‘A tree must be bent while it is young.’ (Proverb)
Proverbs usually have an element of truth. The German speakers will certainly also know the German equivalent ‘Was Hänschen nicht lernt, lernt Hans nimmermehr.’ Do these proverbs also apply to the acquisition of a second language? Are young learners trees that ‘must be bent’ before they are too old to reach a certain language proficiency?
In first and second language research, the concept of a ‘critical period’ respectively of a ‘sensitive period’ was developed to explain probable advantages of children in the process of language acquisition. The aim of this term paper is to find out whether there is a sensitive period for second language learning and to explore possible explanatory approaches.
Within this research, the ‘Critical Period Hypothesis’ (CPH) represents the major focus. According to this hypothesis, “there is a period during which language acquisition is easy and complete (i.e. native-speaker ability is achieved) and beyond which it is difficult and typically incomplete” (ELLIS, 1997: 67). This means, it is assumed that language learners must begin at an early age to learn a language in order to reach native-like proficiency.
Generally, empirical data from course books, handbook articles and journal articles as well as commentaries by different authors are used in order to follow the research question up. First, a framework concerning the origins of the idea of a sensitive period from first language acquisition, and the clarification of particular terms will be created. Then, the distinction between possible advantages of young learners in natural as well as instructional settings will be of interest.
The findings on a critical or sensitive period have also found their ways into the pedagogical practice. It is obvious that especially bilingual kindergartens, that promote an early start in language learning in general, will somehow refer to the idea of a sensitive period in second language acquisition. Therefore, the second part of this term paper will present an analysis of pedagogical concepts of these kinds of day care institutions with respect to the integration of this idea. Website information of different bilingual kindergartens will serve as sources.
Inhaltsverzeichnis (Table of Contents)
- Introduction
- The origins of the notion of a sensitive period in second language acquisition
- Selected studies on the Critical and Sensitive Period Hypothesis In second language acquisition
- Delimitation of terms
- Critical versus sensitive period
- Initial learning rate versus ultimate attainment
- The sensitive period in natural settings
- Empirical results
- Explanatory approaches
- The sensitive period in instructional settings
- The notion of a sensitive period in pedagogical concepts of bilingual kindergartens
- Method
- Results of the Analysis
- Conclusion
Zielsetzung und Themenschwerpunkte (Objectives and Key Themes)
This term paper aims to investigate whether there is a sensitive period for second language learning and to explore possible explanatory approaches. It delves into the 'Critical Period Hypothesis' (CPH) and examines empirical evidence from various sources, including textbooks, research articles, and commentaries. The paper also explores the application of the sensitive period concept in the pedagogical context of bilingual kindergartens.
- The Critical Period Hypothesis (CPH) and its implications for second language learning
- The role of age in language acquisition and its impact on ultimate attainment
- Different explanatory approaches for the sensitive period in second language acquisition
- The application of the sensitive period concept in bilingual kindergarten settings
- The relationship between brain plasticity and language learning
Zusammenfassung der Kapitel (Chapter Summaries)
- Introduction: Introduces the concept of a sensitive period for second language learning, drawing a parallel with the proverb "A tree must be bent while it is young." The paper outlines the research question and the focus on the Critical Period Hypothesis (CPH).
- The origins of the notion of a sensitive period in second language acquisition: Traces the roots of the sensitive period concept back to research on first language acquisition and the work of neuroscientists Penfield and Roberts. It discusses the role of brain lateralization and the concept of plasticity in language learning.
- Selected studies on the Critical and Sensitive Period Hypothesis In second language acquisition: Delves into the definition of key terms like "critical period" and "sensitive period," and explains the difference between "initial learning rate" and "ultimate attainment." It explores empirical evidence for the sensitive period in both natural and instructional settings.
- The notion of a sensitive period in pedagogical concepts of bilingual kindergartens: Examines how the concept of a sensitive period is reflected in the pedagogical practices of bilingual kindergartens. The chapter explores the methods and results of analyzing websites of bilingual kindergartens.
Schlüsselwörter (Keywords)
The key terms and concepts explored in this paper include: Critical Period Hypothesis (CPH), sensitive period, second language acquisition, brain lateralization, brain plasticity, age of onset, ultimate attainment, initial learning rate, bilingual kindergartens, pedagogical concepts, and empirical research.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Annegret Gelbrecht (Autor:in), 2011, Is there a sensitive period in second language learning?, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.grin.com/document/177551
