Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publish your texts - enjoy our full service for authors
Go to shop › English Language and Literature Studies - Literature

Character adaptation in Val McDermid’s retelling of Jane Austen’s "Northanger Abbey"

Title: Character adaptation in Val McDermid’s retelling of Jane Austen’s "Northanger Abbey"

Term Paper (Advanced seminar) , 2014 , 22 Pages

Autor:in: B.A. Elisa Valerie Thieme (Author)

English Language and Literature Studies - Literature
Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Ever since their publication between the years of 1811 and 1817, Jane Austen’s novels, namely Northanger Abbey, Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice, Emma, Mansfield Park and Persuasion, have never gone out of print. Her works are “perennial favourites” (Carson xi) and, furthermore, there seems to be a huge demand for “Austen novelties”. It does not come as a surprise, therefore, that there are hundreds and hundreds of Austen adaptations and spin-offs. All six novels have been repeatedly turned into movies and the amount of literary adaptations appears to be almost uncountable. Since most “educated people . . . have at least heard of Jane Austen [and her] novels are in the public domain” (Parrill 176), adapting them seems to be particularly attractive in regard to the low economic risk and reduced investment costs (no acquisition of legal licences and little marketing costs). Austen has become a “cultural commodity[,] almost a brand name” (Wiltshire 7) and there will probably always be new publications as long as there is such a keen and vast market. The recent “Austen Project”, published by Harper Collins, sees six bestselling authors adapting Jane Austen’s novels and transposing them into the twenty-first century. Economically, it profits not only from Austen’s fan base but also from the faithful readers of popular writers such as Val McDermid, who adapted Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey. This retelling is the latest publication of the Austen Project and seems particularly interesting since Northanger Abbey is chiefly concerned with the mocking of Gothic fiction and the vindication of reading. It deals with bestsellers from the early nineteenth century and thus appears to be firmly rooted in its time. Due to these intriguing particularities, the paper at hand is based on Val McDermid’s modern retelling of Northanger Abbey.
McDermid follows the plot structure very closely and the reinterpretation of the source text chiefly lies in the temporal, linguistic and cultural update. The plot is set in an envi-ronment shifted by two hundred years, Bath has been swapped for the now more fashiona-ble Edinburgh Festival Fringe and almost all characters are expertly tweeting, texting, and posting “selfies” on Facebook. Whereas Austen set out to write an amusing burlesque and a vindication of novel reading, McDermid’s adaptation aims at pleasing the Austen-familiar readers and at humouring them by applying a “modern twist”.

Excerpt


Auf einen Blick

  • Vergleich von sechs Hauptfiguren in Austens Roman und McDermids Adaption
  • Vergleich der Gothic-Lektüre mit der Twilight-Reihe als modernem Gegenstück
  • Untersucht die Verlegung der Handlung zum Edinburgh Festival Fringe
  • 34 Quellen im Literaturverzeichnis

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

2. A Brief Note on Reading Women in the Early Nineteenth Century and Exchanging Gothic Fiction with Twilight

3. Adaptation of Character

3.1 Leading Ladies: Catherine “Cat” Morland, Isabella “Bella” Thorpe and Eleanor “Ellie” Tilney

3.2 The Gents: Henry Tilney (Henry), John “Johnny” Thorpe and General “the General” Tilney

4. Media Use

5. Conclusion

Zielsetzung und Themen

Die Arbeit untersucht, wie Val McDermid Jane Austens Roman „Northanger Abbey“ für das 21. Jahrhundert adaptiert. Im Mittelpunkt steht die Frage, wie sich die zeitliche und kulturelle Verlagerung insbesondere auf sechs Figuren und ihre Beziehungen auswirkt.

  • Romanlektüre von Frauen im frühen 19. Jahrhundert
  • Gothic Fiction und die „Twilight“-Reihe
  • Vergleich der weiblichen und männlichen Hauptfiguren
  • Bildung, Geschlechterrollen und zwischenmenschliche Beziehungen
  • Neue Medien und Kommunikation in der Adaption
  • Handlungsort und zeitgenössischer kultureller Kontext

Auszug aus dem Buch

3. Adaptation of Character

Catherine Morland is “set up from the outset as an anti‐heroine. She has none of the characteristics of novel‐heroines; [i.e.] she is not an orphan [and] not beautiful but ‘very plain’” (Waldron 26). Her character seems to be modelled on the formula found in the burlesque novels. Typical burlesque heroines are young and naïve but commonly possess sound, healthy affections and a good deal of common sense. Their errors are not likely to be long lasting, for their own abilities, with a little experience, are bound to correct them (cf. Kirkham 88). In accordance, Catherine is “without conceit or affection of any kind – her manners just removed from the awkwardness and shyness of a girl; her person pleasing” (Austen 19) and she displays “an unerring sensitivity to certain basic values, and even though she is so lacking in an appreciation of the facetious, she proves her right to respond as she does by the depth of her own feelings” (Hardy 8). In this regard, the adaptation of the character seems to be very true to the source text and Cat’s character is described similarly to Catherine’s: whereas Catherine is “affectionate[,] cheerful and open” (Austen 19), Cat is repeatedly described as “’lovely [and without] cynicism’” (McDermid 174), her family is “deeply average and desperately dull” (McDermid 2) but also loving and kind (cf. McDermid 325). The source text characterises Catherine’s family as “plain matter‐of‐fact people, who seldom [aim] at wit of any kind” (Austen 64). Furthermore, Catherine has grown up “’in a small retired village in the country [where she] can only go and call on [the rather dull] Mrs. Allen’” (Austen 76) which Henry Tilney very rightly considers to be “’a picture of intellectual poverty’” (Austen 76). Accordingly, Catherine strikes the reader as rather naïve and ill‐informed and displays an almost comic degree of social unsophistication (cf. Mooneyham 3). This rural background is maintained in the adaptation, which sees Cat stemming from a tiny village with the rather provincial sounding name Piddle Valley (a replacement of the more neutral “Fullerton”). In addition to that, Cat’s sole social contact remain to be the Allens, who have been converted into “the culture vultures of Piddle Valley” (McDermid 6) and hence rendered slightly more sophisticated.

