At first sight, postcolonial theories and Gothic writing appear to have barely features in common. On the one hand, Gothic as a genre flourished with Horace Walpole's novel The Castle of Otranto in 1764, which celebrated irrationality and explored "feelings, desires and passions which compromised the Enlightenment project of rationally calibrating all forms of knowledge and behaviours" (Smith and Hughes 1).
In the succeeding decades, numerous writers trail Walpole by publishing their individual Gothic novels, e.g. Matthew Gregory Lewis' The Monk, Bram Stoker's Dracula, and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein; Or, the Modern Prometheus. On the other hand, studies in colonialist discourse contemplate colonialisation and its aftermath on individuals, communities and cultures, emerging in the late 1970s as essence of literary criticism. Although both genres appear to focus on antithetic research domains considering time references as well as contexts, they still share their enthusiasm in questioning conceptions of rationality. Therefore, both study areas challenge issues, of which humans are incapable to explain. Thereby, the creation of an 'Other' is crucial.
On the one hand, postcolonial and colonial domains challenge and attempt at standing reason for the clash of cultures with which colonisers and colonised people are confronted. On the other hand, emphasising the idea of transgression, Gothic fiction inhabits images of the Other as well, illustrating anew the impossibility for explanation.
Joseph Conrad published his short story "An Outpost of Progress" in 1897 and collected it to his work Tales of Unrest in 1898. "An Outpost of Progress" has become subject to crucial criticism of imperialism, colonialisation and civilisation, by describing the story of two white men, Kayerts and Carlier, who are in charge of a trading post in the Congo cabin. Consequently, the story represents the difficulties between two oppositional cultures and the effects of this encounter. Considering the dark ambience created throughout the story, this short story can be analysed in terms of a postcolonial gothic reading. This paper aims, therefore, to outline main reasons why this short story accords with characteristics of a postcolonial and colonial gothic reading.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Applies postcolonial and Gothic approaches to Conrad’s short story
- Examines the Gothic significance of graves and crosses
- 22 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Theoretical Approach: Postcolonial Gothic
2.1 (Post-) Colonialism
2.2 Gothic Fiction
2.3 Otherness / ‘Othering’
3. Joseph Conrad’s “An Outpost Of Progress”
3.1 Postcolonial Discourse
3.2 The Gothic in the Short Story
4. Conclusion – A Postcolonial Gothic Reading
Objectives and Themes
This paper asks how Joseph Conrad’s “An Outpost of Progress” can be read through the combined perspectives of postcolonial and Gothic criticism. It develops a framework around colonialism, Gothic fiction and Othering, then applies it to the story’s characters, setting and imagery.
- Colonialism, postcolonialism and European imperial discourse
- Gothic atmosphere, transgression and the sublime
- Otherness and the construction of cultural difference
- Representation and hierarchy at the trading post
- Landscape, darkness and fear in Conrad’s story
Excerpt from the Book
Otherness / ‘Othering’
In accordance with Gina Wisker and Tabish Khair, (Post-) Colonial studies and Gothic fiction overlap in the theory of ‘Othering’ or ‘Otherness’, meaning the process of categorising a group, an individual or an object as the ‘Other’. In Wisker’s view, the theory of ‘Othering’ “exclude[s] and destroy[s] or recognize[s] the rich differences of an Other we construct in order to somehow feel clearer and more secure about our own stable identities” (“Postcolonial Gothic” 169). Tabish Khair argues “the Other is seen as a Self waiting to be assimilated … or the Other is cast as the purely negative image of the European Self, the obverse of the Self” (4). Hence, the Other is characterised by its inferiority towards the European identity. Bill Ashcroft et al. generalise the term of the Other as “anyone who is separate from one’s self”, underlining the crucial necessity of having an Other in order to develop one’s identity by deciding what is ‘normal’ as well as to find one’s place in the world (169). In general, the process of Othering has been applied particularly to post-colonial studies, depicting the Empire’s ability in creating non-Europeans as the Other due to the Europeans’ inability or intolerance in accepting the extraordinary cultural differences (ibid. 170). Further, scholar Stuart Hall agrees with the portrayal of the colonised people as the Other, examining the core of the Other as a construction built to emphasise the absolute opposite to Western norms (cf. 314). Consequently, a crucial differentiation between black and white people derive out of the depiction of the ‘dark’ side as the Other, describing the Western empire as the prototype and master of civilisation. However, this idea of superiority encounters crucially with the essence of enlightenment and modernity (ibid.). While in Postcolonialism the Other is described as someone from a foreign colony, Gothic fiction writers reinforce the idea of the Other by introducing supernatural or mysterious characters such as exemplarily the Devil, ghosts, vampires, lunatics or madwomen (cf. Khair 6). Unsurprisingly, Khair characterises Gothic novels not only as medium to transgress borders but also as a way of “writing of Otherness” (5). In fact, readers may be in a position to dichotomise the novel into ‘abnormal’ and unknown, on the one side, and ‘normal’ and familiar, on the other side, by analysing the individual elements and characters. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus exemplifies the concept of marginalization and strangeness, ensuing in the realisation of Othering the creature. Therefore, every Gothic novel entailing any kind of strange events or creatures confirms the existence of the Other as well as the process of Othering.
Chapter Summaries
Introduction: The introduction presents the relationship between postcolonial criticism and Gothic writing and sets out the paper’s approach to Conrad’s short story.
Theoretical Approach: Postcolonial Gothic: This chapter outlines colonial and postcolonial studies, Gothic fiction and the concept of Othering as a shared point of reference.
Joseph Conrad’s “An Outpost Of Progress”: The chapter reads the story through postcolonial discourse and Gothic devices, examining representations of characters, hierarchy, landscape and atmosphere.
Conclusion – A Postcolonial Gothic Reading: The conclusion brings the theoretical and textual discussions together to evaluate the story as a postcolonial Gothic reading.
Keywords
Joseph Conrad, An Outpost of Progress, postcolonial Gothic, colonialism, postcolonialism, Gothic fiction, Othering, imperialism, colonial discourse, the sublime, literary analysis, Gothic imagery
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It offers a postcolonial Gothic reading of Joseph Conrad’s short story “An Outpost of Progress.”
What are its central themes?
The paper considers colonialism, Gothic fiction, Otherness, imperial discourse and representations of cultural difference.
What is the paper’s primary aim?
It aims to explain why Conrad’s story can be read in postcolonial and colonial Gothic terms.
What method does the paper use?
It develops a theoretical framework from postcolonial and Gothic scholarship and applies it through literary analysis of the short story.
What does the main analysis examine?
It examines colonial discourse, the portrayal of characters and hierarchy, and Gothic features of the story’s setting and imagery.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include postcolonial Gothic, colonialism, Othering, imperialism, the sublime and Gothic imagery.
How does the paper connect postcolonial studies and Gothic fiction?
It uses Othering to explore how both fields represent what is perceived as unfamiliar or outside established norms.
Which Gothic devices does the discussion of Conrad’s story consider?
It considers graves and crosses, descriptions of landscape, claustrophobia, mist, fear and the sublime.
How does the paper approach Makola’s role?
It examines his position at the trading post and the relationship between his authority and that of the two European employees.
- Citar trabajo
- Janine Evangelista (Autor), 2018, Joseph Conrad's short story "An outpost of progress". A (post-)colonial Gothic reading, Múnich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/415809