Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Region: USA

Is the Supreme Court too political and too powerful?

Title: Is the Supreme Court too political and too powerful?

Term Paper (Advanced seminar) , 2012 , 7 Pages , Grade: 84%

Autor:in: Roy Whymark (Author)

Politics - Region: USA
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

The US Supreme Court bears the incredible responsibility for deciding the constitutional
validity of cases by judging the merits of each against the Constitution. Given the context in
which the Constitution was written and its often ambiguous language, the task facing the nine
Justices is not simple and the Court’s activities not without controversy. The influence of the
Court has generated swathes of literature concerning how the Constitution is applied and how
effective those applications have been in shaping public policy.
There can be little doubt that the Supreme Court is both powerful and political and has had a
major impact on American society. Indeed, it was the Court that ruled racial segregation in
schools to be unconstitutional (Brown v. Board of Education 1954); guaranteed the rights to
counsel and due process (Gideon v. Wainwright 1963); established the constitutional right of
abortion (Roe v. Wade 1973); and famously, or perhaps infamously, halted the Florida recount,
effectively awarding the presidency to George W. Bush (Bush v. Gore 2000).
This essay takes the notion that the Court is both political and powerful as given but explores
whether it is too political and too powerful, to the degree that its decisions have a detrimental
impact on the functioning of US democracy.
In considering this issue, one needs to consider outcomes (how the Court has actually shaped
public policy). This essay will focus on three policy areas where the Court has made
landmark decisions (abortion, civil rights, and gun control) and explains that while the Court
is, by its nature, highly political and also powerful, it does not operate in a vacuum and its
influence on society in constrained by the separation of powers, the federal nature of politics,
and public opinion.
Supreme Court functions
Before turning to the Supreme Court’s influence on public policy, it is worth understanding
what the Court is intended for. Article III of the Constitution states that ‘the judicial power of
the United States shall be vested in one supreme court’. This role manifests itself in two
judicial review functions: (i) statutory interpretation; and (ii) constitutional interpretation of
legislation. [...]

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Focuses on three landmark policy areas: abortion, civil rights, and gun control
  • Evaluates judicial decision-making using Posner's legalist and attitudinal models
  • 20 sources in the bibliography

Table of Contents

1. IS THE SUPREME COURT TOO POLITICAL AND TOO POWERFUL?

1.1 Supreme Court functions

1.1.1 Statutory interpretation

1.1.2 Constitutional interpretation

2. Abortion

3. Civil rights

4. Gun rights

5. Conclusion

Objectives & Key Themes

This essay explores whether the Supreme Court of the United States has become excessively political and overly powerful to the detriment of American democracy. By evaluating constitutional theory alongside real-world public policy outcomes, the work analyzes how the Court interacts with elected branches and societal constraints.

  • The core functions of judicial review: statutory interpretation versus constitutional interpretation
  • The institutional debate over judicial independence, lifetime tenure, and democratic legitimacy
  • Constitutional analysis of reproductive rights through landmark abortion jurisprudence
  • The enforcement limitations of the Court demonstrated in civil rights school desegregation
  • Evolving Second Amendment interpretations and the impact of gun rights rulings
  • Democratic checks, federalism, and the political constraints imposed by public opinion

Excerpt from the Book

Constitutional interpretation

It is the constitutional interpretation function that causes the most controversy. In this role, the Court is able to deem legislation unconstitutional, meaning the only recourse for those seeking an alternative outcome is to pursue a constitutional amendment.

I would disagree with the oft-quoted Mark Twain that ‘the Judges have the Constitution for their guidance; they have no right to any politics’ (Twain, 1868) but instead side with Hodder-Williams’s view that the Court has to be political and cannot simply act as ‘a formal agency for legitimation’ for the elected branches (Hodder-Williams, 1992).

Since the Court is required to rule on cases that are, by their very nature political, it is impossible to avoid politics. Interpreting a two centuries-old document that is, at times, silent or ambiguous on contemporary issues is unavoidably political, regardless of whether Justices carry out their duties as living constitutionalists, strict constructionists, originalists, or textualists.

An objection one could raise to the politics of the Court is its lack of democracy. Justices are appointed (not elected) and serve for as long as they wish. This is in sharp contrast to the seemingly never-ending electoral cycle faced by the occupants of Capitol Hill and the White House. One could argue that the Court should be more subservient to the elected branches and therefore, at least indirectly, to the voting citizenry.

However, this would create two problems. Firstly, given the separation of powers, and federalism, there is no single government position to adopt. Secondly, even if there was, the Court would merely be playing the part of a rubber-stamping body, thereby losing all de facto influence and effectively becoming irrelevant, if not redundant.

Moreover, the Founding Fathers intended for the Court to be powerful in order to protect the Constitution and act as a guardian against the other branches. As such, its political independence is vital. As Hamilton asserted in Federalist paper no. 78 (1788), ‘the complete independence of the courts of justice is peculiarly essential in a limited Constitution…’ It is the duty of the Court ‘to declare all acts contrary to the manifest tenor of the Constitution void’.

Overview of Chapters

IS THE SUPREME COURT TOO POLITICAL AND TOO POWERFUL?: Introduces the role of the US Supreme Court under Article III of the Constitution, distinguishing statutory interpretation from constitutional interpretation and showing how legislative bodies retain primary power in statutory matters.

Abortion: Analyzes landmark reproductive rights decisions from Roe v. Wade to Planned Parenthood v. Casey, highlighting how judicial philosophies, state legislation, and federal restrictions continuously reshape access.

Civil rights: Examines the evolution from Plessy v. Ferguson to Brown v. Board of Education, illustrating the fundamental inability of the Court to enforce its decisions without active federal executive and legislative intervention.

Gun rights: Details Second Amendment jurisprudence surrounding District of Columbia v. Heller, discussing ideological decision-making alongside ongoing legislative compromises regarding firearm regulations.

Conclusion: Synthesizes findings across policy sectors to conclude that while the Court is inherently political and powerful, its authority is effectively constrained by democratic checks, federalism, and public opinion.

Keywords

Supreme Court, Judicial Review, Constitutional Interpretation, Statutory Interpretation, Separation of Powers, Roe v. Wade, Brown v. Board of Education, District of Columbia v. Heller, Second Amendment, Civil Rights, Public Policy, Attitudinal Model

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the central focus of this essay?

The essay evaluates whether the US Supreme Court has grown excessively powerful and political to the point of harming American democracy, examining the reality of its influence on public policy outcomes.

What are the key policy areas examined?

The investigation centers on three controversial and landmark policy areas: abortion rights, civil rights desegregation, and Second Amendment gun control.

What is the primary objective of the author?

The primary objective is to demonstrate that although the Supreme Court is inherently powerful and political, its actual capacity to dictate public policy is strictly checked and constrained by the democratic system.

What analytical approach or methodology is applied?

The author employs a qualitative legal and political case-study approach, applying theoretical models such as Posner's attitudinal and legalist spectrum to analyze landmark judicial decisions.

What is discussed in the main body regarding judicial power?

The body explains that the Court's impact depends heavily on external factors; in statutory review the elected branches can override rulings, and in constitutional rulings societal resistance and enforcement weaknesses limit judicial overreach.

Which keywords best encapsulate the work?

Key terms include Supreme Court, Judicial Review, Constitutional Law, Separation of Powers, Civil Rights, Abortion Rights, Gun Control, and Democratic Accountability.

How does the case of Brown v. Board of Education illustrate the limits of the Court?

Brown demonstrates the Court's enforcement weakness; despite declaring segregation unconstitutional in 1954, real integration only advanced after Congress and the President intervened with the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

Why does the author argue that the Supreme Court cannot avoid politics?

The author argues that interpreting ambiguous constitutional clauses on modern societal disputes is inherently political, but this independence was deliberately designed by the Founders to safeguard the Constitution against legislative overreach.

Excerpt out of 7 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Is the Supreme Court too political and too powerful?
College
Birkbeck, University of London  (University of London)
Course
American Politics
Grade
84%
Author
Roy Whymark (Author)
Publication Year
2012
Pages
7
Catalog Number
V207475
ISBN (eBook)
9783656347576
Language
English
Tags
supreme court
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Roy Whymark (Author), 2012, Is the Supreme Court too political and too powerful?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/207475
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  7  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract