Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publicación mundial de textos académicos
Go to shop › Didáctica de la asignatura Inglés - Literatura, trabajos

The Myth of The Strong Irish Immigrant Servant Woman

An Analysis of Novels by Sadlier, McElgun and Atwood

Título: The Myth of The Strong Irish Immigrant Servant Woman

Tesis de Máster , 2006 , 100 Páginas , Calificación: 80

Autor:in: Rosamaria Giammanco (Autor)

Didáctica de la asignatura Inglés - Literatura, trabajos
Extracto de texto & Detalles   Leer eBook
Resumen Extracto de texto Detalles

In this MA thesis I aim to look especially at one specific group of Irish immigrants from the many that took the crossing, namely nineteenth-century young Irish women who found work as servants in the New World. These girls and women encountered many hardships. As explained in the previous section, they were dislocated, and thus vulnerable to abuse and loneliness.
Of course, there are many ways in which this segment of Irish immigrants can be analyzed. It can be done by looking at historic documents, photographs or the occasional letters which were written. Yet, the way in which I shall analyze this group is through the use of three novels that deal with the Irish immigrant servant girl as a protagonist. The novels studied will be two novels from the latter half of the nineteenth century and one contemporary novel, which will give very diverse perspectives. The modern novel is looking back on an era and thus manages to put the immigration of the Famine and post Famine generation into a modern perspective while the novels written in the latter half of the nineteenth century present the view of the writers and people back then. The novels that will be used for this study are Mary Anne Madden Sadlier’s novel Bessy Conway; or, the Irish girl in America (1862), John McElgun’s Annie Reilly: The Fortunes of an Irish Girl in New York (1873) and Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace (1996).

Extracto


At a glance

  • Compares Bessy Conway, Annie Reilly and Alias Grace
  • Examines heroines and their foils through religion, gender, class and ethnicity
  • Includes historical Puck imagery and nineteenth-century newspaper engravings
  • 43 sources in the bibliography

Contents

2. Introduction: “Far at sea”

3. The “Devine Providence”: The Irish Servant Girl and Religion

4. “Morning makes you look prettier”: The Irish Servant Girl and Gender

5. Reinforcing Stereotypes: The Irish Servant Girl, Class and Ethnicity

6. Conclusion: “Success, slow but sure”

Aims and Themes

This thesis examines how nineteenth-century Irish immigrant servant women are represented in Mary Anne Madden Sadlier’s Bessy Conway, John McElgun’s Annie Reilly and Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace. It asks how religion, gender, class and ethnicity shape the protagonists’ experiences and character, and how two nineteenth-century novels compare with a contemporary historical novel.

  • Irish emigration and domestic service in North America
  • Catholic and Protestant identities
  • Gender, sexuality and women’s independence
  • Class, ethnicity and social mobility
  • Literary representations of Irish immigrant communities
  • Famine fiction, historical narrative and storytelling

Excerpt from the Book

The Irish, religion and America

Catholicism has been an important part of Irish history and culture ever since Saint Patrick “saved the country” and converted the population in the fifth century A.D. Yet, when Ireland was under British rule the predominantly Catholic Irish were mocked by their colonizers for their religion. This suppression of Catholic religion by the enemy perhaps influenced the Irish to be even more faithful to the Catholic church and church doctrine. In that view it could be argued that it is no wonder that the Irish stuck so much to their faith. It was a convenient way to create a united group opposing the oppressor. An example of the unification of the Catholic Irish is the erection of the Catholic Association by Daniel O’Connell of Derrynane. By 1829 this organization managed to pressure “the English into restoring most of the freedoms [Catholics] lost under the Penal Laws, including the right to sit in Parliament.” Therefore, the Catholics were indeed organizing against “the other”, in this case the Anglo-Irish and British rulers.

Two of the core novels read for this study belong to Famine literature. This literature was especially aimed at the Catholic Irish emigrants that had to leave the south of Ireland that was tormented by the famine. In fact, much of the Famine literature also promoted Irish independence, and was often “nationalist-political.” The theme of Catholic religion was an important part of this “nationalist-political” view.

