 2014).

As a member of the UN since 18 September 1962, Rwandan people should have been entitled to some sort of protection from a flagrant and serious violation of human rights. In this regard, the article 1 of the UN Charter, explicitly displays its “raison d’être”, that is to say: “To maintain international peace and security, and to that end: to take effective collective measures for the prevention and removal of threats to the peace, and for the suppression of acts of aggression or other breaches of the peace, and to bring about by peaceful means, and in conformity with the principles of justice and international law, adjustment or settlement of international disputes or situations which might lead to a breach of peace.” (United Nations, n.d.). On top of that, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), which was proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly in Paris on 10 December 1948, clearly states on its article 3 saying: “Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person.” Ergo, the United Nations organization could have took some initiatives to contain the massacre, exempli gratia, by putting in place a humanitarian operation. For all intents and purposes, the principle of non-intervention in the internal affairs of states foreseen in Chapter I, Article 2(7) of the United Nations Charter, should in no way be applied in extreme cases like a genocide or in any events where lives of thousands of unarmed civilians are in danger. For that would simply be but “a failure to assist a people in danger” on their behalf. To prove the assertion, on 7 April 2014 in Kigali, the UN SecretaryGeneral Ban Ki-moon publicly recognized their part of responsibility and declared: “The UN is still ashamed over its failure to prevent the 1994 genocide. The UN personnel in Rwanda during the genocide showed a "remarkable bravery", but we could have done much more. We should have done much more; troops were withdrawn when they were most needed”. On top of that, the former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s address, on April 7 2004, to the Commission on Human Rights in Geneva further supports our hypothesis. He declared:

“We must never forget our collective failure to protect at least 800,000 defenceless men, women and children who perished in Rwanda 10 years ago. Such crimes cannot be reversed. Such failures cannot be repaired. The dead cannot be brought back to life. So what can we do? First, we must all acknowledge our responsibility for not having done more to prevent or stop the genocide. Neither the United Nations Secretariat, nor the Security Council, nor MemberStates in general, nor the international media, paid enough attention to the gathering signs of disaster. Still less did we take timely action. When we recall such events and ask “why did no one intervene?” we should address the question not only to the United Nations, or even to its Member States.”

Thus, it would not be an overstatement to assert that the UN is circuitously responsible for the Rwandan genocide (Barbisotti, 2023).

By contrast, when Iraq invaded Kuwait, a petrol rich country that makes up 20% of World’s oil-reserves, on August 2, 1990, i.e. four years before Rwandan Genocide, the reaction of the United Nations and its Security Council were surprisingly different. As on the same day, they unanimously condemned the invasion and called for Iraq to withdraw immediately from Kuwait. With regard to Rwandan genocide, no condemnation nor resolution has been taken, during 100 days of bloodbath among Tutsis and moderate Hutus. Going back to the previously mentioned Gulf War, two military operations: Operation Desert Shield and Operation Desert Storm were rapidly arrayed in response to the attack. Astoundingly, a UN resolution has even been passed by the Security Council, which approved the use of force against Iraq if it failed to withdraw by January 15, 1991. For Saddam Hussein refused to give in, roughly 700,000 allied troops were sent in the Middle East to dash his regime into pieces (Britannica, 2024). Not so happened in Rwanda in 1994, the United States of America, which usually acted as “the World police” (Lebovic, 2020) throughout History, did not act either. Could Rwanda's absence of oil, a strategic resource, have influenced this outcome?

During a state visit to Rwanda in 1998, President Bill Clinton deeply regretted as well the United States inaction in the course of 100 days of agony that Rwandan people suffered. On his speech, he avowed: “It may seem strange to you here, especially the many of you who lost members of your family, but all over the world there were people like me sitting in offices, day after day after day, who did not fully appreciate the depth and speed with which you were being engulfed by this unimaginable terror.” He further added during an interview on CNBC in 2013, saying: “If we’d gone in sooner, I believe we could have saved at least a third of the lives that were lost; that if the US had provided as few as 10,000 troops, more than 300,000 Rwandan lives could have been spared.” Thence, the incomprehensible failure to act on behalf of the US somehow added fuel to the fire.

In brief, the 1994 Rwandan genocide was a culmination and long-term fall out of divisive policy of Belgian colonizer. The tenure of the event would have been less dramatic if “Quai d'Orsay” did not interfere. Better still, the worst might have been avoided if the International Community took all necessary actions promptly.

After demystifying and shading some light on the 1994 Rwandan genocide, let us dive in and find out how they rebuilt their Nation, ever since.

CHAPTER II:

CONCEPTUAL, THEORITICAL FRAMEWORKS AND LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1. Developmental state theory

2.1.1. Historical background of developmental state theory

In the aftermath of the 1994 Genocide, a transitional government led by President Pasteur Bizimungu_ a moderate Hutu_ was established. As a prominent figure in halting the genocide and ending Habyarimana’s regime, Mr. Paul Kagame was nominated as vice-president and minister of defense in July 1994. It is only on March 17, 2000 that the man took office and served as President of the Republic of Rwanda, following a parliamentary election. With President Kagame on its helm, Rwandan government was keen to adopt and follow East-Asian countries’ economic model3 from 1980’s forward, commonly known as “developmental state”: a term coined by Chalmers Ashby Johnson, a professor emeritus of University of California, San Diego “to describe states which follow a certain model of economic planning and management. It was initially used to describe post-1945 Japan and its rapid modernization and growth” (ESCWA, 2020).

In fact, Japan left the whole World amazed back in 1980’s with its swift economic leap forward, the same way as Rwanda does today. Seeing the dazzling success of Japan, other East- Asian countries collectively known as “East Asian tigers” such as Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan have all emulated Japanese economic model and surprisingly yielded the same result. As Professor Mills Soko from the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg put it: “East Asian countries have looked up to Japan as a model of success. Japan represents the power of example and innovation. Japan’s technocracy, led by the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI), played a key part in the country’s extraordinary rise in the post-war period. At the heart of the country’s development was strong collaboration between government and business, facilitated and guided by MITI. This government-business prototype was later copied by

Taiwan and South Korea.” (Soko, 2020). On this basis, Rwanda’s laudatory nickname “Singapore of Africa” came from their emulation of Singapore’s economic model.

In the interest of clarity, let us go through these series of definitions of developmental state theory from subsequent authors below.

2.1.2. Definitions of developmental state or developmentalism

For Chalmers Johnson (1982),

“A developmental state is a state that has economic development as a priority objective; intervenes in the economy not only by means of regulation, but also directly; has a small and highly skilled public bureaucracy to which actual powers are assigned, leaving the legislature and judiciary in the background;”

He further elaborated:

“The state must exercise control over its foreign commercial operations, financial accounts and, therefore, the exchange rate; protects domestic manufacturing industry from end products; facilitates machinery imports; separates foreign technology, in which it has a strong interest, from foreign capital, in which it has no interest; creates state-owned financial institutions; adopts credit and fiscal incentives, but always on a temporary basis, subject to constant assessments; adopts a consolidated public investment budget; offers strong government support for science and technology; and eschews detailed laws, leaving room for firms to take the initiative, with discretionary guidance from the public bureaucracy” (Bresser-Pereira, 2016).

As for Professor Helio Jaguaribe (1962), “the core thesis of developmentalism is that the promotion of economic development and the consolidation of nationality stand as two correlated aspects of a single emancipatory process”. Moreover, developmental states “combined state intervention with a dynamic private sector, modelling themselves on Japan” (Bresser-Pereira, 2016).

While, Dr Mehari Taddele Maru (2021) defends in his article The Developmental State Experience in Ethiopia and Rwanda: Lessons for Libya?, that “in contrast with the liberal state, and as an alternative to it, the developmental state is a state where the government is intimately involved in the macro and microeconomic planning to grow the economy, while attempting to deploy its resources in developing better lives for the people.”

All above-mentioned authors agree at least on 3 points. First, a developmental state is a state that makes rapid economic growth its primary objective. Second, as opposed to liberalism that gives full primacy to the market, developmentalism, for its part, is an economic model where states allow itself to moderately intervene in the economy whenever needed. That is to say, to “coordinate the non-competitive sector of the economy, while the market coordinates the competitive one (sector)” (Bresser-Pereira, 2017). Third, making private sector the engine of its development.

It is worthwhile to stress, though, that developmentalism is in no way a new form of communism. On the contrary, it is of capitalist in nature. Indeed, Professor Luiz Carlos Bresser- Pereira, a Brazilian economist and social scientist, put it in the best words on his article: “ The two forms of capitalism: developmentalism and economic liberalism”.

He claimed that “[...] the state and the market are the main institutions regulating capitalism, and, correspondingly, that the form of the economic and political coordination of capitalism will be either developmental or liberal. It defines the developmental state, relates it to the formation of a developmental class coalition, and notes that capitalism was born developmental in its mercantilist phase, turned liberal in the nineteenth century, and, after 1929, became once again developmental, but, now, democratic and progressive.”

To put it simple, developmentalism stands amongst the two forms of capitalism and by implication, a capitalism.

In brief, it is this theory of “developmental state” by Chalmers Johnson that reveals the mystery that lies behind the so-called “Rwandan economic miracle”. However, the theory on its own would not be sufficient for a “miracle” to come about. Indeed, series of measures and strategies were instigated to make Rwanda one of the fastest growing economies in Africa.

2.2. Literature review

2.2.1. Rwandan strategies and enforcement of developmentalism

The Rwandan economic breakthrough has aroused the interest of a plethora of researchers worldwide. Wherefore, it is no wonder that a vast array of literature could be found on the subject. Let us, then, kick off our literature review with “ Rwanda, Inc.: How a Devastated Nation Became an Economic Model for the Developing World ” (2012) by Patricia Crisafulli and Andrea Redmond. The book in question explores various factors contributing to the remarkable transformation of Rwanda from the aftermath of the 1994 genocide to its status quo. Thereby, the author underlines the roles of leadership of President Paul Kagame and his government in implementing legal and policy reforms. These reforms were argued to be vital for nurturing favorable business environment and attracting foreign investment in the country. Moreover, the narrative points out the significant role of social cohesion and national identity in rebuilding after the genocide. In this respect, the authors defend that the government’s emphasis on unity and reconciliation were among the impetus behind their economic development. On top of that, Crisafulli and Redmond further examine how Rwanda leveraged international relationships and aid effectively. The research reveals how strategic partnerships with foreign governments and NGOs have facilitated growth in the country. While the authors celebrate Rwanda’s progress, they also acknowledge ongoing challenges, such as political repression and human rights concerns. This nuanced viewpoint indicates the authors’ impartiality, which is quite uncommon for books dealing with Rwanda.

What is more, Gouranga G. Das and Rukundo Bosco Johnson in “ Rwandan Economy at the Crossroads of Development: Key Macroeconomic and Microeconomic Perspectives ” (2020), for its part, provides an in-depth study of Rwanda’s economic landscape, highlighting the challenges and opportunities that the country faces. The volume differs itself by providing contributions from various scholars, offering an elaborate examination of both macroeconomic and microeconomic factors influencing Rwanda’s economy. To this end, they discuss Rwanda's impressive post-1994 GDP growth rates, attributing this breakthrough to their rigorous macroeconomic policies. Hence, several chapters of the book address specific sectors of the Rwandan economy, such as agriculture, manufacturing and services. The research reveals that the transformation of agriculture has been a driving force in achieving food security and poverty reduction. Further, the text also addresses challenges such as bureaucratic inefficiencies and the need for more robust financial markets. In addition, the authors demonstrate how investment in human capital played a major role in Rwanda’s development. To this end, they carefully examined educational reorganizations and their implications for skills development, employment and overall, economic productivity. That is to say, turning education as a key driver of their long-term economic growth. Besides, it is worthwhile to note that issues of social equity and environmental sustainability are also among the narratives. The writers consider how economic policies could be aligned with social objectives, particularly in terms of combating inequality and promoting inclusive growth or the so-called “pro-poor” economic policies. The volume concludes with a look at the future of the Rwandan economy, offering policy recommendations for strengthening growth and resilience in the country.

A distinguished author, journalist, and academic Stephen Kinzer also has a keen interest in Rwanda’s development. On his book titled “ A Thousand Hills: Rwanda’s Rebirth and the Man Who Dreamed It ” (2008), he presents us an in-depth exploration of Rwanda's post-genocide recovery through the leadership of President Paul Kagame. Kinzer's narratives combine historical and political analysis to illustrate Rwanda’s transformation from a devastated nation to a model of development in Africa. In doing so, the writer delves into Kagame’s background, leadership style, and his vision of a unified, prosperous Rwanda. To this end, Kinzer portrays Kagame as a complex figure whose authoritarian governance has been instrumental in achieving stability and economic growth. Thus, a significant portion of the book focuses on Rwanda’s economic policies and reforms. Additionally, the contributor also outlines Kagame’s strategies to attract investment, improve infrastructure, and promote technology and innovation. Indeed, the narratives emphasize how these policies have led to impressive GDP growth and various socio-economic indicators. The author, then, went further discussing the challenges of post-genocide reconciliation by emphasizing Kagame’s focus on national unity over ethnic division. By this token, he explores the delicate balance between justice for genocide perpetrators and the need for societal healing. While Stephen Kinzer acknowledges Rwanda’s achievements, he also addresses criticisms of Kagame’s regime, including concerns about political repression, human rights abuses, and limitations on freedom of speech. Stephen Kinzer wraps up the narratives by questioning the long-term implications of Kagame’s leadership style and the challenges that lie ahead.

Numerous, indeed, are authors who are enthusiastic about Rwanda's economic achievements. Among these is Andrew Wallis. On his work “ Rwanda: Rebuilding of a Nation ”, (2015) he offers a wide range of analysis of Rwanda’s post-genocide recovery. Wallis started by laying out a thorough historical context for Rwanda, including the events that led to the genocide, which is key to understanding the country’s ongoing challenges. A significant focus of the book is on the role of leadership in Rwanda’s recovery, particularly the influence of President Paul Kagame. Thus, the author explores Kagame’s vision for a united Rwanda and the authoritarian measures taken to ensure stability and progress. The narratives highlight the complexities of governance in a post-conflict society. By this token, Andrew Wallis analyzed Rwanda’s economic strategies, emphasizing efforts to stimulate growth through infrastructure development, investment in technology, and agricultural transformation. He, thereby, outlined the government's efforts to attract international investment and promote entrepreneurship. In example of previous authors, Wallis also addresses issues of social reconciliation in the aftermath of the genocide. In this respect, he discusses various programs aimed at fostering unity among Rwandans, including community-based initiatives and the Gacaca court system, which sought to address grievances and promote healing. Wallis did not solely content himself of showing a shiny image of Rwanda. He also exposed the other side of the coin. Lastly, the writer considers Rwanda’s relationships with the international community, analyzing how global dynamics have influenced the country’s development and the role of foreign aid in its recovery.

Let us proceed our literature review with “ Rwanda Fast Forward: Social, Economic, Military and Reconciliation Prospects ” (2012) by Maddalena Campioni and Patrick Noack. This particular work displays a clear-cut analysis of Rwanda's development trajectory in the years following the 1994 genocide. The volume brings together contributions from various experts, providing a multi-disciplinary perspective on the challenges and opportunities facing Rwanda. The book emphasizes an all-inclusive understanding of Rwanda’s development, including social, economic and military sector. This approach underscores the interconnectedness of these areas in molding the country's future. Ergo, several chapters of the book focus on Rwanda’s economic policies. In this sense, above-mentioned authors analyzed key sectors that turned Rwanda as a leader in innovation and development in the region. Likewise, the contributors also place a significant emphasis on the process of social reconciliation and healing in post-genocide era. In the way of “Rwanda: Rebuilding of a Nation” by Andrew Wallis, this specific work also endeavors to offer examination of various strategies used by the Rwandan government to promote national unity through community-based program in the example of Umuganda4 and the famous Gacaca court system5. Additionally, it is suggested that the strict security measures were crucial for maintaining peace and nurturing an environment favorable to economic and social development. Further, the book describes Rwanda’s engagement with the international community, exploring how foreign aid, trade partnerships, and diplomatic relations have influenced its development trajectory. The concluding section of the book reflects on the future of Rwanda, addressing potential challenges such as governance issues, human rights concerns, and the sustainability of its development model.

For the sake of understanding, let us keep on with “ Paul Kagame and Rwanda: Power, Genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front ” (2004) by Colin M. Waugh. This book sets itself apart by offering a critical analysis of the complex interaction between leadership, governance, and the historical context of Rwanda under President Paul Kagame. The author brings to the fore the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF) and its role in both the events leading up to the genocide and its subsequent recovery. Waugh, then, examines the long-standing ethnic tensions between the Hutu and Tutsi populations, which culminated in the notorious 1994 genocide. Besides, the author critically analyzed the genocide itself by exploring the failures of the international community to intervene and the RPF’s subsequent actions. Henceforth, he discusses the complexities of accountability and justice, comprising the institution of the Gacaca court system, which mainly aimed to address crimes committed during the genocide. Most of all, the author assesses Kagame's governance model stability, spanning from their economic development to national unity. As a double-edged sword, Colin M. Waugh presents a nuanced view of Kagame’s leadership. On one hand, he acknowledges the significant economic progress accomplished by the administration, on the other one, he points out the authoritarian tendencies and human rights violations associated with his regime.

Lastly, Professor Kingsley Chiedu Moghalu presents us his perspectives on Rwanda's historical background in “ The Rwandan Genocide: The Politics of Global Justice ” (2005). In fact, the book offers an in-depth study of events leading up to the Rwandan genocide and the international community's response. The author starts by delving into Rwanda's colonial legacy, ethnic tensions and governance failures, arguing that these factors created a breeding ground for violence among Rwandans. Moreover, the book did not miss to criticize the international community's response during the genocide, highlighting the inaction and indecision of key global players, including the United Nations and Western countries. Moghalu demonstrates how political concerns outshine humanitarian needs; thus, resulting in a lack of timely intervention in the face of mass atrocities. Much of the book, though, is devoted to the quest for justice in the aftermath of the genocide. In this aspect, the writer discusses the creation of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) and the difficulties encountered in prosecuting the perpetrators of the crimes and questions the effectiveness of international justice mechanisms along with their ability to ensure accountability. In addition, the author usher in the concept of “global justice”, which refers to the concept of equality and fairness in the distribution of resources, rights and opportunities across the world. He analyzes how that global justice intersects with national sovereignty, together with the responsibilities of states to protect their citizens. He did not hold back in criticizing the current international legal frameworks and was, instead, in favor of reforms that prioritize justice and prevention. Overall, Kingsley Chiedu Moghalu reflects on the lessons learned from Rwanda and their implications for future global responses to humanitarian crises. He points out, on the occasion, the significance of putting in place robust mechanisms for early warning, response and post-conflict reconstruction.

All things considered, the key contribution of the present dissertation is the introduction of developmental state theory to interpret Rwanda's impressive development—an approach not explicitly taken by the works cited above.

2.2.2. Impact of developmentalism strategies on Rwandan population

Developmentalism in Rwanda has profoundly influenced the nation's trajectory, shaping its economic growth, social structures, and governance systems. What about its impacts on the population? In response to the question, let us go through these following bodies of literatures.

The developmentalism policies in Rwanda, as detailed in “Development and Developmentalism in Post-genocide Rwanda” (2019) by Shinichi Takeuchi, had both significant benefits and notable drawbacks for the population. On the positive side, the government’s initiatives greatly improved living standards through investments in healthcare, education, and infrastructure, leading to higher life expectancy and better access to clean water. Besides, the Rwandan growth-centered economic policies created job opportunities, especially in urban areas and emerging sectors like tourism and technology. In rural areas, land reform and agricultural modernization have been implemented to enhance productivity and farmers’ income. In fact, policies that emphasized national unity and community-driven projects played a key role in rebuilding cohesion and fostering a sense of shared progress after the genocide. However, these policies also had negative repercussions. As developmentalism often disproportionately benefited urban elites, leaving rural communities marginalized and exacerbating economic disparities. Rural farmers, who are mostly dependent on small-scale subsistence farming, faced challenges due to limited access to land and resources under the land reform policies6. Additionally, the centralized and authoritarian nature of the developmental state muffled political dissent and reduced civil freedoms, creating an atmosphere of fear and limited participation in governance. Forced modernization efforts, such as villagization (Imidugudu)7, disrupted traditional lifestyles, causing dissatisfaction and resistance among many rural residents. In sum, developmentalism in Rwanda brought tangible benefits in terms of stability, healthcare, and education, especially when compared to the devastation of the 1994 genocide. However, these advancements often came at the cost of social equity and political freedoms.

In “Rwanda’s Radical Transformation Since the End of the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi” (2023) by Sheriff F. Folarin, for its part, provides a thorough analysis of the nation’s recovery and development following the 1994 genocide. He explores how the country’s postgenocide growth was driven by developmentalism, an economic and political strategy that had both positive and negative impacts on the population. On the one hand, Folarin highlights how the government’s developmental policies, especially under President Paul Kagame, led to rapid economic progress and modernization. Key areas like healthcare, education, and infrastructure saw significant improvements and the population had better access to essential services, which in turn increased life expectancy and literacy rates. Moreover, Rwanda’s emphasis on national unity, reconciliation, and social cohesion helped rebuild trust among the population after the genocide. The inclusive or pro-poor policies also promoted the sense of shared progress among Rwandans. However, Sheriff F. Folarin did not withhold to pin point several drawbacks of the developmentalism. Thus, he vehemently criticized the centralization of power under Kagame’s leadership, which resulted in a near suppression of political opposition, limited democratic freedoms and creation of an environment of constant terror among the population. In brief, Folarin’s work provides a nuanced view of Rwanda’s development, recognizing the country’s impressive recovery while highlighting the costs associated with its top-down developmentalist governance model.

Let us proceed our literature review with Timothy Longman’s book “ Rewriting History in Post-Genocide Rwanda ” (2017). On his work, the author critically examines the impact of developmentalism and its interrelation with governance in Rwanda. Longman highlights how the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF) used developmentalism as a tool to enforce political control and consolidate its power. Further, he also describes how government development initiatives are often perceived as favoring elites, particularly repatriated Tutsis, at the expense of the population at large. The Kagame’s top-down approach, often, creates resentment among local residents, particularly in rural areas, where people feel alienated from decision-making processes and view the government as coercive rather than collaborative. For example, failure to attend and participate in Umuganda, a mandatory community service, may result in sanctions and a fine of FRW 5,000 or US$3.65, a non-negligible sum of money for vulnerable individuals. These state's authoritarian practices further deepen mistrust between the government and the public. Indeed, many citizens view these measures as tools of domination rather than meaningful efforts at justice, reconciliation or poverty alleviation. In brief, Rwanda’s developmentalism is strongly associated with political control and consolidation of power.

To sum up, Rwanda’s developmentalism have driven significant progress in healthcare, education, and infrastructure, fostering national unity and economic growth. However, these gains came with notable challenges, including rural marginalization, authoritarian governance, and limited political freedoms.

CHAPTER III:

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.1. Data collection methods

The present research is, as sure as shooting, not the first attempt to understand Rwandan development model. Emphatically, Rwandan economic, social and political success has aroused interest of multitude of authors worldwide. Thus, great deal of books and publications on the subject are widely available both online and on printed version. Henceforth, we found it relevant to focus the research work on bibliographical study. President Kagame, the maestro of “the Rwandan economic miracle” is often called upon as an expert speaker at international conferences, forums or even as a guest lecturer at prestigious Universities in the US, in the example of Harvard Business School in Boston (Kagame, 2016) and U.S. Military Academy in New York (Fusco, 2010). Thus, a wide range of recorded video covering of these events, including interviews questioning him concerning Rwanda’s astounding development, are extensively available online. Therefore, video content analysis (VCA) was applied as a supplemental research tool. The key purpose of video analysis is to collect as authentic and trustworthy responses as possible, directly from data subjects.

However, in pursuance of achieving a greater insight, mixed methods, that is to say, qualitative and quantitative study, were resorted to during our investigative research. By way of background, “qualitative research is used to gain an understanding of human behaviour, intentions, attitudes and experience, based on the observation and interpretation of people. It is an unstructured and exploratory technique that deals with highly complex phenomena. This kind of research is usually done to understand the topic in-depth. It is carried out by taking interviews with open-ended questions, observations that are described in words” (Byju's, 2024). While, “quantitative research method relies on the methods of natural sciences, which develops hard facts and numerical data. It establishes the cause-and-effect relationship between two variables using excel spreadsheet. As the results are accurately and precisely measured, this research method is also termed as “Empirical Research”. This type of research is commonly used to establish generalised facts about a particular topic” (Ibid). In sum, bibliographical study, video content analysis, coupled with questionnaires and interviews of subject matter experts undertaken in Madagascar formed our overall data collection tools.

3.1.1. Bibliographical study

In a scientific research worthy of the name, an in-depth bibliographical study is a sine qua non. Right before the dissertation writing per say, we started to gather every book and article that dealt with our subject. In today’s digital age, it is relatively expedient to have access to a large amount of literature, available online, worldwide. Aside from Internet searches, in-situ readings of hard copy books were made at the History department library of the Faculty of Arts and Humanities, since they dispose a wide range of resources relating to History of various countries in the world, including Rwanda's. Other supplementary documents were taken from the Anglophone Studies Department library and my own book collections at home. Once needed materials collected, couple of months were spent on reading and note taking. To avoid losing crucial details, referencing and citations were completed in a separate word document, throughout the process. After reflecting upon different authors’ viewpoint, a rough draft answer to my main research questions was outlined. Then, these ideas were put into sentences in a relevant chronological sequence. Only afterwards did we commence to form our own points, steaming from these author's insights.

Rwandan socio-economic development is a relatively recent phenomenon. Hence, printed books on the subject are scares in our local libraries, and a great deal of those available online are inaccessible without payment. Therefore, finding relevant books in both printed and digital formats was a considerable challenge. After presenting the letter of introduction, though, librarians in the aforementioned Departments were exceptionally helpful in finding the right resources.

3.1.2. Video content analysis

For the sake of objectivity, video content analysis was adopted among our data collection methods. To that end, a great number of videos referring to Rwanda’s economic, social and political success has been searched for, selected and downloaded, for meticulous analysis, from diverse online video platforms, like YouTube, Dailymotion, France 24, Aljazeera and much more. Among these videos are interviews of Mr Paul Kagame, his ministers and other staff members conducted by both local and international journalists. Therefore, answers provided by those individuals could be considered as trustworthy.

Subsequently, those videos were observed to the fullest extent. In this respect, any part of the video that deals with our research questions was converted into text transcripts with name of each participant, place and date during which the event occurred, were mentioned as a citation. In brief, it would be more convenient to interview his Excellency the President or his government members, in person. However, on account of geographical separation and other hindering factors, video analysis, though time-consuming and arduous, served as an alternative option.

3.1.3. Questionnaires

For this research to be more than a simple collection of opinion, quantitative method by means of questionnaires has been applied. With its inflexible quality, it allows us to get more impartial results. Accordingly, random students at the library of Anglophone Department Studies, those of French and Francophone Studies Department (MEFF) and the Department of History, at the Faculty of Arts and Humanities of University of Antananarivo, have been pleaded to fill out certain numbers of questionnaires (See Appendix n°1 and n°2). The breakdown of our population sample is presented as follows: Out of the 100 students, 53 of which were from the Anglophone Studies Department, 25 from the Francophone Studies Department (MEFF) and 22 from Department of History. The participants were students ranging from L1 to M2 levels, aged between 16 and 25. I introduced myself to each of them in a quiet voice, mindful of the fact that they were likely studying or reading in the library. As the questionnaire was straightforward, they were able to complete it independently, and I did not impose a time limit to ensure thoughtful responses. I instructed them to raise their hand once they had finished. After distributing the questionnaires, I sat near the librarian's desk and waited. The entire process took approximately half an hour. The choice of these three departments is no coincidence but a carefully considered decision. By virtue of their academic backgrounds, the aforementioned students could be considered as more “well-informed” than most “average Joes”. For the sake of a better understanding, the questionnaires were issued in two versions: English (See Appendix n°1) and

French (See Appendix n°2). The English versions were entrusted to the English department students, whereas, the French ones to History and French department students.

Once questionnaires filled in, they were gathered and taken home for refined analysis.

3.1.4. Interviews

To thoroughly understand the complexities of the Rwandan economic model, we also adopted a qualitative research approach, focusing on interviews as a key method during our investigation. It is important to note that while interviews provided valuable insights, they were not our primary data source. Instead, they functioned as a guiding framework to contextualize our research. Unlike questionnaires, interviews were reserved for subject matter experts or individuals with relevant backgrounds to minimize the risk of inaccurate responses. While my initial target was to interview at least five individuals, only three agreed to participate. The others declined, on the pretext that the topic was too complex or due to a lack of time. Although interviews and questionnaires were designed to complement each other, questions deemed too straightforward in the questionnaires were omitted from the interviews.

The insights gathered from these interviews were specifically aimed at confirming or challenging the hypotheses generated through our extensive literature review and online research. By integrating these qualitative findings with existing theoretical frameworks, we sought to enrich our analysis and provide a more nuanced perspective on the Rwandan economic landscape. This dual approach allows us to strengthen the overall validity of our research.

CHAPTER IV:

FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS OF RESULTS

4.1. Results from primary data collection

The famed “Rwandan miracle” has not fallen down from the sky. Truly, it is nothing but a fall out of well-thought decisions and continuous efforts deployed by the Rwandan government, over the years. Among these are visionary leadership, disposition to maintain political stability, intolerance for corruption, constant improvement of business environment, adhesion to the Commonwealth, social security reform and parity system.

4.1.1. Visionary leadership

Defeating poverty in Africa, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, is no way a matter of science fiction nor fortuitous. It is, well and truly, within the realm of possible (Bicabaa et al, 2015). Without a doubt, Rwanda is a living and tangible proof that underpins this allegation. Indubitably, economic, social and political success of Rwanda caused much ink to flow over the last couple of decades and are of public knowledge. However, the mystery remains when it comes to how they achieved them, which is the very purpose our actual study. Before going any further, it is crucial to stress that the Republic of Rwanda is no way the richest country in Africa, so far. As stated by Trading Economics, their GDP only stands at US$10.50 billion by the end of 2021. While that of Nigeria, for instance, is hovering as high as US$514.05 billion the same year (Africa news, 2023).

Nevertheless, the interesting thing about Rwanda is how fast it came out of poverty and rebuilt itself from nearly out of nothing, in the wake of 1994, by means of their pro-poor policies; That is to say, policies that aim to improve the overall wellbeing of the people. The following passage from VISION 20208, page 6 says it best: “Economic growth, alone, is not sufficient to bring about the necessary rise in the standard of living of the population. To vanquish hunger and poverty, growth must be Pro-Poor; giving all Rwandans the chance to gain from the new economic opportunities.” In other words, Rwandan economic growth is not solely about impressive figures, it is a growth in favor of its people (See Appendix n°4).

To attain these ambitious goals, President Paul Kagame, like any respectable leader in the world, together with his government members were pondering on finding drastic and lasting solutions to their country’s numerous challenges. A long-term government program called: “Vision 2020” is the embodiment of their findings. Launched in the year 2000, the overall aim of the program is to transform Rwanda into a knowledge-based and middle-income economy within 20 years.

It is interesting to note, though, that the territory of the Republic of Rwanda only measures 26,338 km[2] in total, which represents roughly half of the smallest province of Madagascar: Diego- Suarez, measuring 43,046 km2. With 17,600 km2 of arable land at their disposal, Rwanda is still able to produce and export certain volume of agricultural outputs. In 2020, their annual production of coffee stands around 20,459 tons and respectively 35,000 tons of tea the following year, according to the Rwandan National Agricultural Export Development Board (NAEB). Owing to their small land surface, Rwandan leaders knew they could not rely on the primary sector, alone, to boost their economy. Not mentioning the fact that they are landlocked, bordered by Uganda on the north, Tanzania to the East, Burundi on its south and the Democratic Republic of Congo to its western side. What is more, the country locates around 1,416 km (880Miles) west of the Indian Ocean and 1,250 km (777Miles) east of the Atlantic Ocean, as the crow flies. In fact, they are geographically situated far from both side of the ocean and subsequently from seaports, which would make them less competitive in terms of cost of imports and exports via maritime route. Rwandan leaders are, definitely, well aware of their country’s weakness. To this end, they tend to focus their efforts on areas that do not massively rely on their geographic shortcomings such as services and tourisms. The CEO of the Rwanda Development Board (RDB), Claire AKAMANZI, voiced it with utmost clarity saying:

“When we think about the Rwanda of the future, we consider the advantages and challenges that we have as a country. It is for this reason that we want to position ourselves as a knowledge and services hub, given that this sector does not rely heavily on transport and logistics. We have also been promoting leisure tourism, such as the push to visit the mountain gorillas in the national park. In addition, we are promoting a new sector called MICE, which stands for meetings, incentives, conferences, and exhibitions, and it is already accounting for about 10 percent of our tourism receipts. It is the fastest-growing segment of our tourism sector, and through this, we are making Rwanda a hub for regional and global events. In this way, we have invested in service-based sectors to respond to our challenge of being a landlocked country.” (IMF, 2019).

These geographic disadvantages could have, incontestably, turned out to be stumbling blocks to their economic affluence if Kagame administration did not come up with appropriate strategies enshrined in the aforesaid document VISION 2020, a framework for Rwanda's development; in conjunction with the famous EDPRS (Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy) which sets out medium-term objectives of the country. Among these objectives are sustainable growth for Jobs and exports, reduction of operational costs of business, creation of strong incentives for private sector to increase its investment and promotion of propoor programs like “one cow per poor family” policy, through the “Girinka”9 program (National Strategy for Transformation 2017 - 2024, 11). The “one cow per poor family” scheme involves donating a cow to a needy family, which in turn provides them with milk for consumption and manure to enrich their farmland.

Professor Anastase Shyaka, CEO of the Rwanda Governance Board (RGB), underscored the transformative impact of the Girinka program on rural livelihoods and poverty reduction in Rwanda. Since its launch in 2006, he defends that milk production has grown 4.7 times, reaching 776,284 tons in 2015, compared to just 56,000 tons in 1999 (MINAGRI, 2024). Flora Uwera, a beneficiary of Girinka program from Gicumbi District, shared how it has significantly improved her family’s and community's well-being. She stated: “Thanks to the cow I received through Girinka, I now have milk for consumption and surplus to sell for income. I also use the manure to fertilize my farmland and biogas for cooking and lighting my home,” as Uwera explained during the Umushyikirano, a national dialogue. She further noted that the cow she received has multiplied into 18, of which she has donated 9 to vulnerable neighbors, embodying the program’s spirit of community support (MINAGRI, 2024).

Typically, humanitarian aids come in form of food, clothing and so forth, which put people into a state eternal dependence. So Rwandan leaders apprehend well the meaning of the famous adage: “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime” (Quoteresearch, 2015). Thus, donating cows instead of foodstuffs made Rwandan populace more self-reliant and financially independent over the years.

Still, among other objectives cited in the EDPRS is private sector development via capacity building initiatives and credit schemes. Usually, private sector is left on its own and businesses often find itself struggling to obtain loans or credits from banks in various part of Africa. Considering that private enterprises are one of the biggest tax providers, sources of investment and huge purveyors of employment for local population, Rwandan government turned them into a sector of paramount importance. In an interview conducted by Andrew Kanyegirire, a Deputy Division Chief - Media Relations at International Monetary Fund (March, 2019), the CEO of Rwandan Development Board (RDB) affirmed that “$2 billion worth of investments were registered on the year 2019 while it only stood at $318 million in 2010, from private sector” (Akamanzi, 2019). Then she further added, “On average, the private sector now creates about 38,000 jobs per year, many of which are targeted toward our young people” (Ibid, 2019). Briefly, private sector plays a crucial role in Rwanda’s socio-economic development.

On top of that, Rwanda cleverly invested in sectors that generate returns for the country. As far as MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conferences and Events) strategy is concerned, which aims to turn the country into a world-class conference destination. In 2016, the US$300 million Kigali convention center was built. According to Clare Akamanzi, the chief executive of RDB, the country collected up to US$42 million of revenue from 192 conferences in 2017, alone (Bizimungu, 2018). In May 2018, the International Congress and Convention Association (ICCA) ranked the Capital Kigali as the third most popular conference and event destination on the continent, after Cape Town in South Africa, and Casablanca of Morocco.10 Consequently, if a country aspires to development, its choice of investment project has to be carefully considered.

However, a visionary leadership, on its own, would be less effective without political stability.

4.1.2. Political stability

Among important factors that seduced foreign investors in Rwanda is its political stability. Certainly, investors do not expect to see a political turmoil after few years of doing business in a given country and end up getting their companies looted.

Unlike other African countries in the example of Nigeria, which has known seven coups and Soudan in a number of six, to name just a few, Rwanda only had two in all and never seen a single one for more than 25 years since 1994. Still, the Rwandan President Paul Kagame is often been criticized, mostly by western observers, for being a “dictator” and danger for democracy. All told, political instability can truly discourage investors to come and do business in a given country. Aside from causing investor’s reluctance, it also destroys the economy.

Moreover, it is worth mentioning that Rwanda is a Commonwealth member since 2009. As such, they strictly need to abide to certain values and principles, which are enshrined in the 1971 Declaration of Commonwealth Principles. Among these are: “commitment to democracy and democratic processes, including free and fair elections and representative legislatures; the rule of law and independence of the judiciary; good governance, including a well-trained public service and transparent public accounts; and protection of human rights, freedom of expression, and equality of opportunity”. Therefore, any member state that fails to scrupulously observe these values and principles will be subject to suspension, in the example of Nigeria in 1995 to 1999, Pakistan and Fiji, which both have been sanctioned twice in the year 1999 and 2000, respectively or Zimbabwe in 2002. In this context, if Rwanda violated any of the above rules, it would have known the same fate as the aforementioned countries. So far, the country has never been liable to any suspension from the Commonwealth, to date. In short, labeling the President of Rwanda Paul Kagame as a dictator and danger for democracy is absurd and a complete non-sense.

By and large, western countries tend see their democracy as a “one size fits all” and panacea for all ills. Truly, it is fair to say that western democracy is not always compatible with African context. In other words, a type of democracy that worked well in the United States of America or Europe, for instance, may turn out to have a reverse effect on different part of the world. In fact, democracy requires a certain level of education and political maturity on behalf of the citizen. As David HARVEY in his Literacy in the Athenian Democracy, p.586 states, “We believe that in a democracy the citizens should understand what goes on, and should be equipped with the knowledge necessary to make their decisions — that is why education is so important in a democratic state.” Going back in ancient Greece _ the birthplace of democracy, Athenians were renowned, throughout history, to have some of the most prominent philosophers, mathematicians and historians. Thereupon, the level of education of these ancient Greeks were fairly advanced, compared to some of our contemporaries. For democracy to thrive, educating the masses must be of prime importance. To prove this assertion, let us take the case of the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol in Washington D.C, in 2021. It is no secret that the outrageous attack was mainly orchestrated by a mob of supporters of Donald Trump following his defeat in the 2020 presidential election. With all due respect, most of Donald Trump supporters are commonly labeled as “redneck, ignorant and racist” (Barabak & Duara, 2016). Professor David Alan Dunning, an American social psychologist (University of Michigan), explains the behavior of MAGA supporters saying:

“Many commentators have argued that Donald Trump’s dominance in the GOP presidential race can be largely explained by ignorance; his candidacy, after all, is most popular among Republican voters without college degrees. Trump himself has memorably declared: “I love the poorly educated.” But as a psychologist who has studied human behavior—including voter behavior—for decades, I think there is something deeper going on. Psychological research suggests that people, in general, suffer from what has become known as the Dunning-Kruger Effect. They have little insight about the cracks and holes in their expertise. In studies in my research lab, people with severe gaps in knowledge and expertise typically fail to recognize how little they know and how badly they perform. To sum it up, the knowledge and intelligence that are required to be good at a task are often the same qualities needed to recognize that one is not good at that task—and if one lacks such knowledge and intelligence, one remains ignorant that one is not good at that task. This includes political judgment. ” (Dunning, 2016).

In other words, what Professor David Alan Dunning means by “Dunning-Kruger Effect” is that not only these MAGA supporters are somehow “ignorant” but also royally unaware of their ignorance. The danger lies in the fact that, in a democratic country, people are bestowed the sovereign power to elect their leaders through the ballot box. If electorates are incapable of any sort of discernment, so to speak, they may end up voting for a “wacky candidate” who will work to their detriment. In sum, western democracy is unsuitable for countries with poor level of education.

In this regard, Africans countries need to seek and mold the type of democracy or governance model that suits their needs, cultures and values in the example of Rwanda that introduced another form of democracy called: “consensus democracy” instead of blindly applying “liberal democracy” in the sole purpose of complacency with the international community. By definition, a liberal democracy means:

“Government by the majority of the people. It argues that majorities should govern and that minorities should oppose. This view is challenged by the consensus model of democracy. As the Nobel Prize-winning economist, Sir Arthur Lewis (1965, 64-65) has forcefully pointed out, majority rule and the government-versus-opposition pattern of politics that it implies may be interpreted as undemocratic because they are principles of exclusion. Lewis states that the primary meaning of democracy is that all who are affected by a decision should have the chance to participate in making that decision either directly or through chosen representatives. Its secondary meaning is that the will of the majority shall prevail. If this means that winning parties may make all the governmental decisions and that the losers may criticize but not govern, Lewis argues, the two meanings are incompatible: to exclude the losing groups from participation in decision-making clearly violates the primary meaning of democracy.” (Lijphart, 1984).

In a few words, liberal democracy is far from being the best model of governance and could even turn out to be “undemocratic”, to a certain extent.

Besides, it is through a “paternalistic” form of governance, which many observers confuse with dictatorship that the government of Rwanda managed to considerably reduce poverty in the country. Paternalism could be defined as an “attitude and practice that are commonly, though not exclusively, understood as an infringement on the personal freedoms and autonomy of a person (or class of persons) with a beneficent or protective intent.” (Thompson, 2013). To put it simple, it is an act of limiting people's liberty or autonomy in the sole intention to promote their own good.

A Belgian political scientist, professor of law and political science at the University of Antwerp, Filip Reyntjens (2004), defends that “the (Rwandan) regime openly displayed a paternalistic and distrustful attitude towards the voters. According to Aloisea Inyumba, general secretary of the National Commission for Unity and Reconciliation and a long-standing RPF leader, “The ordinary citizens are like babies. They will need to be completely educated before we can talk about democracy.” Mrs Aloisea Inyumba’s allegation, certainly, strikes a nerve. Nevertheless, when the majority of people are still politically ignorant, they will easily fall prey to any sort of manipulation by certain power-hungry politicians. President John F. Kennedy says it well during his remarks in Nashville at the 90th anniversary convocation of Vanderbilt University, on May 18, 1963. He avowed:

“If the pursuit of learning is not defended by the educated citizen, it will not be defended at all. For there will always be those who scoff at intellectuals, who cry out against research, who seek to limit our educational system. Modern cynics and skeptics see no more reason for landing a man on the moon, which we shall do, than the cynics and skeptics of half a millennium ago saw for the discovery of this country. They see no harm in paying those to whom they entrust the minds of their children a smaller wage than is paid to those to whom they entrust the care of their plumbing. But the educated citizen knows how much more there is to know. He knows that "knowledge is power," more so today than ever before. He knows that only an educated and informed people will be a free people, that the ignorance of one voter in a democracy impairs the security of all.” (JFK, 1963).

Thereof, education and democracy shall always go hand in hand.

History is full of examples supporting the premise. In 1985, President Mikhail Gorbachev made a deplorable mistake by introducing “glasnost and perestroika” reforms in Russia. By definition, “Glasnost translates as 'openness.' It refers to a significant increase in individual freedom of expression in political and social aspects of life in the Soviet Union.” (Hopkins, 2023). Before the actual reform, Russian citizens lived under totalitarianism for centuries and even got accustomed to it over time. Then all of the sudden, Gorbachev gave them total freedom, even though most of them were politically immature at the time. Eventually, an out of control “Glasnost rally” was held at Pushkin Square on December 5, 1965 in order to demand glasnost in the upcoming trial of a literary writer Andrei Sinyavsky and his translator Yuli Daniel, for having published anti-Soviet propagandas in foreign editorials under the respective pseudonyms of Abram Tertz and Nikolai Arzhak (Hornsby, 2008). As a result, thousands of protestors took to the street all over the country; the situation became rampant and involuntarily led to downfall of the U.S.S.R. in 1991. Ergo, the lesson we can withdraw from the above Soviet’s complete fiasco is that liberal democracy is not always in adequacy with people who are still “democratically immature”. What Mikhail Gorbachev should have done was to gradually freeing the people, instead of giving them an absolute total freedom overnight, which could turn out to be destructive. This is exactly why Rwanda opted for a paternalism in place of “western liberalism”. It is, consequently, by this mean that the government of Rwanda was able to put in place political stability for decades. That political stability, in turn, contributes to the improvement of their business environment; by extension, seduced more foreign investors to come and do business in the country.

Political stability, however, is not the one and only factor that makes Rwandan unique and praiseworthy. Please note that the current administration holds the highest rate of female representation in the world, in all its government institution. Surprising as it may seem, they are the first country globally to have female majority in parliament, with 61.3% in the Chamber of Deputies and 36% in the Senate, making them a champion of woman empowerment and gender equality (Parliament of Rwanda, 2024).

Figure 1: Women Representation in the Chamber of Deputies of Rwanda

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source : www.parliament.gov.rw/ (2022)

As a comparison, there are currently 225 female members of parliament (MPs) in the British House of Commons, which roughly represents 35% of the MPs, while the United States only has 27.9% in its House of Representatives (House of Commons, 2024). It goes beyond all understanding how the fledgling Republic of Rwanda is outperforming these two big Nations that are deemed developed and civilized. Certainly, Rwanda’s efforts with reference to woman empowerment do not leave international organizations nor foreign investors indifferent. In fact, they are more eager to cooperate with Nations that endeavor to fight for gender equality. Contrastingly, in the Arab world, for instance, women are still treated as third class citizens. This may result in reluctance of certain investors to cooperate with these countries. Besides, Rwandan female population represents 51.07% of the whole inhabitant according to the latest census (2022), which is about 7.04 million; while male populace only stands at 48.93%, which numbers around 6.74 million. That, clearly, represents more than half of the whole population of 13.78 million (Trading Economics, 2024). Thence, empowering women means benefiting from a huge proportion of human capital or workforce.

Esther Duflo, a professor at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), defends in her article “ Women Empowerment and Economic Development ” (2012) saying: “Women’s empowerment and economic development are closely related: in one direction, development alone can play a major role in driving down inequality between men and women; in the other direction, empowering women may benefit development.” Still, Matthias Doepke from Northwestern University and Michèle Tertilt from Stanford University also argue that “empowering women may not just be a worthy goal in its own right, but may in fact promote overall economic development. Specifically, there is evidence that when transfer payments are given to women rather than to their husbands, expenditures on children go up disproportionately. To the extent that higher spending on children promotes human-capital accumulation, this suggests that empowering women may ultimately lead to faster economic growth.” (Doepke & Tertilt, 2014). Wherefore, economic implication of woman empowerment is beyond dispute. This fact explains why Rwanda is leading by example in gender equality. Everything considered, female empowerment played a tremendous role in Rwanda’s economic development.

Nevertheless, no development can be expected if corruption still prevails.

4.1.3. Zero tolerance for corruption

Corruption is one of the many scourges impoverishing Africa. Hitherto, corruption still reigns supreme in major part of the continent for decades, if not beyond. Actually, low corruption index is one of the Rwanda’s greatest assets. It is interesting to mention that Transparency International’s 2020 Corruption Perception Index ranked the country as the fourth least corrupt nation in Africa and 49th worldwide (Transparency International, 2024). Curiously, Rwanda has a better corruption index than Brazil, China and Ukraine, which is simply out of common for a subSaharan Africa Nation (CPI, 2022). During an interview on Aljazeera (Feb 2014), President Paul Kagame himself explained how fight against corruption affects the economy. He professed that his “zero tolerance for corruption” policy plays an important role in economic development, since no government officials would dare to embezzle public funds or aids (See Appendix n°3). Consequently, these later go where it is meant to be, i.e., to its intended beneficiaries. In fact, humanitarian aid diversion became a customary practice in the continent, where aids are kept in part or in total by some government officials (Askin, 1987). Often, they find themselves exempt of any lawsuit and sanction. Fight against corruption should not remain an empty rhetoric. It implies investigating, prosecuting and punishing those found guilty, including high-ranking government officials. To name just a few, the Rwandan Minister of State in charge of Primary and Secondary Education, Isaac Munyakazi was condemned for 10 years in prison in 2020 for corruption related charges (Kamanzi, 2020). Furthermore, the Division Manager in charge of energy at the Ministry of Infrastructure Robert Nyamvumba who was implicated in a multibillion-corruption case was also handed six years sentence in jail and fined Rwf21 billion (Ashimwe, 2020).

Overall, the reason why Rwanda has a low corruption index is that their anticorruption institutions dared and are empowered to legally sanction their high-ranking officials. Certainly, exemplary sanctions over corruption charges against high-ranking government officials have largely contributed to reducing corruption and boosted investor’s confidence in the country.

Moreover, corruption commonly chimes with favouritism. In an interview with France 24, entitled « Paul Kagame - portrait du mystérieux Président du Rwanda (Paul Kagame - meet the Rwanda's mysterious president) » on November 2018. He made it known that he would not hesitate, if necessary, to evict his inner circle or close collaborators for the sake of efficiency. However, favouritism remains ubiquitous in major part of Africa. A study conducted by Giorgio Blundo and Jean-Pierre Olivier de Sardan in 2021 in West Africa reveals that in Benin, Niger and Senegal, when so-called "juicy" positions such as the ones in customs, justice or tax are obtained, where the possibilities for rapid enrichment are significant, the "appointee" has to pays a monthly "envelope" to his "nominator", in return (Blundo & Olivier de Sardan, 2001). Besides, nominations of government officials are far from being merit-based. It is, rather, some sort of rewards for their loyalty towards the ruling party or a support during a political campaign, regardless of their qualification; where “having a membership card of the party in power is a more important criterion for appointment than competence.” (Ibid.)

As a result, great deal of government officials are incompetents and usually end up making foolish decisions for the country, which in turn perpetuate poverty. In short, poverty in Africa could be partly attributable to the culture of corruption that reigns supreme on the continent for decades; and that corruption and economic development are mutually exclusive.

After seeing how corruption undermines business environment in certain African states, let us see how Rwanda managed to improve their own.

4.1.4. Business environment

Over the years, Rwanda has made a tremendous headway in terms of business environment. The World Bank’s Doing Business report 2020 ranked the country second in Africa behind Mauritius in ease of doing business and 38th the worldwide (Doing Business, 2020). This feat is indisputably far from coincidental. To bring it to fruition, Kagame administration replaced its heavy bureaucratic structures with electronic systems. Thereby, company registrations are fully made on line and all government services in relation with businesses are centered in one building: the RDB (Rwandan Development Board).11 Thus, new investors can register either online at RDB’s website ( http://org.rdb.rw/busregonline ) or in person at RDB’s offices in Kigali. Aside from business registration, RDB also assists business owners in acquiring visas, work permits, connections to electricity and water, etc. With all these government services under one roof, investors do not have to go from one institution building to another to get all required documents for starting their business. As a result, it only takes 24 hours to register a business in Rwanda,12 while it may take couple of days or even weeks in some places.

Therefore, no matter how attractive other African countries like Madagascar or others could be in terms of cost of its qualified work force, for instance, investors will surely be tempted to opt for Rwanda. Since, for businesspersons, “time is money”. That is to say, time being wasted in bureaucratic slothfulness represents a loss of potential earning. Hence, the simple fact of reducing company registration timeframe, on its own, plays an important role in convincing investors to come and do business in Rwanda rather than somewhere else.

What's more, Rwanda also set up favourable policy framework for businesses. Among these are tax benefits and incentives. Vivian Kayitese, the head of Investment Promotion and Implementation, explains that investors who put in a minimum of US$250,000 are provided with an investment certificate (Verd, 2022). This later allows them to benefit from certain tax advantages: like bringing in capital equipment at 0%, facilitation of paperwork like work permits or residence visa. Further, smaller enterprises are exempt from trading license tax for the first two years of operation. All with a view to attracting more investors and create a breeding ground for private sectors to grow. According to the National Institute of Statistics for Rwanda (NISR), the country attracted US$462 million in foreign direct investment (FDI) in 2018, representing five percent of GDP (U.S. Department of State, 2020). In 2020, that amount nearly tripled. The Rwanda Development Board (RDB) reported registering US$1.3 billion mainly from manufacturing, construction, and real estate (RDB, 2022). Predictably, these foreign direct investments resulted in creation of thousands of jobs for local inhabitants and tremendously contributed to reduce poverty rates.

That is not all, in terms of security; Rwanda is one of the safest countries in Africa. The Gallup’s Global Law and Order Index report of 2018 ranked it as the second safest place in the continent, after Egypt (Athan, 2018). Its particularly safe environment of made it a perfect destination for business and tourism alike. This is no mere a coincidence but an outcome of constant efforts and investments in their territorial security. Knowing that score of the crime and security index is among the main factors that foreign visitors and investors consider before visiting a country. On that account, it acts like a double-edged sword, that is to say, to promote both tourisms and foreign direct investments locally and internationally.

In most cases, insecurity is amongst significant factors that leads to rural exodus. With all their possessions, including their primary means of production: zebus, robbed by “dahalo” or thief, Malagasy small farmers find themselves with no other choice than migrating to towns and cities (IOM, 2019). Those farmers who are mostly uneducated, often, do not find ways to make a living in towns. This phenomenon, inevitably, increases the number of poor and poverty rate, in general. A good leader, worthy of the name, needs to comprehend the correlation between insecurity and poverty. In brief, territorial security is a key factor to consider if we truly aim to develop.

Essentially, there are many reasons for Rwanda's socio-economic development. Its accession to the Commonwealth in 2009 was, in a way, decisive for its great economic leap forward, as we will demonstrate in the following paragraphs.

4.1.5. Adhesion to the Commonwealth

By definition, The Commonwealth of Nations is a “voluntary association of 56 independent and equal countries”, mainly made up of former British Colonies, in exception of few African countries such as Mozambique, Rwanda, Gabon and Togo; which did not have a historical link with the British Empire (Commonwealth Secretariat, 2020). In fact, Mozambique was a former Portugal dominion, the Republic of Rwanda, a German and Belgian one. While, Gabon and Togo were both former French colonies. With that being said, what did drive these African countries to join the Commonwealth?

It is patent that great proportion of former British colonies are better off economically than most of French ones.

A study conducted by Andreas Bergh and Günther Fink clearly support this postulate, saying:

“In terms of their income per capita, French and British colonies did not differ much before colonies became independent in the 1960s. [...] This changed in the early 1970s, when average income per capita started to increase more rapidly in British colonies. Between 1975 and 1985, the difference between colonial groups seemed to slowly fade as one might have expected, but rather remarkably this convergence stopped around 1985, with gaps in economic outcomes widening ever since. Starting around the mid-1990s British colonies experienced relatively stable growth rates around 35% per year, while the French colonies continued to grow at rates below 2% per year on average. Overall, average income per capita more than doubled in British colonies between 1970 and 2015, while average income per capita grew by less than 25% in French colonies over the entire 45-year period.”, as displayed on the figure below (Bergh & Fink, 2018).

Figure 2: Average GDP per capita (1960-2015) in British, French and Other Colonies.

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source: Bergh & Fink, 2018

Therefore, the glaring economic disparity between former British and French dominions may explain why some African countries were inclined to join the Commonwealth lately. Indubitably, the Commonwealth of Nations confers certain opportunities to its member states. Among these are trade and education. In this regard, its members can easily have access to a global market via its 56 member states that are scattered all over the World. The CWEIC (Commonwealth Enterprise and Investment Council), presently chaired by Lord Marland, has noted: “ The Commonwealth represents 1 billion middle-class consumers; comprises 40% of the global workforce; and includes half of the top 20 global emerging cities. In addition, [...] bilateral costs for trading partners in Commonwealth countries are on average 19% lower than those between partners in Non-commonwealth States. ” (Brown, 2021). Besides, the current Secretary General, Patricia Scotland further added that the Commonwealth has 585 billion dollars’ worth of trade, during the CHOGM (Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting) 2020 in Kigali. These, with no doubt, represents non-negligible economic prospects for some developing African nations.

Still, the Commonwealth member states may also benefit from a high-quality education from other developed adherent countries. President Kagame put it in the best words during the flag raising ceremony of Rwanda in Marlborough house, London. He declared, “I hope that Rwanda can capitalize on the wide range of education and training programs that the Commonwealth provides. Secondly, we hope to tap into the trade and investment opportunities that the Commonwealth offers so that Rwanda can expand its economy and effectively participate in the global marketplace.” (Ndiho, 2010).

In addition, some African countries see the Commonwealth as a safe haven and emancipatory way from “Françafrique”. Oxford reference defines Françafrique as a “the system through which France engages with African states, most notably its former colonies.” Even after their independence, France was still eager to maintain its stranglehold to its former colonies. Filip Noubel, a journalist and managing editor for Global Voices, explains on an article saying: “France having enriched itself by exploiting energy resources and mines in its colonies was eager to keep privileged access to such resources. Paris was also preoccupied with its image as a world power, and saw sub-Saharan Africa as its pré carré (“own backyard”), from which to protect against both Soviet and American influence by maintaining military bases. General Charles de Gaulle, then president of France, saw an opportunity to maintain his country’s influence in sub-Saharan Africa by creating a web of relations that would serve its economic, diplomatic, ideological and domestic political goals” (Noubel, 2020). Henceforth, joining the Commonwealth allows African states to truly enjoy their sovereignty.

Unquestionably, joining the commonwealth in 2009 was paramount in Rwanda’s economic renaissance. Nevertheless, it would be misleading to assume that a country would develop by simply joining the Commonwealth. For the case of Rwanda, a social security reform has simultaneously been instigated from 2010.

4.1.6. Social security reform

According to the International Labour Organization (ILO), social security is “ a set of public measures that a society provides for its members to protect them against economic and social distress that would be caused by the absence or substantial reduction of income from work as a result of various contingencies like sickness, maternity, employment injury, unemployment, invalidity, old age, death and health care ” (MINECOFIN, 2009).

Further, it is stipulated in the article 22 of the universal declaration of human rights of 1948 that “everyone, as a member of society, has the right to social security and is entitled to realization, through national effort and international co-operation and in accordance with the organization and resources of each State, of the economic, social and cultural rights indispensable for his dignity and the free development of his personality.” (Op.cit.,). Thus, putting in place a social security should not be a matter of choice but rather of obligation for each country, globally.

In Rwanda, however, the government set up what came to be known as “Community Based Health Insurance (CBHI)” in 2010 to encourage equal access to health care for those in informal sector (Rwanda Social Security Board, 2024). By definition, Community Based Health Insurance (“Mutuelle de santé”) is “a solidarity health insurance system in which persons (families) come together and pay contributions for the purpose of protection and receipt of medical care. It was established in order to help people with low-income access medical care at affordable cost” (RSSB, 2024).

What made CBHI a success in Rwanda is its close partnership with the government and donors. These later contribute in paying health assurance fees of those who are less fortunate. For information, Rwandan CBHI offers 3 categories of healthcare schemes: Category 1: for indigent populations only and no fees nor co-payment is required (25% of the population), that category is fully funded by the State; Category 2: costing RWF 3,000, or US$4.65 per year / per capita for those who can afford to pay (70% of the population) and finally Category 3: tailored for those who are determined as able to pay (2 per cent of the population) and costs RWF 7,000, or US$10.85 per year / per capita (Ruberangeyo, et. Al, 2011).

The categorization is made based on socio-economic and demographic information collected nationwide at grassroots level via a program called: “Ubudehe”, which is a socioeconomic stratification system, intended to determine the real economic status of each Rwandan household. Please note that the category is not static as people’s standard of living may vary overtime. Thus, this local level structure makes sure that nobody can pretend to be poorer, for instance, and get cheaper health insurance plan. In brief, lack of social security could be a leading cause of an impoverishment. If Madagascar intends to achieve significant economic growth, it must find every possible means of making health insurance accessible and affordable for the population at large.

4.2. Results from secondary data collection

4.2.1. Questionnaires

Questionnaires could serve as valuable research tools within the field of human sciences. This approach relies on objective measurements, allowing for statistical analysis of the results.

Table 1: Details of the questionnaire participants

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source: Author, November 2024

Three academic Departments at the Faculty of Arts and Humanities of University of Antananarivo took part in the questionnaire. Participants’ age ranges from 16 to 25 years old and levels of study span from L1 (first-year undergraduate) to M2 (second-year master's). The English Department had the highest representation with 53 participants, followed by the French Department with 25, and the History Department with 22. In terms of gender, female participants outnumbered males, accounting for 59% of the total sample compared to 41% male. Overall, the questionnaire included 100 participants, reflecting a diverse group in terms of academic focus, gender, and level of study.

Table 2: Results of the questionnaire conducted with Faculty of Arts and Humanities students, University of Antananarivo.

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source: Author, November 2024

4.2.2. Interpretation of questionnaire’s results

It is clear that everyone knows that Rwanda is indeed an African country. This indicates a solid geographical understanding among the respondents. Further, a significant majority view President Paul Kagame favorably. The figure suggests a high level of approval and admiration for his leadership. This result could be interpreted as a staggering proof of the effectiveness of his policies, particularly in economic development, stability and governance. Although most respondents are aware of Rwanda's economic progress, a significant number remains less informed. This fact implies that, after all, Rwandan economic development is less recognized than it appears. Moreover, a majority seem to believe that a stronger, more centralized regime might be necessary for a country like Madagascar. It is important, however, to consider the implications of supporting a dictatorship, as it can come with serious human rights concerns. Additionally, there is some interest in adopting Rwanda's development model, but the support is not that overwhelming. The statistic suggests that while some see value in Rwanda's strategies, others may have a feeling that Madagascar's context is different from theirs. On top of that, a strong majority believes that the Commonwealth offers more economic advantages compared to Francophonie. The result indicates a perception that the Commonwealth is more beneficial for economic growth and development. Finally, there is a strong consensus that Rwanda could be a model for other developing African countries. The figure reflects the admiration of our respondents for Rwanda’s achievements in economic, social, and political spheres, signifying that many see Rwanda as a success story to emulate.

4.2.3. Interviews

Interviews conducted as part of this research (See Appendix n°5) helped confirm the hypotheses developed during our bibliographic studies. These hypotheses suggested that President Paul Kagame is ultimately not the "dictator"13 that Western media portrays, but rather a capable and committed leader, though strict, who is dedicated to the development of his country. Leaders who do not align with Western interests are often labeled as dictators or threats to democracy, in the example of Kagame. It was also confirmed that "dictatorship," or rather a “firm determination”, is a prerequisite for development. Succumbing to negative practices like corruption, embezzlement, and other forms of misconduct in an attempt to avoid being qualified as a dictator can have a detrimental effect.

Furthermore, our interviews also demonstrate that the Commonwealth offers its members more opportunities than Francophonie. The reason is simple, while the UK fosters a more equitable partnership with its members, France continues to assert a form of post-colonial dominance over its former dominions. In summary, most of the hypotheses we initially set out were largely validated throughout our interviews.

4.3. Observing the Malagasy situation through the lens of Rwanda

4.3.1. Leadership

For a country to prosper, its leader needs to set a clear and appropriate vision or program that responds to the greatest needs of the country. Since, an irrelevant stratagem could lead a nation astray. For illustrative purposes, the coup d’état of February 7 2009 in Madagascar caused the loss of 336,000 direct jobs, according to the International Labor Office (POV, 2021). To this point, no concrete action has been undertaken in finding ways to lessen joblessness. Rather, the government is more concerned to paint a shiny image of deceitful development by constructing great deal of lavish infrastructures to the detriment of real development, that is to say, improvement in people’s revenue and standard of living. There is absolutely no need, for instance, to squander government budgets projects like: cable cars or “Miami”, while the majority of the inhabitants struggle for survival (AFP, 2024).

As opposed to Rwanda, Madagascar is a country with high agricultural potential. Actually, Madagascar has nothing to envy to Rwanda as far as land surface is concerned. The big Island, measuring 587,041 km[2], with 3 million hectares of arable land, represents 20 times the size of Rwanda (Trading economics, 2021). Surprisingly, Madagascar still imported 744,846 tons of rice in 2022 and 424,007 tons in 2023 to fill the gap of its annual production, as stated by Rice Observatory Unit (ODR). For the first half of 2022, we kept importing even more rice than the previous year (Madagascar-tribune, April 30 2024).

Besides, Rwanda is well aware that one of most effective ways to combat poverty is through job creations. Knowing that decent jobs could normally uplift household revenues and by way of consequence, their standard of living. In this respect, Kagame administration negotiated with several multinational companies to relocate in their country. In June 2018, the German automobile maker Volkswagen opened a new assembly plant in Kigali and manufactured up to 5000 vehicles per year. In fact, the company invested US$20 million and created 1000 jobs for local populations (Uwiringiyimana, 2018). What is more, Rwanda also pioneered in constructing the very first smartphones fully made in Africa, from motherboards to all its electronic components, through the Mara Group (Adeyooye, 2019). Since consuming smartphone from abroad equals financially supporting foreign manufacturers. Please note that Rwanda is the world’s second biggest tantalum producer, also known as coltan, with output of 520 metric tons in 2023, a rare mineral used to make capacitors in electronic devices (Pistilli, 2024). Other minerals like lithium, niobium, zirconium and rare earth are also present in the region. Possession of those ores coupled with high-end technologies permitted Rwanda to manufacture their locally made cellphones. In fact, Mara phones are reputed for good quality and more affordable. For this reason, they can easily compete with foreign brands like Samsung, Huawei, Oppo or Xiaomi. In terms of employment, the company boasts that 90% of its workforces are Rwandans and 60% of those are women. Currently, the Mara Group counts more than 11,000 workers (Mkentane, 2019).

Regarding textile industry, Rwanda took a drastic measure to protect its nascent garment and textile industry by increasing tariffs on imported used clothes from $0.20 to $2.50 per kilo, in 2016 (Tara, 2018). Since importations of cheap second-hand clothes not only kill local textile industries but also take away jobs from local garment workers. In that sense, the Rwanda Development Board - RDB has signed an agreement with Pink Mango C&D, a Chinese garment firm, to set up a modern garment factory in Kigali Special Economic Zone (RDB, 2019). They intend to produce apparels for both domestic and export markets. In fact, Pink Mango C&D provided 7,500 jobs to local populace and targeted export earnings of US$20 million over the next five years (Ibid.). The RDB Deputy Chief Executive Officer & Chief Operating Officer, Emmanuel Hategeka made the following remark after the signing ceremony: “The investment of Pink Mango C&D will upskill Rwandans, giving them access to productive jobs and hence ensuring a better standard of living” (RDB, 2019). All in the name of overcoming poverty.

To have an idea of how devastating these western “cast-off” clothes are on African economy, let us take the case of Ghana. A study showed that importation of second-hand wears in 1980s caused a sharp drop in clothing jobs, ranging from 25,000 people in 1977 to 5,000 in 2000. Within solely 23 years, 20 thousand jobs were lost in Ghana (Benson, 2023). Things were even worse in Kenya. As the country counted around half a million garment-workers a few of decades ago, today the figure only stands at tens of thousands (Op. cit.).

Shockingly, Madagascar has done all the opposite of Rwanda. Not only we keep importing second-hand garments, the state even went further by exempting them from customs duties in 2016 (Express de Madagascar, 2016), which is nothing but adding insult to injury.

Going back to the case of Rwanda, their decision to ban western second-hand apparels made them a declared commercial enemy of the United States. In 2018, Trump administration retaliated by withdrawing benefits of Rwanda to export duty-free clothing to the US under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). Faced with this, President Kagame had the guts to confront them and did not give in, for the nation's best interests. What is more, in the aim of both creating more jobs and keeping the country clean, they went on to ban the production and importation of plastic bags and non-biodegradable packaging from 2011 (Behuria, 2021). As a result, the decision spurred the growth of paper bag making SMEs in the country. Overall, it is this true sense of patriotism and firm attitude of President Kagame that explains, in part, their economic resurgence. A quality that a number of African leaders regrettably lack. In brief, those aforementioned decisions, among many, highly contributed in creating thousands of jobs for Rwandese and substantially reduced poverty in the country.

However, in a country like Madagascar, a great deal of people associates development with tall buildings or mega infrastructures. Undoubtedly, these are external signs of development but in no way synonymous of economic growth. In other words, no matter how many buildings or prestigious infrastructures are being constructed in a given country, as long as its populace does not live with more than US$2.15 per person per day (World Bank), which is considered the global poverty line, the country in question remains in the category of poor.

4.3.2. Political stability

Sub-Saharan African countries are particularly known for their volatile political environment. Over the years, private sector in Madagascar bore the brunt of successive political violence from 1972, 1991, 2001 and 2009. Despondently, stores, media companies and food processing factories are targets of choice of rioters. Most find themselves robbed or even burned to ashes, during those tumultuous events.

In the aftermath of each political disturbance, Madagascar’s GDP growth has consistently fallen sharp to negative. According to the World Bank figure, our GDP growth was -2.62% in 1973 while it was 3.93% in 1971; likewise, in 1991 our economic growth fell at -6.31% while it was 3.13% the previous year. In the same way, in 2002 it dropped to its historical lowest level - 12.41% while we registered 5.98% the year before. Still, in 2009 it returned back to negative again to -3.98% while it hovered as high as 6.71% in 2008. Besides, the World Bank statistics confirm that Madagascar had a loss of earnings of US$8 billion between 2009 and 2013 period, alone.

Table 3: Madagascar Gross Domestic Product growth rate

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source: The World Bank

Figure 3: Madagascar Gross Domestic Product growth rate

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Source: The World Bank

What is more, political instability also negatively affects employment. As the International Labor Office says, the 2009 crisis caused a loss of 336,000 direct jobs in Madagascar. Actually, textile, construction and tourism sectors were the most affected. Since the country has been suspended from accessing the American market under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), following the coup d’état of 2009. Because we have lost that relatively huge American market, textile industries were compelled to reduce their production and subsequently, its employees. Besides, we had also seen a sharp fall of 32% in arrivals of tourists from France, our major provider of international tourists, as we were considered as an unsafe destination (POV, 2021).

4.3.3. Business environment

The African Development Bank confirms that in Madagascar, agricultural sector contributes an average of only 35% to GDP, while the secondary and tertiary sectors account for

14% and 51%, respectively. This indicates that Madagascar's economy relies more on services sector, which is somewhat inconsistent for a country traditionally considered agricultural. As a result, instead of fully utilizing our land and producing food locally, we have relied heavily on imports, except in the 60’s. The former President Didier RATSIRAKA says it best in his famous “Livre rouge” or Charter of the Socialist Revolution, (1975, 56). He uttered: “It is scandalous that a rice-producing country with an immense agricultural potential like ours is obliged to import a huge quantity of rice every year, causing a loss of foreign currency, which could have been used to buy the capital goods necessary for our development and industrialization”.

Leslie Kramer, A financial journalist and correspondent for CNBC, explains on her article entitled «How Importing and Exporting Impacts the Economy», on September 27, 2023 that,

“When exports exceed imports, the net exports figure [exports minus imports] is positive. This indicates that a country has a trade surplus. When exports are less than imports, the net exports figure is negative. This indicates that the nation has a trade deficit. A trade surplus contributes to economic growth in a country. When there are more exports, it means that there is a high level of output from a country's factories and industrial facilities, as well as a greater number of people that are being employed in order to keep these factories in operation. When a company is exporting a high level of goods, this also equates to a flow of funds into the country, which stimulates consumer spending and contributes to economic growth” (Kramer, 2023).

In short, importing goods that could have been produced locally contributes to the distortion our balance of trade and devaluation of our currency.

To prove our allegation, no matter how rich countries like the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, Israel and so forth compared to Madagascar, they preferred to find ways to exploit their barren deserts and turn them into farmlands instead of importing foodstuffs (Desert Control, 2022). Certainly, they do have financial means to import them, but they wisely opted to grow them instead. Indeed, these aforementioned countries managed to grow vegetables and several types of crops on their desert lands through variety of revolutionary agricultural technics like the use of nanoclay and drip irrigation system. By definition, nanoclay is a liquid composed mainly clay and other minerals, which is intended to increase desert’s sands water-retention ability and fertility; and developed by Ole SIVERTSEN, the CEO of Desert Control (Lovell, 2024). While, drip irrigation system is a water-saving irrigation technic that delivers water drop by drop to plants. In fact, these two innovative agricultural technics combined permitted deserts in those countries above to flourish and become agriculturally productive.

Unlike those countries with arid or even desert climate, Madagascar, in the exception of southern region, benefits roughly from 6 months of rainy season per year, is allowing itself to abandon its immense fertile lands and imports rice from India, Pakistan and Thailand instead, for several decades now (Minten & Dorosh, 2006). With no doubt, our country can easily become a giant agrarian and foodstuff supplier in the Indian Ocean, provided that we have a leader that truly understands our country’s potentials and needs (EDBM, 2022).

Going back to the case of Rwanda, they at least know their country’s potentials and limits. Therefore, the regime in place wittily aligned their VISION and programs in accordance with these ends. That is to say, promotion of services and ICT based economic activities. Henceforward, there is no wonder why the country is doing better than most African states.

4.3.4. Corruption level

In general, corruption is still rampant in Madagascar. Since a great deal of scandalous corruption allegations are never subject to serious investigation and often find themselves dismissed by the court. As an illustration, we can name the case of the “US$2 million lollipop candy” which involved a former Education Minister (Davis R, 2020). According to the Independent Anti-corruption Office (Bianco), the related file has been transmitted to the High Court of Justice (HCJ), the competent jurisdiction to judge her. Still, the court in question has not pronounced any verdict yet so far. Additionally, the ill-famed "flat screen" case which involved the Minister of the Interior and Decentralization (Bezain, 2020) where several flat screens were bought for the Covid-19 Operational Command Centre (CCO) in Ivato from a computer consumable company owned by this latter's wife, to name just a few. Much to our surprise, these flagrant suspicions of public funds embezzlement remain unpunished to date. Thus, it is this never-ending impunity among high-ranking officials, which perpetrates corruption practices in numerous African states. Apart from public funds being embezzled, most foreign investors are also reluctant to do business in a country where judicial system is riddled with bribery.

4.3.5. Social security conditions

Overall, social security remains an elusive utopia in major part of Africa. In Madagascar, for instance, it is commonplace to stumble upon celebrities being hospitalized and unable to cover their medical costs. Charity concerts, telethons or other types of funds raising are usually held in response to these incidents. As an illustration, Eric Rakotoarimanana, better known by his stage name “Eric Fou'Hehy”, a comedian, suffered from acute kidney failure in May 2018 and had to undergo a kidney transplant in India. The operation, however, costs 75,000 euros, or roughly 365 million ariary (Rakotondrazaka, 2019), which was said to be beyond the reach of the patient's family. By a curious twist of fate, he succeeded in raising all the money he needed and recovered. With all due respect, more or less the same was true of other celebrities such as Mr Gabriel Rakotomavo, known as Dadagaby, the illustrious singer Pierrot Matatana in 2019 and Tsiafarandahy Huggens Patrick, aka "Dat'kôtry" in 2023, to name just a few (Madatsara event).

