Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › Politics - Region: USA

The United States constitution. Should it be altered to make it easier to amend?

Title: The United States constitution. Should it be altered to make it easier to amend?

Seminar Paper , 2012 , 9 Pages , Grade: 1,7

Autor:in: Patrick Spieß (Author)

Politics - Region: USA
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Although it is difficult to prove, the constitution of the United States of America is considered to be one of the most difficult constitution's to amend, as the political scientist Donald Lutz point out (Lutz 1994). Therefore the question arise whether there is a need to alter the amendment procedure, which is enshrined in Article V.
First I will give general ideas of Article V and outline the difficulties that making amendments difficult. Then I will look at arguments against making amendments easier. Following this, I will argue in favour of making amendments easier. My main argumentation will be based on the assumption that not the supermajority rule is the
problem, but the inner logic of Article V itself. Finally I will examine reform proposals, which could solve the problem.

Excerpt


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Examines Michael Rappaport’s proposal for state-drafted constitutional amendments
  • Discusses United States versus Lopez in relation to federal power

Contents

1. Article V and the Amendment Procedure

2. Arguments Against Easier Amendments

3. Arguments for Reform and the Convention Method

4. Proposals for Reform

5. Conclusion

Objectives and Topics

This essay examines whether the United States Constitution should be altered to make amendments easier. It asks whether the principal obstacle lies in supermajority requirements or in the operation of Article V, particularly its convention method, and considers proposals for reform.

  • Article V and constitutional amendment requirements
  • Arguments for retaining a demanding amendment process
  • Judicial interpretation and constitutional change
  • Uncertainty surrounding national conventions
  • State-initiated proposals and alternative voting arrangements

Excerpt from the Book

Should the United States constitution be altered to make it easier to amend?

Drafting the constitution, the framers had to solve the balancing act how to deal with constitutional amendments. On the one hand, if "the constitution makes change too easy, there is a risk that the constitution will not structure politics, but will be hostage to it. But making change too difficult may cause political instability" (Griffin 1995). Finally, the framers decided to set high hurdles for constitutional changes, which becomes obvious through the fact that the constitution has been altered only twenty-seven times over two centuries. The main barrier to amend the constitution is enshrined in Article V of the constitution, which says:

"The Congress, whenever two thirds of both Houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose Amendments to this Constitution, or, on the Application of the Legislatures of two thirds of the several States, shall call a Convention for proposing Amendments, which, in either Case, shall be valid to all Intents and Purposes, as Part of this Constitution, when ratified by the Legislatures of three fourths of the several States or by Conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other Mode of Ratification may be proposed by the Congress; Provided that no Amendment which may be made prior to the Year One thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any Manner affect the first and fourth Clauses in the Ninth Section of the first Article; and that no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate." - Article V

Thus, constitutional amendments require a supermajority in the Congress as well as in the States. Since all changes to the constitution have been initiated by the congress and the convention method has never been used, a discussion about the amendment process arose.

To begin with, Kathleen Sullivan argues, that politicization of the constitution is a bad idea. According to Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, “a constitution is not meant to embody a particular economic [and political] theory [but] made for people of fundamentally differing views” (Sullivan 1997: 64). The constitution provides a framework in which political parties and interest groups can fill in the framework according to their political views. Otherwise the constitution would become a playing field of political groups and the constitutional framework would run the risk to be changed after every change of government. Thus, amendments would allow one group with specific social or economic policy to take advantage of another.

Section Summaries

Article V and the Amendment Procedure: The essay introduces the tension between constitutional stability and adaptability and outlines the amendment procedures set out in Article V.

Arguments Against Easier Amendments: The discussion considers concerns about politicization, short-term policy goals and the role of the Supreme Court in adapting constitutional principles.

Arguments for Reform and the Convention Method: The essay considers judicial reinterpretation and examines uncertainty over whether a national convention could be limited to a particular purpose.

Proposals for Reform: The author discusses state-drafted amendments, alternative state voting weights and possible arrangements for ratification.

Conclusion: The essay argues that defects in the amendment process, rather than supermajority requirements alone, justify reform.

Keywords

United States Constitution, Article V, constitutional amendments, supermajority, national convention, state legislatures, Congress, Supreme Court, judicial interpretation, federalism, state drafting, electoral votes, ballot measures

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the essay about?

It examines whether the United States Constitution should be changed to make constitutional amendments easier.

What are its central topics?

The essay addresses Article V, arguments for and against easier amendments, the national convention method and proposals for reform.

What is the main research question?

The central question is whether the Constitution should be altered to make it easier to amend, with particular attention to how Article V operates.

What method does the author use?

The author develops a constitutional and argumentative analysis using Article V and published scholarship to assess competing positions and reform proposals.

What does the main discussion cover?

It considers objections to easier amendments, arguments for reform, uncertainty over the scope of a national convention and alternatives for proposing and ratifying amendments.

Which keywords characterize the essay?

Key terms include Article V, constitutional amendments, supermajority, national convention, federalism and state drafting.

Why does the essay discuss the scope of a national convention?

It explores disagreement over whether a convention can be restricted to a particular purpose or may propose amendments beyond the scope of its original call.

What is the state-drafting proposal?

As discussed in the essay, Michael Rappaport’s proposal would allow state legislatures to draft and formally propose amendments without a national convention or congressional confirmation.

How are state voting weights addressed?

The essay considers a proposal to use electoral votes for one of the amendment votes as a compromise between population-based representation and equal state representation.

Excerpt out of 9 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
The United States constitution. Should it be altered to make it easier to amend?
College
University of Leeds
Course
United States Politics
Grade
1,7
Author
Patrick Spieß (Author)
Publication Year
2012
Pages
9
Catalog Number
V274318
ISBN (eBook)
9783656668510
ISBN (Book)
9783656668480
Language
English
Tags
united states should
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Patrick Spieß (Author), 2012, The United States constitution. Should it be altered to make it easier to amend?, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/274318
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  9  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract