Grin logo
de en es fr
Shop
GRIN Website
Publicación mundial de textos académicos
Go to shop › Estudios de América - Literatura

Falling Men in the Post-9/11 Novel

Título: Falling Men in the Post-9/11 Novel

Tesis de Máster , 2014 , 58 Páginas , Calificación: 1,5

Autor:in: Master of Arts Nathalie Gerlach (Autor)

Estudios de América - Literatura
Extracto de texto & Detalles   Leer eBook
Resumen Extracto de texto Detalles

Since September 11, 2011, reality has not only outstripped fiction, it’s destroying it. It’s impossible to write about this subject, and yet impossible to write about anything else. Nothing else touches us. (Beigbeder 8)
On an early and sunny Tuesday morning in September 2001 the unimaginable happened, 2973 people were killed in an attack on the World Trade Center in New York City. Within 15 minutes two airplanes hit the Twin Towers and heralded a new age; “the age of terror”. The trauma begins at 8:46 AM local time with the crashing of the first plane into The North Tower. The tower will collapse 102 minutes later. These 102 minutes show images of crashing planes, burning and collapsing towers and people jumping from windows. These images spread around the world and were repeated endlessly, “framing them in the discourses of heroism, patriotism, innocence and trauma” (Däwes 2). The images of 9/11 burned themselves into the memories of contemporary witnesses. On this Tuesday the World Trade Center literally becomes the center of the world. What is happening inside the burning towers remains invisible. Everyone who is located above the crashed planes is left with the choice to burn or to jump. About 200 people throw themselves out of the windows. [...]

Extracto


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.5 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Compares trauma narratives in novels by Beigbeder, Foer and DeLillo
  • Compares Foer’s novel with Stephen Daldry’s 2011 film adaptation
  • 25 sources in the bibliography
  • 9 figures

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

2. Out of the Blue - Trauma

2.1. “There is no Next” – Melancholia in DeLillo’s Falling Man

2.2. “Wearing Heavy Boots” – Mourning in Foer’s Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

3. “You Know How it Ends; Everybody Dies” - Beigbeder’s Windows on the World

3.1. Describing the Indescribable

3.2. “Some Seconds are Longer Than Others” - Timeline of a Catastrophe

3.3. The Higher You Build, The Lower You Fall

4. Falling Men – Images of a National Trauma

4.1. Identity in Don DeLillo’s Falling Man

4.2. “The Photosensitive Surface” – Witnessing the Falling Man

5. The Other

5.1. “Us vs. Them” Display of “the Other” in DeLillo’s Falling Man

5.2. Connecting to the Other in a Post-9/11 World

5.3. Playing Poker

6. Conclusion

Deutsche Zusammenfassung

Objectives and Themes

This thesis examines how three post-9/11 novels represent and respond to individual and collective trauma, asking how depictions of falling people, narrative form and relationships help articulate experiences that resist expression.

  • Trauma theory, melancholia and mourning
  • Comparative readings of novels by Beigbeder, Foer and DeLillo
  • Richard Drew’s Falling Man photograph and the ethics of witnessing
  • Time, imagery and narrative techniques
  • Identity, empathy and the distinction between self and other
  • Foer’s novel and its film adaptation

Excerpt from the Book

3.2. “Some Seconds are Longer Than Others” - Timeline of a Catastrophe

What differentiates Windows on the World from other 9/11 novels mentioned in this thesis, is not only the inside view it allows the reader, but furthermore its unique structure of a timeline. Beigbeder “reconstructs in 120 chapters, the two hours between 8:30 and 10:29 a.m. on September, 2001” (Däwes 33). The novel begins 16 minutes before the first plane hit and ends one minute after the tower, in which Carthew and his two sons are trapped, collapses. There is a clear connection between the horror of this story and the time: “Hell lasts an hour and three quarters. As does this book” (Beigbeder 6). Every page the reader turns brings him/her closer to the impending end. By integrating the time, the author almost sets the countdown to catastrophe and thereby creates an immense suspense, usually experienced in cinema. The cinematic quality of the novel is already hinted at in the title: “some critics claim cinema is a ‘window on the world.’ Others say the novel is. Art is a window on the world” (Beigbeder 240). Undeniably most action movies include a bomb that is about to explode and destroy the world eventually. The bomb timer reminds the protagonist and the viewer of the impending end. Throughout the movie there will be scenes showing the remaining seconds to live, the suspense is almost unbearable. In the end the hero just so happens to deactivate the bomb one second before it was about to go off and saves everybody’s lives. The experience of suspense is basically the same in Beigbeder's novel, the main difference is knowing that in the end “the bomb” does blow off and kills everyone in its direct surrounding. There is not only a connection between the movie and this novel in the means of created suspense, but rather by its time frame as well: “They suffered for 102 minutes, the average running time of a Hollywood film” (63).

Time is essential within the framework of trauma. Trauma itself is defined by an interruption of time. The generally known and accepted measurements of time are invalidated, suddenly “some seconds are longer than others” (2). Trauma theory assumes that people affected by traumatic experiences “find themselves frozen in time” (Versluys 83). 9/11 enduringly affected time. The seconds of the collapse are captured for eternity within media and mental frameworks of witnesses. And suddenly there are the days before and after the planes. “September 11 is presented as an epoch-making event, demarcating a before and an after – a historical caesura that ushers in a new and better order” (145). Beigbeder’s novel, the story of Carthew Yorston, may end at 10:29 a.m. but “September 11 has an afterlife […] The collapse of the towers is not their true ending” (Versluys 127).

Chapter Summaries

1. Introduction: Introduces the attacks, the image of falling people and the three novels. It outlines the thesis’s approach to trauma and its chapter structure.

2. Out of the Blue - Trauma: Presents concepts of trauma, melancholia and mourning, then examines characters in DeLillo’s and Foer’s novels. It also compares Foer’s novel with its film adaptation.

3. “You Know How it Ends; Everybody Dies” - Beigbeder’s Windows on the World: Examines Beigbeder’s fictional account of events inside the World Trade Center, its minute-by-minute structure and the symbolic significance of the towers.

4. Falling Men – Images of a National Trauma: Discusses representations of falling people, Richard Drew’s photograph and the relationship between images, identity and witnessing in DeLillo’s novel.

5. The Other: Explores empathy and exclusion, including DeLillo’s portrayals of terrorists, personal relationships and poker.

6. Conclusion: Brings together the readings of the three novels and considers literature’s role in representing and responding to trauma.

Deutsche Zusammenfassung: Provides a German-language summary of the thesis and its discussion of the three novels.

Keywords

post-9/11 fiction, trauma theory, collective trauma, melancholia, mourning, falling bodies, witnessing, Richard Drew, Don DeLillo, Jonathan Safran Foer, Frédéric Beigbeder, narrative time, otherness, identity

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this thesis about?

It examines representations of the September 11 attacks and their traumatic aftermath in three novels, with particular attention to images of falling people.

What are its central themes?

Its themes include individual and collective trauma, mourning, melancholia, witnessing, narrative time, identity and relationships with others.

What is the main research question?

The thesis asks how post-9/11 novels portray and respond to trauma, including its human dimension as represented by falling people.

What method does the author use?

The author offers comparative literary analysis informed by trauma theory, supported by close readings of novels, a film adaptation and photographic imagery.

What does the main body cover?

It develops the distinction between melancholia and mourning, analyzes the three novels and their imagery, and discusses identity, witnessing and otherness.

Which keywords characterize the work?

Key terms include post-9/11 fiction, trauma, mourning, melancholia, witnessing, falling bodies and otherness.

Which novels are examined?

The thesis examines Frédéric Beigbeder’s Windows on the World, Jonathan Safran Foer’s Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close and Don DeLillo’s Falling Man.

How does the work address photography?

It analyzes Richard Drew’s photograph The Falling Man and considers its composition, reception and relationship to literary depictions of witnessing.

Does the thesis consider a film adaptation?

Yes. It compares Foer’s novel with Stephen Daldry’s adaptation, including their respective uses of images of falling people.

Final del extracto de 58 páginas  - subir

Detalles

Título
Falling Men in the Post-9/11 Novel
Universidad
Humboldt-University of Berlin  (Amerikanistik)
Calificación
1,5
Autor
Master of Arts Nathalie Gerlach (Autor)
Año de publicación
2014
Páginas
58
No. de catálogo
V292973
ISBN (Ebook)
9783656903246
ISBN (Libro)
9783656903253
Idioma
Inglés
Etiqueta
falling post-9/11 novel
Seguridad del producto
GRIN Publishing Ltd.
Citar trabajo
Master of Arts Nathalie Gerlach (Autor), 2014, Falling Men in the Post-9/11 Novel, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/292973
Leer eBook
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
  • Si ve este mensaje, la imagen no pudo ser cargada y visualizada.
Extracto de  58  Páginas
Grin logo
  • Grin.com
  • Envío
  • Contacto
  • Privacidad
  • Aviso legal
  • Imprint
  • Cancelar contrato