In fact, this phenomenon is a microcosm of what is happening in the country. Given that even famous singers, musicians, film actors and other celebrities struggle to pay for their medical bills, it is no surprise if the 81% of the population who live on less than $2.15 a day may find it hard to get by (INSTAT, 2022). The reason behind this occurrence is simple: the quasi-absence of an affordable health insurance in the country. It is important to stress that there are already several insurance companies in the country like ARO, Allianz, ASCOMA, Sanlam, AFAFi (“Antoka ho an’ny FAhasalaman’ny Fianakaviana”) - “mutuelle de santé”, etc. that offer health insurance plans. Still, membership fees are often out of reach of the mainstream population. A child psychologist at HJRA hospital (“Hôpital Joseph Ravoahangy Andrianavalona”), Melanie Anton, witnessed: “The majority of people here can’t pay [for treatment]; they are farmers, or unemployed,” Anton further added: “Parents are worried about not being able to pay for medicines, so they pull their kids out of hospital before treatment or surgery is completed and take them back home” (Anton, 2011). Besides, workers in informal sectors that represent 95% of the total employment in Madagascar (IMF, 2023) are not covered by the “Organisation Sanitaire Tananarivienne Inter Entreprises” (OSTIE), an intercompany medical centre based in Antananarivo.

4.3.6. Membership to the Commonwealth

Madagascar is fully entitled to apply for membership in the Commonwealth, given its historical ties, though short, with Great Britain in the early 19th century. Indeed, Madagascar’s application for membership in the Commonwealth dates back in 2008, but political turmoil in 2009 delayed the process. By way of background, relations between the two Nations date back to the Napoleonic Wars (1800’s), when British forces dismantled French dominance in the Indian Ocean, seizing Mauritius, Réunion, and Seychelles. While Réunion was returned to France after the wars, Britain retained control of the other islands. To avoid the risk of French or other foreign powers gaining influence in Madagascar and threatening the strategic route to India and Ceylon, Robert Townsend Farquhar, the newly appointed governor of Mauritius, sought to establish British influence on the island. In 1817, Farquhar supported Radama I, King of Imerina, in his quest to unify Madagascar under his rule. On October 23, 1817, a treaty of friendship and peace was signed, with Britain recognizing Radama I as the monarch of the entire island. A subsequent treaty in 1820 acknowledged Madagascar as an independent state and continued to support Radama I's regime. In return, Radama agreed to abolish slavery throughout his kingdom. As a result, Britain further provided financial and material support, including gold, silver, weapons, uniforms and horses. Radama I truly admired British advancements in education, governance, and warfare, partly inspired by Britain’s defeat of his idol, Napoleon Bonaparte. Determined to modernize Madagascar in the style of Western Europe, he became an ardent Anglophile. In 1820, he invited the London Missionary Society to establish churches and schools in Antananarivo, the capital. By 1821, missionaries had gained significant influence, leading to thousands of conversions to Christianity (Knight, 2012).

In brief, Britain played a pivotal role in shaping Madagascar’s historical and developmental trajectory, which makes us fully entitled to claim membership in the Commonwealth.

It is no accident that countries like Rwanda (2009), Gabon and Togo (2022) that did not have historical ties to Britain, have joined the Commonwealth; they are well aware of the opportunities and advantages associated with it. What is preventing Madagascar from reconsidering its application for membership in the Commonwealth of Nations?

CONCLUSION

The remarkable transformation of Rwanda or the so-called "Rwandan miracle" is not a mere coincidence nor fortuitous but a result of strategic planning, visionary leadership, and an unwavering commitment to overcoming the challenges created by geography and historical ordeal. The Rwandan government has adeptly overcome its limited resources and geographic disadvantages through comprehensive development frameworks such as VISION 2020 and the Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy (EDPRS). These initiatives emphasize a pro-poor growth model that prioritizes the welfare of its citizens, ensuring that economic advancements translate into tangible improvements in standards of living. What is more, the leadership of President Paul Kagame has been pivotal in fostering an environment favorable to private sector growth, attracting foreign investment, and also promoting sectors that leverage Rwanda’s strengths, such as ICT and tourism. By prioritizing local job creation and self-reliance, initiatives like the "one cow per poor family" policy demonstrate Rwanda’s commitment to sustainable development that empowers its citizens rather than maintaining them into dependency.

The prevalence of poverty in Madagascar is a result of ill-chosen priorities and ineffective governance. Despites possessing abundant resources and agricultural potential, a lack of strategic investment and an overreliance on imports have stunted its economic growth and exacerbated poverty. Rwanda’s example underscores the importance of making informed, long-term investment decisions that align with national strengths and needs. Rwanda’s journey proves that with visionary leadership, a clear and pragmatic development strategy, and a dedication to improve the lives of its citizens, significant progress is achievable, even under challenging circumstances. As Rwanda continues to evolve, its experience offers valuable lessons for other nations seeking to break free from the cycle of poverty and build a prosperous future. A true development is about creating opportunities and ensuring that all citizens could thrive economically.

Rwanda’s remarkable ability to maintain a stable political environment has been a key factor in attracting foreign investment and establishing economic resilience. Madagascar's history of political turmoil has resulted in significant economic hindrances and job losses. Rwanda's model of governance, characterized by a paternalistic approach, seeks to empower its citizens through education and inclusive decision-making, aligning with its commitment to a unique form of consensus democracy. The liberal democracy may not always be suitable for contexts where political maturity is still trivial. By prioritizing stability and gradual empowerment, Rwanda has created a conducive environment for business and development, leading to impressive economic growth and social progress.

Rwanda’s commitment to gender equality is evidenced by its leading rate of female representation in the government. Empowering women not only supports equality but also drives economic development, underlining the interconnectedness of social justice and economic success.

Zero tolerance for corruption is among the main driving force of Rwanda’s development. By establishing a robust culture of accountability and rigorous penalties for corrupt practices, Rwanda managed to cultivate an environment where public funds are safeguarded and directed towards their intended purposes. This proactive stance not only enhances investor confidence but also contributes to the overall economic stability and growth of the nation. The entrenched culture of corruption in countries like Madagascar, where accountability mechanisms are weak and impunity prevails, the detrimental impact of corruption on governance and economic progress is horrendous.

The remarkable strides in enhancing its business environment make Rwanda a destination of choice for investment in Africa. The country’s second-place ranking in the World Bank’s Doing Business report reflects a deliberate and effective shift from bureaucratic slowness to simplified electronic processes that significantly reduce the time and effort required to register a business. This efficiency not only attracts investors but also create a favorable atmosphere for entrepreneurial growth. Rwanda's favorable policy framework, including tax incentives for both large and small enterprises, further improves its appeal to investors. The substantial influx of foreign direct investment has created numerous job opportunities and contributed to poverty reduction. Commitment to internal security plays a critical role in its attractiveness as a business hub. Being one of the safest countries in Africa not only reassures investors but also encourages tourism.

The decision of countries like Rwanda, Mozambique, Gabon, and Togo to join the Commonwealth of Nations displays a strategic shift towards embracing economic opportunities and asserting sovereignty outside traditional colonial ties. The economic disparity observed between former British and French colonies illustrates a clear incentive for these nations to align with partners that promises greater economic growth and access to global markets. The Commonwealth not only offers trade benefits, as evidenced by lower bilateral costs and substantial trade volume, but also provides invaluable educational resources that can drive development. Joining the Commonwealth served as a mean for certain countries to distance themselves from the lingering influence of their former colonial powers. Rwanda's accession to the Commonwealth in 2009 has played a crucial role in its economic transformation, demonstrating that while membership provides significant advantages, it must be coupled with relevant domestic policies and reforms.

As opposed to Rwanda, Madagascar has relatively a weak social security system. The present research found that Madagascar has a weak safety net, which leaves many people, even celebrities, struggling with medical costs, in case of serious illness. Rwanda’s Community Based Health Insurance (CBHI) program helps many people to access affordable healthcare. The findings show that a good health insurance can significantly reduce poverty and promote fairness in society. To boost its economy and enhance the well-being of its citizens, Madagascar must facilitate access to affordable health insurance.

Transformation of Rwanda following the 1994 genocide is a result of state intervention and economic planning, rooted in the concept of the developmental state. Under the leadership of President Paul Kagame, Rwanda adopted an approach similar to that of East Asian nations, particularly Japan and Singapore, focusing on rapid economic growth through strategic government involvement in the economy; rather than relying solely on the market. The Rwandan experience proves that developmentalism could also work in Africa. What on earth hinders Madagascar from adopting it and follow the footsteps of Rwanda?

BIBLIOGRAPHY

- Askin, Steve. Food Aid Diversion, Middle East Report.1987. 145

- Bergh, Andreas; Fink, Guenther. The French curse? On the puzzling economic consequences of French colonization. 2018. IFN Working Paper, No. 1234, Research Institute of Industrial Economics (IFN), Stockholm. pp.04-05

- Bresser-Pereira, Luiz Carlos. Models of the developmental state. 2016. pp.36-37

- Byanafashe, Déo & Rutayisire, Paul. History of Rwanda. 2016. National Unity and Reconciliation Commission (NURC). pp.182-225

- Campioni, Maddalena & Noack, Patrick. Rwanda Fast Forward: Social, Economic, Military and Reconciliation Prospects. 2012

- Crisafulli, Patricia & Redmond, Andrea. Rwanda, Inc.: How a Devastated Nation Became an Economic Model for the Developing World. 2012

- Doepke, Matthias & Tertilt, Michèle. Does Female Empowerment Promote Economic Development ? February 2014. National Bureau of Economic Research. Cambridge. 01

- Dr Hornsby, Robert. Political Protest and Dissent in the Khrushchev Era. 2008. 213

- EDBM. Invest in Agribusiness, Madagascar _ Breadbasket of the Indian Ocean. 2022. 16

- Folarin, Sheriff F.. Rwanda’s Radical Transformation Since the End of the 1994 Genocide against the Tutsi. 2023

- Geraghty, Mark Anthony. Gacaca, Genocide, Genocide Ideology: The Violent Aftermaths of Transitional Justice in the New Rwanda. 2020. Comparative Studies in Society and History, 62(3), pp.588-618

- Ggombe, Kasim Munyegera & Newfarmer, Richard S. Industries without Smokestacks: Industrialization in Africa Reconsidered. 20 December 2018. Oxford Academic. 317

- Gouranga, G. Das and Rukundo, Bosco Johnson. Rwandan Economy at the Crossroads of Development: Key Macroeconomic and Microeconomic Perspectives. 2020

- Henry Louis Gates, Jr. & Kwame Anthony Appiah. Encyclopedia of Africa, Oxford University Press, 177

- International Organization for Migration (IOM). Mainstreaming Migration into Rural and Urban Development - Assessment Report: Madagascar. 2020. IOM. Brussels. 05

- Kinzer. Stephen. A Thousand Hills: Rwanda’s Rebirth and the Man Who Dreamed It. 2008

- Lijphart, Arend. Democracies: Patterns of Majoritarian and Consensus Government in Twenty- One Countries. 1984. Yale University Press. 30

- Longman, Timothy. Rewriting History in Post-Genocide Rwanda. 2017

- Ministry of Finance and Economic planning - Republic of Rwanda. National social security policy. February 2009. 03

- Minten, Bart & Dorosh, Paul. Rice Markets in Madagascar in Disarray: Policy Options for Increased Efficiency and Price Stabilization. September 2006. 08

- Mutabazi, Alphonse. Rwanda Country Situational Analysis. May 2011. 08

- Pov & Andrianirina. Dictionnaire de la démocratie de façade. 2021. 97

- Professor Chiedu Moghalu, Kingsley. The Rwandan Genocide: The Politics of Global Justice. 2005

- Ratsiraka, Didier. Livre rouge or Charter of the Socialist Revolution. 1975. 56

- REMA (Rwanda Environment Management Authority). RWANDA Atlas of our changing environment. 2018. 03

- Reyntjens, Filip. Rwanda, ten years on: from genocide to dictatorship. 2004.183

- Takeuchi, Shinichi. Development and Developmentalism in Post-genocide Rwanda. 2019

- Takeuchi, Shinichi. Developmental State Building - Development and Developmentalism in Postgenocide Rwanda. 19 January 2019. pp.121-134

- UNDP. 3rd Rwanda National Human Development Report. August 2021. 08

- Wallis, Andrew. Rwanda: Rebuilding of a Nation. 2015

- Waugh, Colin M. Paul Kagame and Rwanda: Power, Genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front. 2004

- Waugh, Colin M. Paul Kagame and Rwanda: power, genocide and the Rwandan Patriotic Front. 2004. McFarland & Co. Publishers. 03

- Zorobabel Bicabaa, Schwidrowski Zuzana Brixiova & Ncube, Mthuli. Eliminating Extreme Poverty in Africa: Trends, Policies and the Role of International Organizations. May 2015. African development Bank Group. 04

WEBOGRAPHY

- Africa news. It is Nigeria, a country in West Africa, which stands out as the most powerful economy on the continent. With a GDP estimated at $477 billion in 2022, Nigeria is at the top of the ranking of the richest African countries, ahead of Egypt and South Africa. 2023 https://www.africanews.com/2023/12/08/here-are-the-richest-countries-m-africa/Accessed 30 November 2024

- AFP (Agence France Presse). June 21 2024 https://www.barrons.com/articles/madagascar-president-opens-new-cable-car-in-capital-577ffca2 Accessed 30 November 2024

- Akamanzi, Clare. Clare Akamanzi explains how Rwanda is encouraging private sector development. June 2019. IMF https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2019/06/private-sector-development-in-rwanda- trenches Accessed on 18 May 2024

- Ashimwe, Edwin. Rwanda: Ex-Energy Boss Nyamvumba Handed Six-Year Sentence, Fined Rwf21 Billion. September 29 2020 https://allafrica.com/stories/202009300127.html Accessed 05 July 2024

- Anton, Melanie. Cancer treatment for the lucky few. May 30 2011 https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/report/92843/madagascar-cancer-treatment-lucky-few Accessed 04 December 2024

- Ban Ki-moon. Rwanda genocide: UN ashamed, says Ban Ki-moon. April 7 2014. BBC News https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-26917419 Accessed 25 November 2024

- Barbisotti, Martina. The United Nations and the Rwandan genocide. October 13 2023 https://unipd-centrodirittiumani.it/en/topics/the-united-nations-and-the-rwandan-genocide Accessed 25 November 2024

- Barabak Mark Z. & Duara Nigel. “ We’re called redneck, ignorant, racist. That’s not true’: Trump supporters explain why they voted for him ”. November 13 2016. Los Angeles Times https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-donald-trump-american-voices-20161113-story.html Accessed 24 November 2024

- Behuria, Pritish. Ban the (plastic) bag? Explaining variation in the implementation of plastic bag bans in Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda. February 2021. University of Manchester-UK, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349473289 Ban the plastic bag Explaining variation in the implementation of plastic bag bans in Rwanda Kenya and Uganda Accessed 02 July 2024

- Benson, Sophie. Q&A: The Or Foundation on the Realities of the Global Second Hand Clothing Market. September 2023 https://goodonyou.eco/or-foundation-global-second-hand-clothing-market/Accessed 02 December 2024

- Bezain, Laetitia. Madagascar: la société civile dénonce un conflit d'intérêts dans un marché public de matériel informatique (Madagascar: civil society denounces a conflict of interest in a public procurement contract for IT equipment). August 23 2020. Radio France International, https://www.rfi.fr/fr/afrique/20200823-madagascar-soci%C3%A9t%C3%A9-civile-conflit-d- int%C3%A9r%C3%AAts-march%C3%A9-public-mat%C3%A9riel-info Accessed 24 November 2024

- Bizimungu, Julius. Rwanda Targets U.S.$74 Million From Conference Tourism. August 03 2018. NewTimes Rwanda, https://goplacesdigital.com/east-africa-travel-and-tourism-news-from-3rd-10th-august-2018/ Accessed 02 July 2024

- Bresser-Pereira, Luiz Carlos. The two forms of capitalism: developmentalism and economic liberalism. 2017 https://www.scielo.br/j/rep/a/kmwCJdCqH5JqN7JLrB3hpcm/Accessed on 16 March 2024

- Britannica. Rwanda genocide of 1994. April 7 2024. Encyclopedia Britannica https://www.britannica.com/event/Rwanda-genocide-of-1994. Accessed 13 May 2024.

