For the past decade, the Islamic faith, especially when represented by minority communities living in Western countries, has repeatedly been the subject of heated debate in the political and the public sphere. Its followers are consequently confronted with the predicament of living in accordance to the prescriptions of their faith and being compelled to justify it. In this regard, Islamic adherence could very well be assessed as quite a burden. However, religion and spirituality have long since been recognised as beneficial to the coping process in times of emotional and psychological distress, albeit predominantly in the Christian context. Acknowledging the special situation of Muslims in Western countries , this paper aims to provide an analysis of the situation of Muslims with mental health issues living in a non-Islamic society, namely the multicultural, secular societies of the UK and the USA. It furthermore seeks to establish in what ways the Islamic religion influences the patients‘ outlook on themselves and their choices of treatment. It presumes that anti-Muslim bias, unfortunately widespread in the West, has its impact on its victims‘ psychological well-being. Not merely belonging to a minority group, but one that is continuously hated against, might prove to be a factor that negatively affects the psychological health of Muslims.
Numerous questions are inherently connected with this approach: How does affiliation to Islam influence adherence to treatment regimes? Do Muslims in the West generally oppose biomedicine? Or are biomedical and traditional treatment complementary in the minds of the sick? Does Islam promote behaviour beneficial to mental health or does it rather constitute a risk factor? Does the simple fact of following Islam present Muslims living in the West with conditions harmful to their mental health?
At a glance
- Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Examines the Psychological Measure of Islamic Religiousness in an international study
- Discusses Cinnirella and Loewenthal’s study of Pakistani Muslim participants
- 29 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Mental illness in Islamic and Muslim tradition
3. Mental health stressors
4. Muslims in the US
4.1. Statistics and demographics
4.2. Coping strategies and health care seeking behaviour
5. Muslims in the UK
5.1. Statistics and demographics
5.2. Coping strategies and health care seeking behaviour
6. Conclusion
Aims and Themes
This work examines how Islam influences the mental health, perceptions of illness and treatment choices of Muslims living in the United States and the United Kingdom. Drawing on existing research, it considers how religious beliefs interact with cultural practices, discrimination and access to mental health care.
- Islamic and Muslim understandings of mental illness and healing
- Discrimination, social exclusion and psychological stress
- Demographic and social contexts in the United States and United Kingdom
- Religious coping and traditional healing practices
- Attitudes towards professional mental health services
- Relationships between faith, culture and health care decisions
Excerpt from the Book
4.2. Coping strategies and health care seeking behaviour
“Many American Muslims, then, construct their ‘clinical reality‘ in relation to Islam, and their Islam-informed explanatory model determines whether, when, and how to seek help from conventional allopathic medicine (professional domain) and when to seek help from more explicitly Islam-based modes of healing (folk and popular domains).“
These folk and popular domains according to Padela and Curlin comprise the guidance of Islamic clerics and rituals involving herbal medicine, potions and prayer. Although relevant data have not been collected yet, it can be safely assumed that most Muslims would turn to these sources of help before considering Western medicine as an option. As soon as the situation arises that a Muslim wants to seek professional counselling or therapy in order to treat his or her mental illness, another challenge comes up; in the US, “formal services or agencies tailored for the needs of Muslim clients are severely lacking“, probably resulting in many cases remaining untreated. Secular therapists would be considered unfit to tend to the specific needs of Muslims. Disclosing a firm belief in the presence of angels and malevolent spirits might lead the untrained clinician to misdiagnose the Muslim patient as psychotic, a consequence most Muslims would be aware of. It is highly probable that treatment happens in a more informal context with imams taking care of their clients‘ grievances, much as is common in Muslim countries, yet officially impossible in the US where different standards need to be met in order to qualify as a mental health professional.
It is unsurprising, then, that Muslim immigrants make disproportionately less use of formal mental health services. This is in part due to a mistrust of Western counsellors and the general mental health system. This mistrust is nurtured not only by the experience of discrimination, but also by the encouragement in the family and community to deal with psychological ailments without Western help. Furthermore, the fear of social stigma prevents the utilisation of professional services. Since the belief in supernatural causes of mental illness is prevalent among Arab-Muslims, e.g., a preference for religious help in form of faith healers and traditional remedies stands to reason. In one of the most recent studies concerned with the mental health care seeking behaviour of American Muslims, a majority reported preference of family members (21%) or religious authorities (19%) over Western trained professionals (11%). Thus is revealed the Muslim “perception of mental health illness as a ‘private family matter‘.“ Although imams customarily deal with the mental problems within their community, they have usually not undergone proper training.
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The author sets out the research questions and explains the focus on Muslims living in the United States and the United Kingdom. The chapter introduces existing scholarship and outlines the work’s approach.
2. Mental illness in Islamic and Muslim tradition: This chapter discusses religious and cultural understandings of mental illness, including spiritual, supernatural and biological explanations. It also considers Islamic and traditional approaches to healing.
3. Mental health stressors: The author explores potential psychological pressures associated with discrimination, social exclusion and conflicts surrounding identity and religious practice. The discussion is identified as partly speculative.
4. Muslims in the US: This chapter reviews demographic information and research on American Muslims’ coping strategies and approaches to mental health care. It considers stigma, religious support and barriers to professional services.
5. Muslims in the UK: The author examines demographic and social contexts before discussing studies of British Muslims’ beliefs about mental illness and their intentions to seek help. Particular attention is given to research involving people of South Asian origin.
6. Conclusion: The final chapter draws together the discussion of religious, cultural and social influences on mental health and treatment decisions. It also considers the limitations of the research reviewed and the need for further study.
Keywords
Islam, Muslim mental health, United States, United Kingdom, mental illness, religious coping, health care seeking, discrimination, stigma, traditional healing, psychological services, acculturation, cultural diversity
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It examines the relationship between Islam and the mental health and treatment decisions of Muslims living in the United States and the United Kingdom.
What are the central themes?
The work addresses beliefs about mental illness, religious and traditional healing, discrimination, social context and the use of professional mental health services.
What is the primary research question?
The central question is how Islamic beliefs and practices influence Muslims’ perceptions of mental health and their choices of treatment in Western societies.
What research method does the author use?
The author reviews and discusses existing academic literature and studies, including research on mental health beliefs and health care seeking in the United States and the United Kingdom.
What does the main body cover?
It considers Islamic and Muslim traditions, potential mental health stressors, and the demographic contexts and health care seeking practices of Muslims in each of the two countries.
Which keywords characterise the work?
Key terms include Islam, Muslim mental health, religious coping, discrimination, stigma, traditional healing and health care seeking.
How does the work distinguish Islamic teachings from cultural practices?
It notes that some healing practices common among Muslim communities are rooted in cultural traditions rather than Islamic texts, and that practices can differ between communities.
What role does izzat play in the discussion of British Muslims?
The work discusses izzat as a South Asian concept connected with family honour and examines research on its relationship to intentions to seek psychological help.
How does the work address religious and professional care?
It considers religious authorities, prayer and traditional healing alongside professional mental health services, including the possibility that different approaches may be used together.
- Citar trabajo
- Nejla Demirkaya (Autor), 2014, The Influence of Islam on the Mental Health of Muslims living in the West, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/293786