However, for this study it is especially interesting to see how Irish-American (female) immigrants dealt with their religion while being abroad. The question is whether the Irish immigrants retained their faith and culture or if they sold out to the new predominantly Protestant culture which constantly surrounded them. The three core novels deal with this issue of religion in different ways. As said, the older novels seem to have, in the introduction, didactic qualities and try to give moralizing accounts of good and bad, whereas Atwood analyses the matter from a much more modern perspective.

On the other hand, the way in which young Irish immigrant women in nineteenth-century North America related to religion should perhaps be analyzed to acquire a more nuanced and coherent view. The only trouble in doing this is that it is very difficult to read or obtain any first hand sources from North American Irish servant girls themselves on religion. Unfortunately, letters, photos, diaries and other such sources by immigrant women themselves are scarce. In other words, an image has to be build up from fictional secondary literature.

Chapter Summaries

2. Introduction: “Far at sea”: The introduction outlines Irish emigration, women’s employment and the historical context of domestic service. It introduces the three novels and the comparative approach.

3. The “Devine Providence”: The Irish Servant Girl and Religion: This chapter examines religious identity, faith and moral instruction in the three novels, including the different narrative perspectives used in Alias Grace.

4. “Morning makes you look prettier”: The Irish Servant Girl and Gender: The discussion considers gender roles, sexuality, dependence and independence, alongside the heroines’ relationships with their families and communities.

5. Reinforcing Stereotypes: The Irish Servant Girl, Class and Ethnicity: This chapter explores social status, Irish identity, stereotypes and the possibilities of upward mobility, with attention to postcolonial criticism.

6. Conclusion: “Success, slow but sure”: The conclusion brings together the study’s discussion of migration, personal growth and social mobility, and compares the narrative approaches of the earlier novels and Alias Grace.

Keywords

Irish immigration, domestic service, Irish-American fiction, famine literature, historical fiction, religion, gender, class, ethnicity, social mobility, Catholicism, postcolonial criticism, Bessy Conway, Annie Reilly, Alias Grace

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this thesis about?

It studies literary representations of nineteenth-century Irish immigrant women working as domestic servants in North America.

What are its central themes?

Its principal themes are religion, gender, class and ethnicity, considered alongside migration, community and social mobility.

What question guides the study?

The thesis asks how these social and cultural factors influence the portrayal of the heroines and how representations differ across the selected novels.

What research method does the author use?

The author conducts a comparative literary analysis of three novels, examining protagonists, supporting characters and narrative techniques in relation to historical and critical scholarship.

What does the main analysis cover?

It examines the novels in three thematic chapters devoted to religion, gender, and class and ethnicity.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include Irish immigration, domestic service, famine literature, historical fiction, religion, gender, class, ethnicity and social mobility.

Which novels are compared?

The study compares Mary Anne Madden Sadlier’s Bessy Conway, John McElgun’s Annie Reilly and Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace.

How does the study approach storytelling in Alias Grace?

It considers the novel’s use of multiple perspectives and different kinds of text, including their implications for interpreting Grace’s story.

What role does the Irish immigrant community play in the analysis?

The thesis examines how community connections provide support and shape the heroines’ experiences of work, religion and social belonging.

Final del extracto de 100 páginas  - subir

Detalles

Título
The Myth of The Strong Irish Immigrant Servant Woman
Subtítulo
An Analysis of Novels by Sadlier, McElgun and Atwood
Universidad
Leiden University  (Leiden University)
Curso
English language and culture
Calificación
80
Autor
Rosamaria Giammanco (Autor)
Año de publicación
2006
Páginas
100
No. de catálogo
V274106
ISBN (Ebook)
9783656660354
ISBN (Libro)
9783656660323
Idioma
Inglés
Etiqueta
myth strong irish immigrant servant woman analysis novels sadlier mcelgun atwood
Seguridad del producto
GRIN Publishing Ltd.
Citar trabajo
Rosamaria Giammanco (Autor), 2006, The Myth of The Strong Irish Immigrant Servant Woman, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/274106
Leer eBook
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
Extracto de  100  Páginas
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Envío
  • Contacto
  • Privacidad
  • Aviso legal
  • Imprint
  • Cancelar contrato