Often in history, people change their opinion about important historical figures. Statesmen despised by their people are often admired soon after their death or even right after they are deselected. People revered during their lifetime have become outcasts after historical facts turned up that proving they were failures or even felons. Winston Churchill, British Prime Minister from 1940 to 1945 and from 1951 to 1955, has experienced both during lifetime. Before Winston Churchill became British Prime Minister, some people called him a “brilliant abnegator.“ But his courageous fight against Hitler during World War II had a lasting effect on Churchill’s reputation, and in the years after the war he was almost transfigured. Incredibly much has been written about Churchill as a politician, statesman, strategist and historian, a man with indomitable zest for action, a brilliant mind and a hot temper. As a consequence from the personality cult of his time, he was declared the “Anti-Hitler.“ John Charmley, a Churchill biographer, writes that „Churchill stood for the British Empire, for British independence and for an “anti-socialist vision of Britain.“ Yet not every aspect of his long and eventful life is viewed positively today: Charmley also points out that all Churchill had contributed to the European idea was “hardly more than an impressive speech.“ Churchill’s order to bomb civil residential areas of German cities in WWII to demoralize the people and to take revenge on the Germans for air raids on Coventry and London is seen as critically as his involvement in decisions that led to the to the expulsion on 12.4 million people after WWII. Yet most people agree that Churchill’s unbendingness saved the lives of millions of people. Other biographers often emphasized his racist attitudes, although these were still common among Europeans until the late 1950s. Churchill was convinced of the White - not to say Anglo-Saxon - supremacy. Most interestingly, under his government Britain started becoming a multicultural society. The same goes for the principles of eugenics, which he was convinced of, but which were also widespread among contemporaries. However, he also talked about the Jews as „the most impressive and remarkable race that has ever appeared on earth,“ which contrasts him from ideological racists of his time as well as the fact that many biographers mention his magnanimity as his predominant character trait. [...]
At a glance
- Grade: 1.7 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Includes a proposed 12-question survey; no actual survey was conducted
- Examines Churchill’s portrayal in British newspaper website articles
Table of Contents
I. Introduction
I.1 Churchill's reputation
I.2 Why I wrote this paper
II. Historical Facts about Churchill
II.1 A short biography
II.2 Prime Minister Churchill and his role in World War II
II.3 The years after the war and his second term as Prime Minister
III. How is Churchill depicted in British Media today?
III.1 Usability of different newspaper web sites
III.2 The recent depiction of Churchill in British print media
IV. What do you think about Churchill? – a sample questionnaire for a survey in Britain
IV.1 Explanation of the questionnaire and its different questions
IV.2 Possible results of a survey
V. Conclusion
V.1 Summary of the results
V.2 My opinion about Churchill's reputation
VII. A sample questionnaire for a survey in Britain
Objectives and Themes
This paper explores how Winston Churchill is regarded in Britain, asking whether he remains admired and how British newspapers portray him. It combines a historical overview and an examination of newspaper coverage with a proposed questionnaire for a future survey.
- Churchill’s political career and wartime leadership
- His reputation and contested aspects of his legacy
- Representations of Churchill in British newspapers
- Access to online newspaper archives
- A proposed survey of British views and knowledge
Excerpt from the Book
IV. What do you think about Churchill? – A sample questionnaire for a survey in Britain
The first question requires personal data. By evaluating the questionnaire results considering age, gender and political conviction I can find out how different groups within the population (e.g. women, seniors, or liberals) value Churchill today, since I expect considerable differences among the different groups.
In question 2 a) I ask all participants if they have ever heard of Winston Churchill or not. Before the first question, I ask the participants to answer the questions in the correct order. I did not do so because I am German, but because all participants who answer this question with “No“ are practically finished at this point, as they will be unable to answer the questions following. Yet I expect this rate to be far below 5% of all participants, since Churchill still seems to be remarkably present in contemporary Britain, not to say “common knowledge.“ Question 2 b) then serves to analyze where the participants got their information about Churchill from.
In the third question people are asked to write down whatever comes to their mind when they think of Churchill. This is a test question the answers of which can show whether the participants have in-depth knowledge about Churchill (answers include concrete dates, special information, quotes etc.), or marginal knowledge and stereotypes (cigar, V-sign, “No Sports!“, Prime Minister etc), or no knowledge at all (wrong answers, no associations.)
Question 4) is for the same purpose as question three. By evaluating the answers I can estimate whether there is distinct knowledge about Churchill or not. Here again it is important that the participants answer the question in the correct order (the best possible way to ensure this would be a computer based questionnaire that shows one question at a time.)
While questions 1 to 4 served rather to categorize the participants, all other questions ask for the participants’ concrete opinion about certain aspects of Churchill’s life. Questions 5), 6) and 7) question his behavior during WWII. The participants are asked to give their opinions whether Churchill’s way to take action against Germany was right or not, including the question whether the air raids on German cities were justified. All three questions can be answered with “Yes“ or “No,“ (question 7) also with “Partly“) but also with “I can’t say“ because I expect that some people will not find a definite answer to every question.
Chapter Summaries
I. Introduction: The author introduces contrasting assessments of Churchill and explains the question that prompted the paper: whether Churchill is still admired in Britain.
II. Historical Facts about Churchill: This chapter traces Churchill’s political career, his wartime leadership and his second term as prime minister.
III. How is Churchill depicted in British Media today? The author discusses access to newspaper websites and examines examples of how British articles refer to and assess Churchill.
IV. What do you think about Churchill? – a sample questionnaire for a survey in Britain: The author explains the proposed survey questions and discusses how responses might be evaluated.
V. Conclusion: The paper brings together its discussion of Churchill’s reputation and presents the author’s own assessment of his historical role.
VII. A sample questionnaire for a survey in Britain: The questionnaire presents questions about respondents’ knowledge of Churchill, their views of his actions and their assessment of his historical importance.
Keywords
Winston Churchill, British public opinion, British newspapers, political reputation, World War II, wartime leadership, historical memory, newspaper archives, survey design, questionnaire, political biography, British history
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this paper about?
It examines Winston Churchill’s reputation in Britain through a historical overview, examples from British newspapers and a proposed public-opinion questionnaire.
What are its central themes?
The paper addresses Churchill’s political career, wartime leadership, contested legacy, media portrayal and potential differences in public opinion.
What is the main research question?
The author asks how British people think about Churchill and whether he remains admired.
What method does the author use?
The author draws on biographical literature and searches British newspaper websites for references to Churchill. The paper also designs a questionnaire, but does not report a completed survey.
What does the main body cover?
It presents a short biography, examines examples of newspaper coverage and explains the proposed questionnaire and possible ways to evaluate responses.
Which keywords characterize the paper?
Key terms include Winston Churchill, British public opinion, World War II, political reputation, newspaper coverage and survey design.
What does the proposed questionnaire ask?
Its 12 questions address respondents’ backgrounds, knowledge and associations, views of Churchill’s wartime actions, explanations for election outcomes and assessments of his importance.
Which newspapers feature in the media discussion?
The author discusses material from newspapers including The Guardian, The Independent and The Herald, alongside the accessibility of their online archives.
Was the proposed survey carried out?
No. The author explains that the questionnaire was designed for a possible future survey in Britain.
- Quote paper
- Bernd Blasius (Author), 2003, "The Man Who Saved the World"? - How the British Think About Winston Churchill Today, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/58293