- Blundo, Giorgio & Olivier de Sardan, Jean-Pierre. La corruption quotidienne en Afrique de l'Ouest (Day-to-day corruption in West Africa). 2001. Politique africaine, 83, 8-37 https://www.caim.info/revue-politique-africaine-2001-3-page-8.htm Accessed 05 July 2024

- Brown, Thomas. Renewing the UK’s trading relationship with Commonwealth countries. July 2021. House of Lords Library. the UK Parliament, https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/renewing-the-uks-trading-relationship-with-commonwealth- countries/Accessed on 13 April 2024

- Chang, Ha-Joon. The East-Asian Development Model. April 8 2023 https://www.tutor2u.net/economics/reference/the-east-asian-development-model Accessed 26 November 2024

- Commonwealth Secretariat. New date announced for Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM). 23 September 2020 https://thecommonwealth.org/news/new-date-announced-commonwealth-heads-government- meeting-chogm Accessed 06 December 2024

- Davis R. Affaire de bonbons-sucette à 8 milliards Ar : Le dossier de l’ex-ministre Rijasoa Andriamanana déjà transmis à la HCJ (8 billion Ar candy-sweets case: The case of former minister Rijasoa Andriamanana already referred to the HCJ). June 22 2020. Midi Madagasikara, https://midi-madagasikara.mg/affaire-de-bonbons-sucette-a-8-milliards-ar-le-dossier-de-lex- ministre-rijasoa-andriamanana-deja-transmis-a-la-hcj/Accessed 24 November 2024

- Desert Control. From sand to soil in 7 hours. 2022 https://impact.desertcontrol.com/uaefarming Accessed 02 December 2024

- DGIE (Rwanda Directorate General of Immigration and Emigration), 2024 https://www.migration.gov.rw/about-rwanda Accessed 15 May 2024

- Dunning, David. The Psychological Quirk That Explains Why You Love Donald Trump. 2016 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/05/donald-trump-supporters-dunning-kruger- effect-213904/Accessed on 27 March 2024

- East Africa Living Encyclopedia. Rwanda - History. University of Pennsylvania https://www.africa.upenn.edu/NEH/rwhistory.htm Accessed 16 May 2024

- Encyclopedia Britannica. John Hanning Speke. April 30 2024 https://www.britannica.com/biography/John-Hanning-Speke Accessed 15 May 2024

- Encyclopedia Britannica. Persian Gulf War. April 8 2024 https://www.britannica.com/event/Persian-Gulf-War Accessed 16 May 2024

- Emmanuel Macron. Rwanda - Speech by President Emmanuel Macron at the Kigali Genocide Memorial (Kigali, 27 May 2021). May 27 2021. France Diplomacy https://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/country-files/rwanda/news/article/rwanda-speech-by-president- emmanuel-macron-at-the-kigali-genocide-memorial Accessed 24 November 2024

- ESCWA (Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia). Developmental State model. https://archive.unescwa.org/developmental-state-model Accessed 26 November 2024

- Express de Madagascar. Commerce avec l ’Europe - Zéro droit de douane sur les fripperies (Trade with Europe - Zero customs duties on second-hand clothes). January 13 2016 https://www.bilaterals.org/?commerce-avec-l-europe-zero-droit&lang=en Accessed 04 December 2024

- Jonathan Scott. 2020 Investment Climate Statements: Rwanda. 2020. U.S. Department of State, https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-investment-climate-statements/rwanda/#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20National%20Institute,latest%20year%20 data%20is%20available. Accessed 05 July 2024

- John Connolly. Why is a former French colony joining the Commonwealth? July 4 2022. The spectator https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-is-a-former-french-colony-joining-the-commonwealth/Accessed 24 November 2024

- House of Commons. Women in Politics and Public Life. March 06 2024. UK Parliament https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01250/Accessed 06 December 2024

- Kamanzi M, Nicole. Former Minister Dr. Munyakazi sentenced to 10 years. October 17 2020 https://en.igihe.com/news/article/former-minister-dr-munyakazi-sentenced-to-10-years Accessed 05 July 2024

- Kofi Annan. Address by Kofi Annan to the Commission on Human Rights. April 07 2004 https://www.un.org/sg/en/content/sg/speeches/2004-04-07/address-kofi-annan-commission- human-rights Accessed 25 November 2024

- Kramer, Leslie. How Importing and Exporting Impacts the Economy. September 27 2023 https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/100813/interesting-facts-about-imports-and- exports.asp Accessed 30 November 2024

- Knight, White. Commonwealth Stamps Opinion. 29 January 2012 https://commonwealthstampsopinion.blogspot.com/2012/01/madagascar.html#:~:text=At%20som e%20time%20in%20the,any%20further%20for%20the%20present. Accessed 03 December 2024

- Hopkins David. Perestroika and Glasnost: Definition, History & Results. 2023 https://study.com/academy/lesson/perestroika-definition-lesson.html Accessed 30 March 2024

- Lebovic, Sam. Why Is America the World’s Police? October 19 2020 https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/sam-lebovic-stephen-wertheim-tomorrow-the-world/Accessed 26 November 2024

- Lesniewski, Rainer. February 3 2018 https://www.istockphoto.com/fr/vectoriel/carte-administrative-et-politique-de-rwanda- gm913819906-251543845 Accessed 24 November 2024

- Lovell, Rachel. Nanoclay: the liquid turning desert to farmland. 2024 https://www.bbc.com/future/bespoke/follow-the-food/the-spray-that-turns-deserts-into- farmland.html Accessed 02 December 2024

- Maron, Jeremy. What led to the genocide against the Tutsi in Rwanda? June 26 2019. Canadian Museum for Human Rights https://humanrights.ca/story/what-led-genocide-against-tutsi-rwanda Accessed 16 May 2024

- Madatsara event, 2024 https://madatsara.com/recherche.html?s=tolotanana&startdate=&enddate=&thematic=&place=&a rtist=&organizer=&token=7daa765d0290c68ffded506.NmB5uWnX9B1uu1E33 WqhjtM80QqKt 3euSgsP5DUW18.Rg0sihiNx3kv igC7pPE6nJ43jFfHYmV-kF9VtmGGRdkDU7WK-CtbS3cBA Accessed 04 December 2024

- Mandimbisoa R. Baisse des importations de riz (Fall in rice imports) . April 30 2024 https://www.madagascar-tribune.com/Baisse-des-importations-de-riz.html#:~:text=Cette%20performance%20exceptionnelle%20a%20permis,424%20007%20tonne s%20en%202023. Accessed 27 June 2024

- Mapsland, 2024 https://www.mapsland.com/africa/rwanda/large-location-map-of-rwanda Accessed 24 November 2024

- Mkentane, Luyolo. Made in Africa’ smartphone will be manufactured in KwaZulu-Natal. October 16 2019 https://www.businesslive. co.za/fm/fm-fox/2019-10-16-made-in-africa-smartphone-will-be-manufactured-in-kwazulu-natal/#google vignette Accessed 02 July 2024

- MINAGRI. Rwandans laud agricultural programmes during this year’s Umushyikirano. 2024 https://www.minagri.gov.rw/updates/news-details/rwandans-laud-agricultural-programmes- during-this-year-s-umushyikirano Accessed 30 November 2024

- Ndiho, Paul. Rwanda inducted into the Commonwealth. March 2010 https://paulndiho.com/2010/03/09/rwanda-inducted-into-the-commonwealth/Accessed on 12 April 2024

- NISR (National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda). 2023 https://www.statistics.gov.rw/publication/Rwanda population 2022 Accessed 15 May 2024

- Noubel, Filip. Françafrique': A term for a contested reality in Franco-African relations. February 2020 https://globalvoices.org/2020/02/05/francafrique-a-term-for-a-contested-reality-in-franco-african- relations/Accessed 12 April 2024

- Oluwafisayo Dorcas Adeyooye. Made in Rwanda, Mara Phones is Africa’s first fully made smartphone. October 2019 https://www.builtinafrica.io/videos/mara-phones-rwanda Accessed 01 July 2024

- Paul Kagame. Our number one asset is our People- Kagame. February 26 2016 https://www.paulkagame.com/our-number-one-asset-is-our-people-kagame-4/Accessed 22 November 2024

- Parliament of Rwanda. Women representation. 2024 https://www.parliament.gov.rw/women-representation Accessed 06 December 2024

- Pistilli, Melissa. Top 5 Tantalum-mining Countries (Updated 2024) ”. 2024 https://investingnews.com/daily/resource-investing/critical-metals-investing/tantalum- investing/2013-top-tantalum-producers-rwanda-brazil-drc-canada/#toggle-gdpr Accessed 02 December 2024

- President John F. Kennedy. Remarks in Nashville at the 90th anniversary convocation of Vanderbilt University. May 18 1963 https://www.jfklibrary.org/archives/other-resources/john-f-kennedy-speeches/vanderbilt- university-19630518 Accessed 13 May 2024

- Professor Soko, Mills. What drove Asia’s economic success stories, and what should Africa emulate? July 2020 https://theconversation.com/what-drove-asias-economic-success-stories-and-what-should-africa- emulate-143361 Accessed on 25 March 2024

- Professor Uwizeyimana, Dominique Emmanuel. Is a Singaporean-modelled developmental approach viable for other African nations? Lessons from Rwanda. Mar 1 2019. University of Johannesburg https://journals.co.za/doi/epdf/10.31920/2516-5305/2019/v16n1a10 Accessed 13 May 2024

- Quoteresearch. Chinese Proverb? Maimonides? Lao-Tzu? Anne Isabella Thackeray Ritchie? Italian Adage? Native American Saying? Mao Zedong? August 28, 2015 https://quoteinvestigator.com/2015/08/28/fish/Accessed 30 November 2024

- Rakotondrazaka, Andry Patrick. Levée de fonds - Eric « Fou Hehy » cherche 75 000 euros (Fundraising - Eric "Fou Hehy" seeks €75,000). February 19 2019 . L'Express de Madagascar https://lexpress.mg/19/02/2019/levee-de-fonds-eric-fou-hehy-cherche-75-000-euros/Accessed 11 July 2024

- RDB. Rwanda partners with Chinese garment firm to set up a modern garment factory. May 10 2019 https://rdb.rw/rwanda-partners-with-chinese-garment-firm-to-set-up-a-modern-garment-factory/ Accessed 02 December 2024

- RDB. Rwandan Culture and Traditions. 2024 https://visitrwanda.com/interests/rwandan-culture-and-traditions/#:~:text=Culture%20and%20Traditions-,Umuganda,their%20nation%20as%20a%20whole. Accessed 27 November 2024

- RSSB (Rwanda Social Security Board). CBHI Scheme. 2024 https://www.rssb.rw/scheme/cbhi-scheme Accessed 05 December 2024

- Ruberangeyo, Theophile et al. Rwanda's Community Based Health Insurance. 2011 https://www.socialprotection-toolbox.org/practice/rwandas-community-based-health-insurance Accessed 25 April 2024

- Sgt Fusco, Vincent. Rwanda president visits West Point. March 14 2010 https://www.army.mil/article/35854/rwanda president visits west point Accessed 22 November 2024

- Tashobya, Athan. Gallup report: Rwanda is second safest place in Africa. June 2018. The New Times https://www.newtimes.co.rw/article/154869/News/gallup-report-rwanda-is-second-safest-place-in- africa Accessed 09 July 2024

- Tara John. How the US and Rwanda have fallen out over second-hand clothes. 28 May 2018 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-44252655 Accessed 02 July 2024

- Thompson, Lindsay J. Paternalism. December 23 2013. Encyclopedia Britannica https://www.britannica.com/topic/paternalism. Accessed 25 April 2024

- The United Nations. Peace, dignity and equality on a healthy planet. n.d. https://www.un.org/en/about-us/un-charter/chapter-1 Accessed 25 November 2024

- Transparency International. Our work in Rwanda. 2024 https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/rwanda Accessed 06 December 2024

- UNESCO, 2022 https://en.wal.unesco.org/countries/rwanda/languages/kinyarwanda-2 Accessed 15 May 2024

- Uwiringiyimana, Clement. Volkswagen opens Rwanda's first car plant. June 27 2018 https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSKBN1JN0NF/Accessed 01 July 2024

- Zuber, David. Grégoire Kayibanda (1924-1976). March 23 2022 https://www.blackpast.org/global-african-history/people-global-african-history/gregoire- kayibanda-1924-1976/Accessed 20 May 2024

APPENDICES

Appendix 1: Questionnaires in English version for the English department students

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Appendix 2: Questionnaires in the History and French department students

Abb. in Leseprobe nicht enthalten

Appendix 3: An excerpt of transcript of President Kagame’s interview with Aljazeera’s journalist Riz Khan, 28 January 2011.

Riz Khan: Mr. President, good to have some time with you!

President Kagame: Thank you

Riz Khan: The anti-corruption watch-dog, the Transparency International, has listed Rwanda as one of the least corrupt nations, saying that corruption there is pretty much negligible. What are you doing right?

President Kagame: Well, first of all we discuss it so that our people know how bad corruption is. It’s a daily conversation, it’s in education. Everybody knows how bad it is; we emphasize that corruption will derail our economy, progress, spoil our politics - it is simply negative to what we intend to achieve. We have also put rules and policies in place to fight corruption. Since we have also created the rule of law, and made sure there is no impunity when it comes to corruption, this has worked and people are served very well.

Riz Khan: What benefits has Rwanda seen from controlling corruption?

President Kagame: Public service delivery is as you would have it. Whether it is buying drugs and taking them to hospital or any other service to our people, it goes there directly. Every penny we spend on the development of our people goes where we it is intended and the benefits are huge. People associate themselves with that and understand the benefits.

Appendix 4: An excerpt of transcript of President Kagame speaking as guest lecturer at Harvard Business School, Boston, 26 February 2016.

Paul Kagame: Thank you, Professor Ora.

First of all, I want to say that our situation, Rwanda's case is a very complex one, but is full of lessons not only for Rwandans, maybe for the rest of the world, and specifically for Africa.

It shows what we are capable of in two ways. One, where we put ourselves the tragedy of 94, the destruction that came with it. So it shows how human beings are capable of the worst things that they can do for themselves.

But 22 years down the road, it also shows what human beings are capable. Coming from this background of a tragedy to a situation where not only comparison can be made between our situation with the normal situations, but also how, in fact, in some instances, Rwanda can provide examples to learn from across the world.

If you look at the reforms we have carried out in many areas, Rwanda ranking in terms of doing business by global institutions, among the top, competitiveness of economy is among the top and consistently, and the growth of our economy has been registered for the last 14 years, between 7 and 8% every year.

Women empowerment and participation in politics, business decision making; 64% of our women representing the country in parliament, 40% in the cabinet, between 40 and 50 in the judiciary. In terms of education, there is quantity, which is very important, but I think there is quality to it as well. If you look at the enrolment rates, primary schools, secondary and into higher education, the figures speak for themselves.

So normally in education there are two problems. One, you have the quantities, how many people are you able to educate. But it's also the quality. Well, we have places (in Africa) where both are a problem.