Zusammenfassung der Kapitel

1. Introduction: Die Einleitung ordnet McDermids Roman in den Markt der Austen-Adaptionen ein und erläutert den Schwerpunkt auf der Übertragung der Figuren.

2. A Brief Note on Reading Women in the Early Nineteenth Century and Exchanging Gothic Fiction with Twilight: Das Kapitel behandelt zeitgenössische Vorbehalte gegenüber der Romanlektüre von Frauen und vergleicht die Rolle der Gothic Fiction mit jener der „Twilight“-Reihe.

3. Adaptation of Character: Das Hauptkapitel vergleicht sechs Figuren der Vorlage mit ihren Gegenstücken in der Adaption. Es untersucht unter anderem Bildung, Sprache, Beziehungen und gesellschaftliche Erwartungen.

4. Media Use: Dieses Kapitel betrachtet den Übergang von Briefen zu digitalen Kommunikationsmitteln und die Schwierigkeiten, die daraus für die Modernisierung der Handlung entstehen.

5. Conclusion: Das Fazit bündelt die Beobachtungen zu Schauplatz, Figuren und Erzählabsicht und ordnet die Adaption im Verhältnis zur Vorlage ein.

Schlüsselwörter

Jane Austen, Val McDermid, Northanger Abbey, Literaturadaption, Figurenanalyse, Gothic Fiction, Twilight, Romanlektüre, Geschlechterrollen, Figurenbeziehungen, Mediennutzung, soziale Medien, Edinburgh

Häufig gestellte Fragen

Worum geht es in der Arbeit?

Sie vergleicht Jane Austens „Northanger Abbey“ mit Val McDermids zeitgenössischer Adaption desselben Romans.

Welche Themenfelder stehen im Mittelpunkt?

Im Vordergrund stehen die Übertragung der Figuren, Lesegewohnheiten, Geschlechterrollen und die Nutzung neuer Medien.

Was ist das zentrale Ziel der Untersuchung?

Die Arbeit untersucht, wie die Verlagerung ins 21. Jahrhundert die Figuren und ihre Beziehungen verändert.

Welche wissenschaftliche Methode wird verwendet?

Die Autorin beziehungsweise der Autor vergleicht die literarischen Texte anhand ausgewählter Figuren und Motive und bezieht dazu Forschungsliteratur und Rezensionen ein.

Was wird im Hauptteil behandelt?

Der Hauptteil stellt sechs zentrale Figuren der Vorlage ihren Gegenstücken in der Adaption gegenüber und betrachtet anschließend die Rolle der Medien.

Welche Schlüsselwörter charakterisieren die Arbeit?

Zu den Schlüsselwörtern gehören Literaturadaption, Figurenanalyse, Gothic Fiction, Romanlektüre, Geschlechterrollen und Mediennutzung.

Welche Funktion hat die „Twilight“-Reihe im Vergleich?

Die Arbeit untersucht sie als zeitgenössisches Gegenstück zu der Gothic Fiction, die in Austens Roman eine wichtige Rolle spielt.

Welche Figuren werden näher verglichen?

Analysiert werden Catherine Morland, Isabella Thorpe, Eleanor Tilney, Henry Tilney, John Thorpe und General Tilney sowie ihre jeweiligen Entsprechungen bei McDermid.

Welche Bedeutung hat der neue Schauplatz?

Die Arbeit betrachtet die Verlagerung von Bath zum Edinburgh Festival Fringe als Bestandteil der zeitlichen und kulturellen Aktualisierung.

Excerpt out of 22 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Character adaptation in Val McDermid’s retelling of Jane Austen’s "Northanger Abbey"
College
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz  (DEL)
Course
Adaptation and Appropriation
Author
B.A. Elisa Valerie Thieme (Author)
Publication Year
2014
Pages
22
Catalog Number
V283217
ISBN (eBook)
9783656827580
ISBN (Book)
9783656828761
Language
German
Tags
character mcdermid’s jane austen’s northanger abbey
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
B.A. Elisa Valerie Thieme (Author), 2014, Character adaptation in Val McDermid’s retelling of Jane Austen’s "Northanger Abbey", Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/283217
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  22  pages
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Shipping
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract