This study critically examines the induction experiences of Newly Qualified Teachers (NQTs) in Malta’s state school system, drawing on the reflections of second-year NQTs on their first year of teaching. It explores the challenges encountered, evaluates the effectiveness of current induction structures and investigates the forms of support needed to enhance professional confidence and retention. A convergent parallel mixed-methods design integrates survey data from 53 second-year NQTs (out of a cohort of 163) with qualitative data generated through semi-structured interviews with four mentors, four heads of school and the education officer responsible for induction. Grounded in established theory, the study conceptualises induction as both a structural and relational process. The findings foreground second-year NQTs’ reflections on their first year of teaching, highlighting how sustained mentoring and relational leadership shaped professional confidence, identity formation and retention intentions. The data reveal enduring system and school-level pressures, alongside relational challenges, particularly in classroom management, workload demands and professional isolation, while the perceived effectiveness of mentoring varied according to relational quality, time availability and school culture. The study highlights the importance of sustained, empathetic and context-responsive support in promoting NQTs’ well-being and professional belonging. It concludes that within the Maltese context, teacher retention can be strengthened by more deliberately aligning policy structures with relational leadership practices to support early-career teachers.
This dissertation was submitted for the Master in Applied Educational Leadership (MQF Level 7) at the Institute for Education, Malta. The author graduated with an overall Grade A (82.66%). Drawing on research involving newly qualified teachers, mentors and educational leaders, the study examines teacher induction, mentoring and retention within Malta's state education system. It offers evidence-based recommendations to strengthen professional support, enhance teacher development and inform educational policy and practice.
At a glance
- survey evaluating reflections of 53 second-year newly qualified teachers
- semi-structured interviews with four mentors, four heads of school, and an education officer
- full survey instrument for newly qualified teachers printed in appendix
- 186 sources in the bibliography
- 21 figures and 8 tables
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction
Background and Context of NQT Induction in Malta
Research Rationale
Researcher Positionality
Purpose and Scope
Aims of the Research and Expected Contributions
Overview of the Structure of the Dissertation
Chapter 2: Literature Review
Theoretical Frameworks and Early-Career Teacher Development
Challenges as Perceived by NQTs
Impact of Mentoring on Teacher Self-Perception and Career Decisions
The Role of Mentors in NQT Induction: Challenges and Opportunities
Enhancing Mentorship through Communities of Practice
Transition Theory and Mentorship: Shaping Novice Teachers' Journeys
Induction in Malta
Induction Practices in Malta
Bridging Theory and Practice in Maltese NQT Induction
Contextualising Support: Insights from Maltese Schools
Leadership and Support
Empowerment and Retention Strategies
Challenges in Educator Retention: Contemporary Issues
Induction Effectiveness: Comparative Insights
Sustaining Educator Stability through Long-Term Mentoring
Gaps in the Literature and Research
Mentorship Pairing and Relational Dynamics in NQT Induction
Gap in Mentorship Structures: School Leadership Roles in Malta
Addressing Key Gaps in NQT Induction in Malta
Conclusion of the Review of Literature
Chapter 3: Methodology
Research Paradigm
Research Design
Theoretical Frameworks: Application to Methodology
The Quantitative Strand
The Qualitative Strand
Elite Interview
Quantitative Data Analysis
Qualitative Data Analysis
Integration and Interpretation of Data
Sampling Strategies and Participant Background
The Significance of Focusing on Second-Year NQTs
Reliability, Validity and Generalisability
Survey Piloting
Interview Piloting
Qualitative Component: Credibility and Transferability
Ethical Considerations
Data Privacy and Confidentiality
Informed Consent and Voluntary Participation
Data Collection and Ethical Safeguards
Navigating Ethical Tensions in Insider Research
Data Retention and Disposal
Reflexivity: Researcher Positionality and Influence
Reflexive Practices
Commitment to Objectivity
Limitations of Methodology
Sample Scope and Representativeness
Exclusion of Resigned NQTs
Response Bias
Limitations of Research Tools
Conclusion
Chapter 4: Results and Analysis
Quantitative Findings
RQ1. What are the Challenges faced by Newly Qualified Teachers during their Initial Placements?
Integration into School Culture
Confidence Growth
RQ2. How effective are Current Induction Programmes in Supporting Newly Qualified Teachers?
RQ3. How can Newly Qualified Teachers be better Supported during their Induction Period?
Qualitative Findings
Policy-Level Reflections: Insights from the Education Officer (EO)
Mentors’ Perspectives on Supporting NQTs
HoSs’ Perspectives on Supporting NQTs
Leadership Perspectives on Induction
Workload and time constraints
Confidence as a Developmental and Vulnerable Outcome
Mentoring as a Core Mechanism
Systemic Gaps Beyond the First Year of Teaching
Practical and Logistical Challenges
Collegiality and Collaboration
Emotional Well-being and Resilience
Synthesis of Convergence and Divergence
Triangulation Matrix
Chapter 5: Discussion
RQ1. What are the Challenges faced by Newly Qualified Teachers during their Initial Placements?
RQ2. How Effective are Current Induction Programmes in Supporting Newly Qualified Teachers?
RQ3. How can Newly Qualified Teachers be Better Supported during their Induction Period?
Dominant Areas of Convergence and Divergence Across Data Sources
Linking Findings to Malta’s National Education Strategy (2024–2030)
Linking Findings to Theoretical Frameworks
Positioning Second-Year NQTs as Reflective Agents for Policy Insight
Implications for Strengthening Induction Structures
Researcher Reflexivity
Limitations of the Study
Chapter 6: Conclusion
Synthesis of Key Findings
Methodological Insight
Theoretical Contribution
Contribution to Knowledge
Recommendations for Practice
Recommendations for Policy
Social Implications
Recommendations for Future Research
Researcher Reflection
Final Reflections
Research Objectives & Focal Themes
This study investigates the induction and mentoring experiences of Newly Qualified Teachers (NQTs) in the Maltese state education system, addressing the core challenges encountered during early-career transitions, the perceived efficacy of current induction frameworks, and actionable strategies to foster professional confidence and retention.
- Evaluating early-career stressors, including heavy workload, classroom management, pupil behaviour, and professional isolation.
- Examining the operational effectiveness and relational dynamics of mentorship, appraisal procedures, and leadership support.
- Investigating systemic discontinuities in support, particularly the abrupt transition occurring between the first and second year of teaching.
- Aligning induction structures with national strategic goals outlined in Malta’s National Education Strategy 2024–2030.
- Proposing policy and school-level frameworks to transition induction from procedural compliance to an integrated culture of professional belonging.
Excerpt from the Book
Leadership and Support
In Malta, school leadership plays a significant role in shaping NQT induction. HoSs contribute to mentoring arrangements through the coordination of induction processes and oversight of support structures for early-career teachers (Kutsyuruba & Bezzina, 2024). HoSs are responsible for appointing a Deputy Head as Induction Coordinator, a role intended to ensure structured and consistent support for early-career teachers (Government-MUT Agreement, 2017). Beyond management, school leaders foster reflective environments aligned with national goals to strengthen collaboration between schools and the Ministry (MEYR, 2023b).
Gauci’s (2021) study revealed that SLT members often serve as relational anchors for NQTs, balancing mentorship with appraisal. Gauci also highlighted bureaucratic burdens and limited training, which constrain their ability to offer personalised support. Gauci’s study suggested that streamlining procedures could enable school leaders to engage more meaningfully with beginning teachers and reinforce professional learning.
Within the current framework, induction support in state schools typically takes two forms: mentoring which focused on developmental guidance, emotional support and professional growth and appraisal, which involves evaluation against performance criteria. While Church and independent schools often mirror these practices, they are not formally bound by the induction provisions outlined in national agreements (Eurydice, 2023). Clarifying this distinction is crucial, as blending roles can strain relationships and erode trust. Maltese literature reinforces this view, framing mentoring as a reflective practice distinct from formal assessment (Buhagiar & Attard Tonna, 2015). While mentoring is institutionalised as a developmental tool (Government-MUT Agreement, 2010), appraisal remains tied to accountability. Kutsyuruba and Bezzina (2024) argue that role delineation preserves the integrity of support and evaluation.
School leaders’ influence, however, extends beyond managing these dual roles. Langdon et al. (2019) and Bickmore and Bickmore (2010) suggest that induction should be embedded within school culture, not approached as a procedural task. This could mean cultivating a learning ethos that reinforces mentoring as a relational practice. Gauci (2021) recommends that SLT members foster reflective practice by maintaining regular dialogue with mentors and EOs, thereby strengthening teaching capacity and professional growth.
Chapter Overview
Chapter 1: Introduction: Introduces the background of teacher induction and attrition in Malta, establishing the research rationale, positionality, purpose, scope, and specific research questions.
Chapter 2: Literature Review: Synthesises international and Maltese literature on early-career development, theoretical frameworks, mentoring practices, school leadership, and identified research gaps.
Chapter 3: Methodology: Outlines the pragmatic research paradigm, convergent parallel mixed-methods design, sampling strategies across surveys and interviews, data analysis procedures, ethical safeguards, and methodological limitations.
Chapter 4: Results and Analysis: Details the empirical quantitative findings from surveyed second-year teachers alongside qualitative insights from mentors, school heads, and the education officer, culminating in an integrated triangulation matrix.
Chapter 5: Discussion: Interprets empirical results through theoretical lenses and Malta’s National Education Strategy (2024–2030), discussing core areas of convergence and divergence across data sources.
Chapter 6: Conclusion: Synthesises key conclusions, detailing methodological, theoretical, and practical contributions, while offering policy recommendations and directions for future research.
Keywords
teacher induction, newly qualified teachers, mentoring, educator retention, educational leadership, Malta state schools, mixed-methods research, professional development, classroom management, relational leadership, Communities of Practice, Transition Theory
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary focus of this dissertation?
The dissertation examines the lived induction experiences of Newly Qualified Teachers (NQTs) within the Maltese state school system, focusing on early-career challenges, support mechanisms, and teacher retention.
What core themes are explored throughout the study?
Central themes include classroom and behaviour management pressures, workload strain, the quality and frequency of mentoring, the tension between appraisal and developmental support, and the need for sustained multi-year assistance.
What are the primary aims and research questions of the research?
The research investigates the specific challenges faced by NQTs during their initial placements, evaluates how effectively existing induction programmes support them, and identifies actionable strategies to better support early-career educators.
Which scientific methodology does the author adopt?
The study employs a pragmatic convergent parallel mixed-methods design, combining quantitative survey data from 53 second-year NQTs with qualitative semi-structured interviews from four mentors, four school heads, and an elite interview with the Education Officer responsible for induction.
What are the main findings presented in the results section?
The findings indicate that while approximately 75% of NQTs rate induction positively and 79% value mentoring, early-career educators face intense workload and behaviour management hurdles, coupled with an abrupt withdrawal of formal support in their second year.
What keywords characterize this scholarly work?
Key terms include teacher induction, newly qualified teachers, mentoring, teacher retention, educational leadership, professional development, and mixed-methods research.
Why did the study specifically examine second-year teachers rather than first-year novices?
Second-year teachers occupy a unique liminal space where they have completed the initial formal induction phase and can retrospectively evaluate the support received, while navigating increased professional autonomy and diminished formal scaffolding.
What critical gap was identified regarding the second year of teaching in Malta?
The research uncovered a significant systemic discontinuity, termed a post-induction gap, where formal mentoring ceases abruptly after Year 1 despite increased workload, accountability, and expectations in Year 2.
- Citation du texte
- Edward Marmara (Auteur), 2026, Empowering and Retaining Educators, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/1788151