In fact, we started from a point where both were a problem. So we have tackled them one after another, that is, the enrolment rate. The other one we are now working on and investing in is the quality of education.

So put together, still we are in a good place. If you compare with many other countries which, in fact, should be ahead of us, given where we have been and the situation we have had to manage in health; the universal coverage that our people have is among the best in the world. Again, working on quality. It's not just about numbers; it's also about quality that has to accompany it. And that again is also registering significant increase.

A student: I'm curious about your vision for the future of Rwanda over the next 10 to 20 years?

Paul Kagame: Well, my vision for the future is not divorced from the vision we have had. One, the vision we have had is really hinged on people, their well-being, their development. And then the rest are those things that enable us to be where we want to be. But the aim is to be a stable, secure and prosperous country. The aspiration is really the same for all people, whether it is in Rwanda, Africa or other parts of the world. So, I think we've been doing a lot, as I said earlier, to build the foundation, a very firm foundation on which we can keep building for the well-being of Rwandans. I think we are going to do probably better than anybody, as our number one asset is our people. That is why we invest in our people for their health, their education and skills.

A student: Thank you very much for being here. The mill convention brought up electricity point. I think it's a fair point that you made great progress, went from 2% to 9% of the population in terms of access to electricity but that’s still 9%. What is your take on this?

Paul Kagame: The current connections for electricity are at 22% and that is off and on grid connections. In the next two to three years, our aim is to have 70%. That is possible because of the investments that are already underway now. Initially our main source of electricity is hydro but we have right now 25 MW from methane gas. Methane gas to power is something that has taken a bit of time because of the technology. But now it is proven that it is working and we have methane gas under Lake kivu in large amounts. It is roughly 66 billion cubic meters. With only 3 billion cubic meters, we can have between 700 and 800 megawatts and this is for a very long time because the gas keeps regenerating itself.

A student: I was wondering how your strategy in national identity building and how important that was in kind of the programs that you came up with in Rwanda?

Paul Kagame: Yes, that's a very good question. In fact, I should quickly say what has helped us with the tragedy is (because) we talked about. It helped mobilize people in different sections of our population that were affected or had been affected by the atrocity. After the tragedy, everyone took note that nobody benefited from it. Not a single family, not a single individual, everybody lost, whichever side they were from. So, there was a compelling need for people to get together and unity of our people working together is the best thing. It is the way forward for all of us. So that has helped to mobilize people and everybody is engaged. That's why even some of the programs actually we cut out are easier to implement in our case than probably in many other cases that you may think of. There is that unit of purpose. There is that understanding that we have a bad history. Everybody suffered and nobody doesn't want a good future. So good politics, mobilizing people to work together, good policies, coming together, I think have given us what we are seeing as very good progress and sustainable.

A student: I’m Helen. I come from Senegal. I was comparing the Senegal result and I was really impressed by the result in education where you were able to have 29 universities since from one in 1994. In Senegal you have 10 universities. You have a long tradition of education and very strong support on that sector. So the success is impressive. And I guess there is some... Some reason, underlying reason, very powerful underlying reason for that. And also I thought that based on what is very specific to Rwanda compared to other African countries. We are both an Anglophone and a French country. I was wondering if you see education as a sector in which you can become a hub of excellence for Africa and that on which you can really be able to attract student progress. And how can you do that? And how can you build growth based on the sector?

Paul Kagame: Sure! Thank you. I mean that is already happening in a number of ways. In fact, for example, Carnegie Mellon University has a campus in Rwanda, especially for master's level education. Mainly in computer science and so on. This is a program we developed with them and got support from the African Development Bank. We asked them to support it. And the whole idea was again to deal with the quality of education. And also it doesn't stop our young people to continue to go abroad to study in very good universities that are there. Certainly, we want that to happen; that it continues to happen. But we also wanted to make sure that we avail this quality institution as this one is. In fact, not only to serve Rwanda but also to serve the region. In fact, the East African community region has endorsed it as a centre of excellence where most of their people will be coming to be educated and trained. That is why Rwanda is now hosting the African Institute of Mathematical Sciences. So it's because of this, the centre used to be in South Africa. It has now relocated to Rwanda. But it's in that quest to create good institutions or higher learning as well as feed it from the bottom. And in the end, if this turns it into a hub, so be it. We'll be very happy. But our main focus is really to make sure that our people and together with other Africans who can also benefit from what we are benefiting from, is what we want to create.

A student: Are there any lessons that you think could be, from the work that you've done, that you think could apply to other African countries that are where you were in 2000? So are there one or two lessons and things that you did that really could be applying to other cases that are in the same position?

Paul Kagame: Well, I guess so, even if I think of any specific one. Because Rwanda, like other African countries, there are many similarities as much as there are some differences, but I think there are more similarities than differences. So for example, it's all about how you manage whether politics or economics. For example, if there is fighting corruption, which has bled our economy. If the model we have applied of accountability from the bottom, the top or top to bottom, then other countries can do that. Why not? It's all about political will, it's whether you decided and are committed to doing it, and it will happen. So I think that's the main thing. I'm sure there are lessons to learn. As we have learned lessons from other places, the things we are doing, some of them have been experimental, but others we have right away picked from other places and applied them to our own situation and things have worked. So if they can work for us from elsewhere, then from Rwanda, things may work for others as well.

A student: I just wanted to add to that point. I find it interesting that the Rwandan Development Board was modelled after Singapore. And also the goal of your vision 2020 was very much to follow a trajectory where you become a knowledge-based economy by 2020. And so, I was curious to get your thoughts on sort of how you chose to follow this development model, and what challenges you foresee in following this development trajectory, and where you might see the potential divergence?

Paul Kagame: Right! I have just said we've learned from other countries, from other people's experiences. And definitely, we are very close to Singapore. We work very closely with them. In fact, they have participated in a number of things where they have helped us given from. So what we do is like we go out and do some shopping. We go to countries. And we go to Singapore. And look at the things we like. And not only the things we like, but things that may work for us. And then we choose. So in our shopping process, we liked what we saw in Singapore. And so given the good relationship, we had learned a few things and worked together. And some of the things shaped around that. And then, as again I said, for Rwanda, we have a lot of opportunities. We have a lot of people. And in the end, we have to make sure that the number one asset is our people. And with the people, you just have to invest in education and training and their health. And then the rest, infrastructure, all kinds of other things, just help to prepare whatever we want to do for it.

A student: I have a few comments (to make) from your case, and of course it ends in 2009. But looking at the FDIs being just north of 1% of GDP, the exports growth between 2004 and 2009, and also seeing that the commercial lending rates have not really gone down below 16%, there will be a perceived sense that there is weakness in the private sector, especially towards export- oriented growth. How did your government and how did you actually manage to change the way you moved?

Paul Kagame: It takes time. It has been happening over time. Private sector, like many other sectors in our country, have also started from a very low base indeed. But we have... We have benefited from more people being exposed, and now the private sector level of effectiveness in our economy has completely changed and has been growing over time. In fact, we have also been seeing more FDIs coming in. Last year alone, we, for example, went up to 1.2 billion U.S. dollars that came in.

Appendix 5: Summary of Interview with Hemerson Andrianetrazafy (Mahamasina - September 27, 2024)

Is Paul Kagame a good leader?

When we talk about Paul Kagame, there are rumours spread especially by the West saying that freedom of Rwandan people is trampled by the regime. We know at least the oppositions in Rwanda are struggling. Is he a good leader? If we look at the history of Rwanda, with all the challenge the country has been through, killings between Hutus and Tutsis at time. We must recognize that Rwanda’s recovery can be largely attributed to Paul Kagame. Aside from economic development, there was a social development because they introduced the concept of Unity through diversity. This end was coupled with Cultural Revolution. This shows the importance of politics of culture in a society. And they had a clear vision of what they wish to achieve as a country. To me, aside from those leaders who were assassinated by foreign powers which I will not mention, as they are numerous; Paul Kagame is among good leaders, worthy of the name. My concern for Kagame, though, is that he starts to have the flaw of most of African leaders of clinging into power. He has been President for decades now. And this may tannish his messianic image.

What do you think was behind Rwanda’s economic development?

Well, what brought about development in Rwanda is as follows and this has been proven throughout History. Whenever a society is on the brink of destruction, it will wake up to reason. Rwandans draw lessons from their historical experiences and worked tremendously to mend their nation. Thus, development starts from self-consciousness. Apart from that, inclusion and involvement of every member of the community in the development process, especially in business and entrepreneurship, played a key role in Rwanda’s economic development. That economic inclusion is something we lack in Africa, especially in Madagascar. We, the average citizen who make up majority of the population, do not have our say in this country’s life.

Everything is decided from the top. However, whenever people is not involved in the development process, no progress could be expected. Besides, the number wealth or asset of a country is its people. Hence, if people are not being taken care of properly or not provided with favourable environment for them to thrive, they are likely to remain poor. I find it stupid that we need to depend on foreign investors to develop our country. Why don’t you empower, educate and training your people to be an engine of economic growth. Unlike in Rwanda, Malagasy people in general sense are being excluded from the process of development. It is deeply troubling to learn that in Madagascar, education is being dismantled certain regime to keep people in ignorance and poverty, preventing them from rising up against their plight. Only in Anosy, a neighbourhood in the heart of Antananarivo, there are countless children begging on the street. They are not part of the schooling system. And the street is what educates them. What will they become after 5 to 10 years? It is no surprising if poverty and insecurity are exacerbating. Not so happens in Rwanda, they knew to turn things around and overcame the issue. We need an inclusive approach to tackle our country’s challenge. Thus, it is quite normal if Rwanda’s economy is doing better, because of aforementioned reasons.

According to you, do we need a dictatorship regime in Madagascar or not?

One must not equate dictatorship with rigor. Adopting firm positions to ensure the successful implementation of a development program does not mean totalitarianism. That is being responsible. Dictatorship occurs when people are merely compliant. When the government's vision is clear to the people, along with steps required to achieve it, and there is will be no dictatorship at all. To me, totalitarianism arises when rulers take unilateral decisions that go against the best interests of the people. You asked me if we need dictatorship in Madagascar. In my opinion, we need first to put in place a society that best suits our need and common goods. To answer your question, if dictatorship happens in Madagascar, I will be the first to oppose it.

Is it more beneficial more an African country to be part of the Commonwealth or Francophony?

Commonwealth is the community of former British colonies. As such, they have English as a common anchor. Francophonie is the new, the third form of neo-colonialism. There is cultural colonialism. I present French as a language of culture and communication. It is completely natural for Francophones to get along or establish something they have in common. But here’s the thing. At its core, and we must once again refer to history, the Anglo-Saxon logic is not the same as the Latin-French logic. The French opted for what is called "contact racism." They saw themselves as the bearers of civilization, as mentors, as guides; above this mass of believers, they called natives. But their policy aimed to assimilate, to take what seemed closest to their standards of nationalization and assimilation. And to be assimilated, you had to adhere to their norms. You had to know all the rules of conjugation, syntax, know the great authors, and possess general knowledge with an encyclopaedic inclination, etc. And the British? They were never assimilationists. That’s why Indo-Pakistanis remained Indo-Pakistanis. They kept their traditions, their religious practices despite the significant initiatives undertaken by religious congregations like the London Mission Society or the Quaker Union. In brief, members of the Commonwealth have a stronger and more deeply rooted sense of identity than the Francophones.

[...]


1 Tutsi also called Watusi, Watutsi or Abatutsi is a bantu-speaking ethnic group of the African Great Lakes region of Rwanda and Burundi. They (Tutsis) are mostly very tall and slender (Britannica, 2024).

2 The eight Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), which range from halving extreme poverty rates to halting the spread of HIV/AIDS and providing universal primary education, all by the target date of 2015, form a blueprint agreed to by all the world’s countries and all the world’s leading development institutions (un.org, 2024).

3 The East Asian development model (developmentalism) is a term used to describe the economic development strategies that have been pursued by the countries of East Asia, such as Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. These strategies have been characterized by high levels of investment in education, infrastructure, and technology; export- oriented growth; and government intervention in the economy. The East Asian development model has been successful in achieving rapid economic growth. Between 1960 and 1990, the average annual growth rate of GDP in East Asia was 8.5%, compared to 3.5% for the world as a whole. This growth has lifted millions of people out of poverty and has made East Asia one of the most prosperous regions in the world (Chang, 2023).

4 Translated from Kinyarwanda (one of the official languages of Rwanda) as “coming together in common purpose to achieve an outcome”, Umuganda is when Rwandans from all walks of life come together to work for the good of their neighbourhoods and their nation as a whole. The last Saturday of every month, shops are closed, buses stop running, traffic disappears from the roads, and Rwandans set aside their personal business for the morning and contribute their efforts to public works projects around the country, which can include litter clean-up, tree planting, building houses for the vulnerable, and more (RDB, 2024).

5 The Gacaca courts were a system of transitional justice in Rwanda following the 1994 genocide. The term 'gacaca' can be translated as 'short grass' referring to the public space where neighbourhood male elders (abagabo) used to meet to solve local problems (Geraghty, 2020).

6 The land reform in Rwanda comprised a series of initiatives that aimed to tackle the emerging uncertainties about land ownership. Given the history of violent conflict, the Rwandan Constitution of 2003, the National Land Policy of 2004 and the Organic Land Law of 2005 all incorporated land ownership and gave it a formal legal basis. The Land Tenure Regularisation (LTR) programme was then established to register and administer land ownership in Rwanda (centre for public impact).

7 Imidugudu, meaning villages, are the smallest administrative divisions of Rwanda. Imidugudu are the result of a forced villagization program that was launched on 13 December 1996 by a decision of the Rwandan Cabinet which set out to concentrate the entire rural population in such villages. Rwanda today has more than 14 000 imidugudu, each of which houses about a hundred families (dbpedia).

8 VISION 2020 is a framework for Rwanda's development, presenting the key priorities and providing Rwandans with a guiding tool for the future. It supports a clear Rwandan identity, whilst showing ambition and imagination in overcoming poverty and division.

9 Girinka is an old cultural practice in Rwanda whereby a cow is given by one person to another either as a sign of respect and gratitude or as a marriage dowry.

10 https://rdb.rw/icca-ranks-rwanda-second-most-popular-destination-for-conferences-and-events-in-africa-up-one- place-from-2018/

11 https://org.rdb.rw/business-registration/Accessed 07 July 2024

12 Ibid.

13 Dictator is a leader who has complete power in a country and has not been elected by the people (Cambridge Dictionary).

Excerpt out of 113 pages  - scroll top

Buy now

Title: Tracking Rwandan Progress in Addressing Learning Crisis in Madagascar (2009–2023)

Master's Thesis , 2025 , 113 Pages , Grade: Mention très bien

Autor:in: Marius Heriniaina (Author)

African Studies
Look inside the ebook

Details

Title
Tracking Rwandan Progress in Addressing Learning Crisis in Madagascar (2009–2023)
Subtitle
Comparative study of Madagascar and Rwanda
Course
Civilisation
Grade
Mention très bien
Author
Marius Heriniaina (Author)
Publication Year
2025
Pages
113
Catalog Number
V1777585
ISBN (PDF)
9783389208601
ISBN (Book)
9783389208618
Language
English
Tags
Rwanda genocide developmental state economy democracy commonwealth
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Marius Heriniaina (Author), 2025, Tracking Rwandan Progress in Addressing Learning Crisis in Madagascar (2009–2023), Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1777585
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  113  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract