Knowledge, which is true belief based on strong, justifiable evidence, being generated is knowledge created or acquired; something is being learned. There are different ways of learning, which generate knowledge differently. Two of these are critical and creative thinking, which often work together when learning. Critical thinking focuses on questioning, evaluating and analyzing assumptions, suggesting that critical thinking holds an element of creative thinking, which involves coming up with a new idea by combining ideas that haven’t been combined before, because originality and flexibility are required to successfully question, analyze and evaluate. These procedures rely heavily on all the Ways of Knowing (WOKs). Reason is needed to question assumptions by inducing a larger truth from the assumptions and testing the truth’s validity. Language is necessary to pick up on bias in text, which affects the evaluation of assumptions. Sense perception and emotion are often needed to follow a ‘gut instinct’ about the validity of assumptions. Overall, critical and creative thinking need to interact to enable the most effective way of learning. This can be shown with examples from the natural sciences and the language arts as Areas of Knowledge. More specifically, examples from my IB physics class and my IB A1 German class can be analyzed. Nevertheless, my arguments also apply in biology, chemistry and other A1 literature courses.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Discusses Dürrenmatt’s Die Physiker alongside Brecht’s Leben des Galilei
- Uses Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity to examine creativity in physics
Contents
1. Knowledge and ways of thinking
2. Critical and creative thinking in physics
3. Cultural perspectives on physics
4. Authors and students of literature
5. Generating and discovering knowledge
Objectives and Themes
This essay evaluates the claim that knowledge is generated through the interaction of critical and creative thinking. Drawing on examples from physics and literature, it asks how these forms of thinking contribute to knowledge and how their interaction varies across disciplines and communities of knowers.
- Critical and creative thinking as ways of learning
- Reason, language, sense perception and emotion
- Experimentation and creativity in physics
- Individual and public knowledge
- Literary creation, interpretation and bias
- The distinction between generating and discovering knowledge
Excerpt from the Book
TOK Essay
Although physics seems biased towards critical thinking, many professional physicists show that creativity also plays a vital role. This can be understood by examining the knowledge issue: To what extent can art be considered a part of science? As Albert Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity, published in 19162, shows, many physicists on the highest level of physical research must be able to think outside the box of what seems evident. Einstein’s theory stated that light can be bent by very massive objects3. To come up with this thesis, Einstein used reason and critical thinking to determine what and how he wanted to explain, but also needed creativity to come up with this abstract idea. His emotions and his sense perception convinced him that his theory was correct because, as he stated, his theory “was too beautiful ever to be refuted”4. Using language as a WOK, the word ‘too’ shows that Einstein didn’t simply write a theory that made sense, he wrote a theory that was aesthetically pleasing, and thus incorporated art into his scientific discovery. Hence, he went further than just using critical thinking to explain a phenomenon and instead used a combination of critical and creative thinking.
The degree of interaction between critical and creative thinking in physics varies between different communities of knowers, which connects to the knowledge issue: How is knowledge in physics generated differently for a community of knowers (public knowledge) than for an individual knower (individual knowledge)? In the ‘real world’ of physics, professionals often need creativity to find an original way of proving physical laws and generate knowledge not just for themselves, but for the masses. Subsequently, critical thinking is needed to work out the proof logically. This suggests a strong balance of critical and creative thinking. As a student, however, I use a slightly higher degree of critical thinking to prove laws because I am not at the level of physics where I can invent my own proofs. I acquire individual knowledge by relying on professionals’ work. It can thus be said that the statement: Knowledge is generated through the interaction of critical and creative thinking is most valid in the professional world of physics, and that often a higher degree of interaction is needed to generate public knowledge than to generate individual knowledge.
Section Summaries
Knowledge and ways of thinking: The essay defines critical and creative thinking and introduces reason, language, sense perception and emotion as ways of knowing.
Critical and creative thinking in physics: A classroom experiment and Einstein’s theory of relativity provide examples for examining how knowledge is acquired and developed in physics.
Cultural perspectives on physics: The discussion considers Feng Shui when exploring how cultural perspectives can affect the relationship between creative and critical thinking.
Authors and students of literature: Examples from plays by Dürrenmatt, Brecht and Miller illustrate questions about authors’ intentions, interpretation and bias.
Generating and discovering knowledge: The final discussion questions whether knowledge is created or instead discovered and understood.
Keywords
critical thinking, creative thinking, knowledge generation, theory of knowledge, physics, literature, ways of knowing, reason, language, sense perception, emotion, individual knowledge, public knowledge
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the essay about?
It examines the relationship between critical and creative thinking in the generation and acquisition of knowledge.
What are its central themes?
The essay explores ways of knowing, experimentation, creativity, literary interpretation and the distinction between individual and public knowledge.
What question does the essay address?
It evaluates the claim that knowledge is generated through the interaction of critical and creative thinking in two areas of knowledge.
What method does the author use?
The author develops an argumentative comparison using classroom experiences and examples from physics and literature.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers physics experiments, scientific creativity, cultural perspectives and the roles of authors and students in literature.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include critical thinking, creative thinking, knowledge generation, physics, literature and ways of knowing.
How is Einstein’s theory of relativity used?
It serves as an example in a discussion of creativity and critical thinking in professional physics.
Which literary works are discussed?
The essay refers to Friedrich Dürrenmatt’s Die Physiker, Bertolt Brecht’s Leben des Galilei and Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman.
How does the essay distinguish individual and public knowledge?
It considers the knowledge acquired by an individual student alongside knowledge developed for a wider community by professional physicists.
- Citation du texte
- Martha Geiger (Auteur), 2012, Theory of Knowledge Essay, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/208041